文献速递胃肠外科急腹症与外科感染

无症状食管旁疝:观察等待还是择期腹腔镜修补?

Approach to asymptomatic paraesophageal hernia: watchful waiting or elective laparoscopic hernia repair?
PubMed 文献 · Surg Endosc · 2017-08-04

该研究用马尔可夫蒙特卡洛微观模拟决策分析模型,对以女性为主、平均年龄62.5岁的无症状食管旁疝(PEH)假设队列进行终身随访,比较观察等待(WW)与择期腹腔镜疝修补(ELHR)两种策略所获得的以质量调整生命月(QALM)表示的健康收益。二维模拟显示WW在82%的模拟中占优,平均多获得5个QALM(168 vs. 163),确定性敏感性分析结果稳健。

要点

  • 无症状PEH初始选择观察等待在多数模拟中健康收益更优
  • WW较ELHR平均多获得5个QALM(168 vs. 163)
  • 结论基于决策分析模型,需结合个体情况判断

核心结论

  • 对无症状食管旁疝患者,初始采用观察等待比择期腹腔镜疝修补更可能获得更大的健康收益。

研究设计与样本

  • 马尔可夫蒙特卡洛微观模拟决策分析模型,随访假设的无症状PEH队列至终身。
  • 队列以女性为主,平均年龄62.5岁(正态分布)。
  • 比较观察等待(WW)与择期腹腔镜疝修补(ELHR)两种策略,并以质量调整生命月(QALM)衡量健康收益。
  • 采用二维模拟处理模型不确定性,并行确定性敏感性分析检验关键假设。

主要发现

  • 在考虑个体与参数层面不确定性的二维模拟中,WW在82%的模拟中为更优策略。
  • WW平均比ELHR多获得5个QALM(168 vs. 163)。
  • 模型对确定性敏感性分析稳健,并经过内部验证。

临床怎么用

  • 面对无症状PEH患者,可将观察等待作为初始治疗选择与患者讨论。
  • 决策需结合患者个体情况,不能仅凭模型结果一概而论。

局限性

  • 研究为基于假设队列的决策分析模型,非真实患者队列研究。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: There is no consensus on whether asymptomatic paraesophageal hernia (PEH) should be operated. Some argue that surgery is necessary prophylaxis against potentially catastrophic consequences of acute complications in untreated PEH. Others reason that the acute complications are rare and emergent operations have relatively low mortality. In the laparoscopic era, elective operations have become safer and less morbid. However, recent studies report high incidence of recurrent hernia, some of which affect quality of life and require further interventions. In light of these new findings, we investigated whether asymptomatic PEH should receive elective laparoscopic hernia repair (ELHR) or watchful waiting (WW). METHODS: A Markov Monte Carlo microsimulation decision analysis model followed a hypothetical cohort of asymptomatic PEH patients who have predominantly female gender and normally distributed mean age of 62.5 years for the lifetime. Accrued health benefits expressed in quality-adjusted life months (QALM) were compared between two strategies: WW and ELHR. Two-dimensional simulations were performed to account for uncertainties in the model. Deterministic sensitivity analyses were performed to test key assumptions. RESULTS: After considering both individual- and parameter-level uncertainties in the two-dimensional simulations, WW was the superior strategy in 82% of the simulations, accumulating mean 5 QALM more than ELHR (168 vs. 163). Our model was robust to deterministic sensitivity analyses and was internally validated, which supported the validity of our results. CONCLUSIONS: Patients with asymptomatic PEH are more likely to achieve greater health outcomes if they undergo WW as initial treatment than ELHR.

来源:Surg Endosc,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jung JJ, Naimark DM, Behman R, et al. Approach to asymptomatic paraesophageal hernia: watchful waiting or elective laparoscopic hernia repair? Surg Endosc. 2017. PMID: 28779249. doi:10.1007/s00464-017-5755-y

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。