外科会诊作为社会过程:对共享决策的启示
该定性研究观察3名普通外科医生与45名考虑腹股沟疝修补或胆囊切除术患者的会诊,并访谈医患双方。发现会诊前事件使医患倾向特定决策,会诊中医生对手术干预的仲裁能力及对病情严重性的建构存在差异,常使基于风险/获益的知情讨论边缘化。结论提示决策模型应考虑更广的时空跨度,共享决策可能高估患者改变决策进程的能力。
要点
- 会诊前事件已使医患倾向特定决策,影响会诊中的讨论。
- 医生对手术干预的仲裁能力和病情严重性建构存在差异。
- 基于风险/获益的知情讨论常被上游动态边缘化。
核心结论
- 决策模型应纳入会诊前事件等更广的时空因素。
- 共享决策可能高估患者在专科医生办公室内改变决策进程的能力。
- 需研究以风险/获益讨论为焦点的决策辅助工具如何改变决策的社会过程。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究,观察3名普通外科医生与45名考虑腹股沟疝修补或胆囊切除术患者的会诊,并对医患进行半结构化访谈。
主要发现
- 会诊前事件使医患倾向特定决策。
- 医生对手术干预的仲裁能力及对病情严重性的建构存在差异。
- 上游动态常使基于风险/获益的知情讨论边缘化。
临床怎么用
- 外科医生应意识到会诊前事件对决策的预设影响。
- 在会诊中主动为风险/获益讨论保留核心位置。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: This qualitative study examines surgical consultation as a social process and assesses its alignment with assumptions of the shared decision-making (SDM) model. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: SDM stresses the importance of patient preferences and rigorous discussion of therapeutic risks/benefits based on these preferences. However, empirical studies have highlighted discrepancies between SDM and realities of surgical decision making. Qualitative research can inform understanding of the decision-making process and allow for granular assessment of the nature and causes of these discrepancies. METHODS: We observed consultations between 3 general surgeons and 45 patients considering undergoing 1 of 2 preference-sensitive elective operations: (1) hernia repair, or (2) cholecystectomy. These patients and surgeons also participated in semi-structured interviews. RESULTS: By the time of the consultation, patients and surgeons were predisposed toward certain decisions by preceding events occurring elsewhere. During the visit, surgeons had differential ability to arbitrate surgical intervention and construct the severity of patients' conditions. These upstream dynamics frequently displaced the centrality of the risk/benefit-based consent discussion. CONCLUSION: The influence of events preceding consultation suggests that decision-making models should account for broader spatiotemporal spans. Given surgeons' authority to define patients' conditions and control service provision, SDM may be premised on an overestimation of patients' power to alter the course of decision making once in a specialist's office. Considering the subordinate role of the risk/benefit discussion in many surgical decisions, it will be important to study if and how the social process of decision making is altered by SDM-oriented decision aids that foreground this discussion.
引用
- Clapp JT, Arriaga AF, Murthy S, et al. Surgical Consultation as Social Process: Implications for Shared Decision Making. Ann Surg. 2019. PMID: 29240006. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000002610
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。