决策分析模型在外科研究中的价值:腹腔镜与开腹远端胰腺切除术的示例
该研究通过决策树模型比较腹腔镜远端胰腺切除术(LDP)与开腹远端胰腺切除术(ODP)治疗非恶性病变的成本效果。
要点
- 即使LDP 30天死亡率高1.79倍、中转率62.2%等不利场景,LDP仍更具成本效果。
- 减小不确定性未改变结论,针对并发症等的随机试验极不可能推翻现有结论。
核心结论
- 基于当前证据,LDP治疗非恶性病变比ODP更具成本效果,且针对并发症、住院时间、费用、生活质量和生存的随机临床试验极不可能改变该结论。
研究设计与样本
- 研究构建决策树模型模拟非恶性病变行LDP或ODP的临床路径,分析基于并发症、住院时间、费用、生活质量和生存的成本效果。
主要发现
- 模型显示LDP相比ODP更具成本效果。
- 使LDP不具成本优势的场景不现实,如LDP后30天死亡率是ODP的1.79倍、中转率62.2%、LDP后切口疝手术修复率21%、LDP后平均住院时间比ODP长2.3天。
- 考虑所有不确定性后LDP仍更具成本效果,且最小化这些不确定性未改变结果。
关键数值与推荐
- LDP后30天死亡率为ODP的1.79倍时,LDP仍具成本效果。
- LDP中转率62.2%时,LDP仍具成本效果。
- LDP后切口疝手术修复率21%时,LDP仍具成本效果。
- LDP后平均住院时间比ODP长2.3天时,LDP仍具成本效果。
临床怎么用
- 决策分析建模可帮助识别外科研究中的相关不确定性,并指导未来研究方向的确定。
- 对于非恶性病变的远端胰腺切除,当前证据下LDP是更具成本效果的选择。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To illustrate how decision modeling may identify relevant uncertainty and can preclude or identify areas of future research in surgery. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: To optimize use of research resources, a tool is needed that assists in identifying relevant uncertainties and the added value of reducing these uncertainties. METHODS: The clinical pathway for laparoscopic distal pancreatectomy (LDP) versus open (ODP) for nonmalignant lesions was modeled in a decision tree. Cost-effectiveness based on complications, hospital stay, costs, quality of life, and survival was analyzed. The effect of existing uncertainty on the cost-effectiveness was addressed, as well as the expected value of eliminating uncertainties. RESULTS: Based on 29 nonrandomized studies (3.701 patients) the model shows that LDP is more cost-effective compared with ODP. Scenarios in which LDP does not outperform ODP for cost-effectiveness seem unrealistic, e.g., a 30-day mortality rate of 1.79 times higher after LDP as compared with ODP, conversion in 62.2%, surgically repair of incisional hernias in 21% after LDP, or an average 2.3 days longer hospital stay after LDP than after ODP. Taking all uncertainty into account, LDP remained more cost-effective. Minimizing these uncertainties did not change the outcome. CONCLUSIONS: The results show how decision analytical modeling can help to identify relevant uncertainty and guide decisions for future research in surgery. Based on the current available evidence, a randomized clinical trial on complications, hospital stay, costs, quality of life, and survival is highly unlikely to change the conclusion that LDP is more cost-effective than ODP.
引用
- Tax C, Govaert PHM, Stommel MWJ, et al. The Value of Decision Analytical Modeling in Surgical Research: An Example of Laparoscopic Versus Open Distal Pancreatectomy. Ann Surg. 2019. PMID: 29099396. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000002553
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。