内科与普外科住院医师对复杂手术患者术后并发症风险评估的比较
该研究让76名普外科和76名内科住院医师在线评估7个复杂临床场景的术后并发症风险,并与NSQIP风险调整模型比较。结果显示两组住院医师对并发症和死亡的估计相似,但均普遍高估风险,仅11%的NSQIP估计值落在其95%CI内。
要点
- 普外科与内科住院医师对复杂手术患者的并发症风险估计相似。
- 两组均普遍高估术后并发症和死亡风险,仅11%的NSQIP估计值落在其95%CI内。
- 普外科住院医师更自信但较少讨论代码状态或咨询NSQIP等风险调整模型。
核心结论
- 普外科与内科住院医师对复杂手术患者的术后并发症和死亡风险估计相似,但两组均普遍高估风险。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为匿名在线评估,纳入城市三级学术医疗中心的76名普外科住院医师和76名内科住院医师,总体应答率64%。
- 参与者评估7个真实复杂临床场景,估计任何并发症、死亡、手术部位感染、肺炎和心脏并发症的风险,并与NSQIP在线计算器的风险调整结果比较。
主要发现
- 普外科住院医师对回答的自信度均值为3.6(95%CI 3.4-2.8),内科住院医师为2.8(95%CI 2.6-3.0),P < .001。
- 普外科住院医师对不提供手术的自信度均值为4.3(95%CI 4.1-4.4),内科住院医师为3.7(95%CI 3.4-3.9),P = .006。
- 普外科住院医师讨论代码状态的自信度均值为3.2(95%CI 2.9-3.4),内科住院医师为3.8(95%CI 3.5-4.1),P < .001。
- 普外科住院医师咨询NSQIP等风险调整模型的自信度均值为2.9(95%CI 2.7-3.1),内科住院医师为3.7(95%CI 3.4-4.0),P < .001。
- 在91%的临床估计中,两组同样高估每种风险;在9%的估计中,内科住院医师高估更严重;仅11%的NSQIP估计值落在其95%CI内;所有并发症的估计均值比NSQIP估计高26%至33%。
临床怎么用
- 临床中应意识到住院医师可能高估复杂手术患者的术后风险,需借助NSQIP等风险调整工具校准。
- 应加强住院医师对风险调整模型的使用和代码状态讨论的培训。
局限性
- 研究为单中心、匿名在线评估,样本量有限,可能影响结果的普遍性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Anticipating postsurgical complications is a vital physician skill, particularly when counseling surgically complex patients on their risks of intervention. Although internists and surgeons both counsel patients on surgical risks, it is uncertain who is better equipped to accurately anticipate surgical complications. OBJECTIVE: To examine how internal medicine and general surgery trainees compare in their assessment of risk of surgically complex patients. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: General surgery and internal medicine residents (urban, tertiary, and academic medical center) answered an anonymous, online assessment of 7 real-life, complex clinical scenarios. Participants estimated the chance of any morbidity, mortality, surgical site infection, pneumonia, and cardiac complications. Scenarios represented a diverse general surgery practice, including colectomy, duodenal ulcer repair, inguinal hernia repair, perforated viscus exploration, small-bowel resection, cholecystectomy, and mastectomy in surgically complex patients likely to be comanaged by surgical and internal medicine services. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Responses were compared with risk-adjusted outcomes reported by the American College of Surgeons’ National Surgical Quality Improvement Project (NSQIP) online calculator. RESULTS: A total of 76 general surgery residents (50 [65.8%] male and 26 [34.2%] female) and 76 internal medicine residents (36 [47.4%] male and 40 [52.6%] female) participated (64% overall response rate). General surgery residents were significantly more confident with their responses (general surgery residents’ mean response, 3.6 [95% CI, 3.4-2.8]; internal medicine residents’ mean response, 2.8 [95% CI, 2.6-3.0]; P < .001) and with not offering operations (general surgery residents’ mean response, 4.3 [95% CI, 4.1-4.4]; internal medicine residents’ mean response, 3.7 [95% CI, 3.4-3.9]; P = .006) but less likely to discuss code status (general surgery residents’ mean response, 3.2 [95% CI, 2.9-3.4]; internal medicine residents’ mean response, 3.8 [95% CI, 3.5-4.1]; P < .001) or consult risk-adjusted models, such as NSQIP (general surgery residents’ mean response, 2.9 [95% CI, 2.7-3.1]; internal medicine residents’ mean response, 3.7 [95% CI, 3.4-4.0]; P < .001). For 91% of clinical estimates, both groups similarly overestimated every type of risk; in 9% of estimates, internal medicine residents had higher overestimates. Estimates varied significantly, with wide 95% CIs; however, only 11% of the NSQIP estimates fell within the 95% CIs. Overall, the mean percentages of the estimates ranged from 26% to 33% over NSQIP estimates for all complications. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: General surgery and internal medicine residents demonstrated similar estimates of postoperative complications and death. Both groups overestimated risks in surgically complex patient scenarios compared with NSQIP risk calculator estimates. This near-universal overestimation of risk underscores the importance of developing risk-estimation resources for internists and surgeons. This study compares assessment of risk of postsurgical complications in surgically complex patients between internal medicine and general surgery trainees. QUESTION: How do internal medicine and general surgery trainees compare in their assessment of risk of postsurgical complications in surgically complex patients? FINDINGS: In this study, assessment of risk of postsurgical complications was not significantly different between internal medicine and general surgery trainee groups, but both groups consistently overestimated risk compared with the American College of Surgeons’ National Surgical Quality Improvement Project risk-adjusted model. MEANING: Trainees may overestimate risks when counseling patients; a broad range of estimates implies a lack of consensus on true risk for surgically complex patients.
引用
- Healy JM, Davis KA, Pei KY, et al. Comparison of Internal Medicine and General Surgery Residents' Assessments of Risk of Postsurgical Complications in Surgically Complex Patients. JAMA Surg. 2018. PMID: 29049425. doi:10.1001/jamasurg.2017.3936
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。