机器人腹壁疝修补术并不优于腹腔镜:一项全国数据库回顾
该回顾性数据库研究纳入2013年1月至2015年9月接受腹壁疝修补术的46799例患者,比较开放、腹腔镜与机器人三种术式的结局。结果显示开放手术并发症、再入院、住院时间和术后阿片类药物使用均最高,机器人手术并发症和术后感染率高于腹腔镜,但死亡率、再入院、住院时间和术后止痛药使用无差异;机器人手术直接成本最高。
要点
- 开放腹壁疝修补术的并发症、再入院、住院时间和术后疼痛用药均高于腹腔镜和机器人。
- 机器人腹壁疝修补术的并发症和术后感染率高于腹腔镜,短期结局无优势。
- 机器人手术直接成本最高,腹腔镜最低。
核心结论
- 腹腔镜和机器人腹壁疝修补术的总体患者结局优于开放手术。
- 机器人腹壁疝修补术在短期结局或阿片类药物使用方面较腹腔镜无显著改善。
- 机器人手术成本最高,开放手术成本也显著高于腹腔镜。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性全国数据库(Vizient)查询研究,纳入2013年1月至2015年9月接受腹壁疝修补术的46799例患者。
- 开放组39505例,腹腔镜组6829例,机器人组465例,各组人口学特征相似。
主要发现
- 开放手术较机器人或腹腔镜显著增加总体并发症、30天再入院、住院时间和术后疼痛用药。
- 开放手术死亡率和术后感染率高于腹腔镜。
- 机器人手术并发症和术后感染率显著高于腹腔镜,但死亡率、30天再入院、住院时间和术后疼痛用药无差异。
- 手术平均直接成本机器人最高,其次开放,腹腔镜最低。
临床怎么用
- 腹壁疝修补术优先考虑腹腔镜入路,因其短期结局优于开放且成本最低。
- 机器人腹壁疝修补术不应常规替代腹腔镜,除非有特定临床指征。
- 开放腹壁疝修补术与更高的并发症、再入院和住院时间相关,应谨慎选择。
局限性
- 无法评估长期复发数据,需进一步研究以确定机器人在腹壁疝修补术中的作用和复发率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Minimally invasive surgery (MIS) use for ventral hernia repair has increased over the last decade. Whether outcomes are improved by robotic assistance remains a subject of debate. The aim of this study is to evaluate outcomes (including cost, complications, length of stay (LOS), and pain medication utilization) in patients who underwent an open (OVHR), laparoscopic (LVHR), or robotic (RVHR) ventral hernia repair (VHR). METHODS: The Vizient database was queried using ICD-9 procedure and diagnosis codes for patients who underwent VHR from January 2013 to September 2015. Complications, 30-day readmission, mortality, LOS, cost, and intra-hospital opiate utilization were analyzed using IBM SPSS v.23.0.0.0. Median tests with post hoc pairwise comparisons, Fischer's exact, and Pearson's chi-squared test with Bonferroni correction were applied where appropriate, with α = 0.05. RESULTS: 46,799 patients (OVHR: N = 39,505, LVHR: N = 6829, RVHR: N = 465) met the criteria and patients in each group had similar demographics (Table 1). OVHR was associated with significant increased overall complications, 30-day readmission, LOS, and postoperative pain use compared to RVHR or LVHR. OVHR had higher mortality and postoperative infection rates than LVHR. RVHR had significantly higher rates of complications and postoperative infections compared to LVHR, although there was no difference in mortality, 30-day readmission, LOS, and postoperative pain medication use. Mean direct cost of surgery was significantly higher for RVHR, followed by OVHR and LVHR. CONCLUSIONS: Overall patient outcomes were improved in the LVHR and RVHR groups compared to the open approach. However, RVHR patients did not have significant improvement compared with the LVHR group in either short-term outcomes or opiate medication used. While RVHR surgery was the most expensive modality, OVHR was also significantly costlier than LVHR, which was the least expensive. Long-term data on recurrence could not be evaluated and should be studied to determine the role of robotic surgery in VHR and recurrence rates.
引用
- Armijo P, Pratap A, Wang Y, et al. Robotic ventral hernia repair is not superior to laparoscopic: a national database review. Surg Endosc. 2017. PMID: 29052065. doi:10.1007/s00464-017-5872-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。