可复性腹壁疝:诊断即修补与观察等待的临床结局及成本效果
结果显示诊断即修补极具成本效果,开放与腹腔镜的选择取决于手术成本与术后生活质量;围术期死亡率或年复发率超过特定阈值时观察等待更优。
要点
- 诊断即修补可复性腹壁疝极具成本效果。
- 开放与腹腔镜修补的选择取决于手术成本和术后生活质量。
- 围术期死亡率高或复发风险高者,观察等待更可取。
核心结论
- 诊断即修补可复性腹壁疝极具成本效果,开放与腹腔镜之间的选择取决于手术成本与术后生活质量。
- 围术期死亡率高或复发风险高的患者,观察等待更可取。
研究设计与样本
- 队列特征(平均年龄58岁,女性63%)、医院成本与围术期死亡率来自全国住院患者样本(2003-2011),其他概率、成本与效用值来自文献。
- 采用意愿支付阈值$50,000/QALY,并进行随机与概率敏感性分析以识别影响最优管理的参数阈值。
主要发现
- 观察等待策略下,39%最终需要修补(其中14%为急诊修补),24%复发。
- 诊断即修补策略下,70%复发。
- 诊断即腹腔镜修补与诊断即开放修补相比具有成本效果(增量成本效果比$27,700/QALY)。
- 手术策略(开放与腹腔镜)的选择对成本和术后生活质量敏感。
- 当围术期死亡率超过5.2%或年复发率超过19.2%时,观察等待成为首选。
关键数值与推荐
- 观察等待:39%最终修补,14%急诊修补,24%复发。
- 诊断即修补:70%复发。
- 腹腔镜 vs 开放诊断即修补的增量成本效果比为$27,700/QALY。
- 围术期死亡率>5.2%或年复发率>19.2%时,观察等待更优。
- 意愿支付阈值为$50,000/QALY。
临床怎么用
- 对可复性腹壁疝可考虑诊断即修补,因其具成本效果。
- 开放与腹腔镜的选择应结合手术成本与术后生活质量。
- 围术期死亡率或复发风险高的患者可优先观察等待。
局限性
- 研究为微模拟模型预测,结论依赖模型假设与文献来源参数。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare long-term clinical and economic outcomes associated with 3 management strategies for reducible ventral hernia: repair at diagnosis (open or laparoscopic) and watchful waiting. BACKGROUND: There is variability in ventral hernia management. Recent data suggest watchful waiting is safe; however, long-term clinical and economic outcomes for different management strategies remain unknown. METHODS: We built a state-transition microsimulation model to forecast outcomes for individuals with reducible ventral hernia, simulating a cohort of 1 million individuals for each strategy. We derived cohort characteristics (mean age 58 years, 63% female), hospital costs, and perioperative mortality from the Nationwide Inpatient Sample (2003-2011), and additional probabilities, costs, and utilities from the literature. Outcomes included prevalence of any repair, emergent repair, and recurrence; lifetime costs; quality-adjusted life years (QALYs); and incremental cost-effectiveness ratios. We performed stochastic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses to identify parameter thresholds that affect optimal management, using a willingness-to-pay threshold of $50,000/QALY. RESULTS: With watchful waiting, 39% ultimately required repair (14% emergent) and 24% recurred. Seventy per cent recurred with repair at diagnosis. Laparoscopic repair at diagnosis was cost-effective compared with open repair at diagnosis (incremental cost-effectiveness ratio $27,700/QALY). The choice of operative strategy (open vs laparoscopic) was sensitive to cost and postoperative quality of life. When perioperative mortality exceeded 5.2% or yearly recurrence exceeded 19.2%, watchful waiting became preferred. CONCLUSIONS: Ventral hernia repair at diagnosis is very cost-effective. The choice between open and laparoscopic repair depends on surgical costs and postoperative quality of life. In patients with high risk of perioperative mortality or recurrence, watchful waiting is preferred.
引用
- Wolf LL, Ejiofor JI, Wang Y, et al. Management of Reducible Ventral Hernias: Clinical Outcomes and Cost-effectiveness of Repair at Diagnosis Versus Watchful Waiting. Ann Surg. 2019. PMID: 29194083. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000002507
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。