实验性腹膜炎模型中不同补片用于腹壁修复的特性研究
该研究在大鼠腹膜炎模型中比较五种补片(两种交联/非交联生物补片、两种合成补片)植入后30、90、180天的整合、皱缩、粘连及组织学表现。结果显示XCM Biologic®在整合、宏观感染及组织学参数上最优,但皱缩最明显,需充分重叠放置。
要点
- XCM Biologic®在腹膜炎模型中整合与组织学表现最优。
- Strattice™粘连最少,但整合劣于XCM Biologic®和Permacol™。
- XCM Biologic®皱缩最明显,放置时需充分重叠。
核心结论
- XCM Biologic®在整合、宏观补片感染及组织学参数(胶原沉积和新生血管化)方面表现更优。
- 放置补片时需充分重叠,因XCM Biologic®皱缩率高。
研究设计与样本
- 雄性Wistar大鼠随机分为五组,诱导腹膜炎后24小时植入补片,分别于30、90、180天处死。
- 共135只大鼠随机分组,其中18只死于腹膜炎。
- 比较五种补片:Permacol™(交联胶原)、Strattice™(非交联胶原)、XCM Biologic®(非交联胶原)、Omyra® Mesh(压缩聚四氟乙烯)和Parietene™(聚丙烯)。
主要发现
- XCM Biologic®皱缩最明显,但与其他补片相比无显著差异。
- 组织学分析显示所有补片间的异物反应存在显著差异。
临床怎么用
- 在 potentially contaminated 腹壁疝修复中,XCM Biologic®可能是有用的选择。
- 使用XCM Biologic®时需确保补片充分重叠以应对皱缩。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The use of synthetic mesh to repair a potentially contaminated incisional hernia may lead to higher failure rates. A biological mesh might be considered, but little is known about long-term results. Both biological and synthetic meshes were investigated in an experimental model of peritonitis to assess their characteristics in vivo. METHODS: Male Wistar rats were randomized into five groups and peritonitis was induced. A mesh was implanted after 24 h. Five meshes were investigated: Permacol™ (cross-linked collagen), Strattice™ (non-cross-linked collagen), XCM Biologic® (non-cross-linked collagen), Omyra® Mesh (condensed polytetrafluoroethylene) and Parietene™ (polypropylene). The rats were killed after either 30, 90 or 180 days. Incorporation and shrinkage of the mesh, adhesion coverage, strength of adhesions and histology were analysed. RESULTS: Of 135 rats randomized, 18 died from peritonitis. Some 180 days after implantation, both XCM Biologic® and Permacol™ had significantly better incorporation than Strattice™ (P = 0·003 and P = 0·009 respectively). Strattice™ had significantly fewer adhesions than XCM Biologic® (P = 0·001) and Permacol™ (P = 0·020). Thirty days after implantation, Permacol™ had significantly stronger adhesions than Strattice™ (P < 0·001). Shrinkage was most prominent in XCM Biologic® , but no significant difference was found compared with the other meshes. Histological analysis revealed marked differences in foreign body response among all meshes. CONCLUSION: This experimental study suggested that XCM Biologic® was superior in terms of incorporation, macroscopic mesh infection, and histological parameters such as collagen deposition and neovascularization. There must be sufficient overlap of mesh during placement, as XCM Biologic® showed a high rate of shrinkage. Surgical relevance The use of synthetic mesh to repair a potentially contaminated incisional hernia is not supported unequivocally, and may lead to a higher failure rate. A biological mesh might be considered as an alternative. There are few long-term studies, as these meshes are expensive and rarely used. This study evaluated the use of biological mesh in a contaminated environment, and investigated whether there is an ideal mesh. A new non-cross-linked biological mesh (XCM Biologic® ) was evaluated in this experiment. The new non-cross-linked biological mesh XCM Biologic® performed best and may be useful in patients with a potentially contaminated incisional hernia.
引用
- Kaufmann R, Jairam AP, Mulder IM, et al. Characteristics of different mesh types for abdominal wall repair in an experimental model of peritonitis. Br J Surg. 2017. PMID: 28901533. doi:10.1002/bjs.10635
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。