文献速递胃肠外科围术期管理与 ERAS

机器人对比腹腔镜对比开腹结直肠手术:探索合理选择标准

Robotic versus laparoscopic versus open colorectal surgery: towards defining criteria to the right choice.
PubMed 文献 · Surg Endosc · 2017-08-15

该综述分析患者、疾病及手术操作相关参数,旨在为术前选择合适术式提供指导;文章回顾手术演进、已发表数据及成本因素,讨论机器人、腹腔镜与开腹三种平台的优势与不足。机器人技术具有三维视野、可转腕、消除手颤及术者舒适等优势,可能扩展微创手术范围并缩短学习曲线,但成本更高、手术时间更长、缺乏触觉反馈等;传统腹腔镜亦已进步并具备高清三维视野。最终需按病例评估以价值(质量/成本)为基础的术式影响。

要点

  • 机器人优势包括三维视野、可转腕、消除手颤及术者舒适,可能扩展深盆腔等困难部位的微创手术范围并缩短学习曲线。
  • 机器人劣势包括成本更高、手术时间更长、缺乏触觉反馈、可能不寻常的并发症及难以移动手术床和在不同象限操作。
  • 传统腹腔镜亦已演进,可为全体团队成员提供高清三维视野;术式价值需按病例评估质量与成本之比。

核心结论

  • 机器人手术的技术与设计发展可能解决部分不足,但各术式的价值影响需总体及按病例评估。
  • 价值作为质量与成本之比取决于疾病、并发症、患者、效率及财务等众多参数。

研究设计与样本

  • 综述,回顾手术演进、已发表数据及成本因素,分析患者、疾病与所需手术操作相关参数以制定术前选择指导。

主要发现

  • 机器人技术优势包括三维视野、可转腕、消除手颤及术者舒适,可能通过允许在腹腔镜难以到达部位(如深盆腔)操作、完成复杂任务(如体内缝合)及缩短学习曲线来扩展微创手术范围。
  • 传统腹腔镜亦已演进,可为全体团队成员提供高清三维视野。
  • 机器人劣势包括成本更高、手术时间更长、缺乏触觉反馈、可能不寻常的并发症、难以移动手术床及难以在不同象限操作。

临床怎么用

  • 术前选择术式时需综合评估患者、疾病及所需手术操作参数,并按病例权衡质量与成本之比。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: Analysis of various parameters related to the patient, the disease, and the needed surgical maneuvers to develop guidance for preoperative selection of the appropriate and the best approach for a given patient. Rapid advances in minimally invasive surgical technology are fascinating and challenging alike. It can be difficult for surgeons to keep up with new modalities that come on to the market place and to assess their true value, i.e., distinguish between fashionable trends versus scientific evidence. Laparoscopy established minimally invasive surgery and has revolutionized surgical concepts and approaches to diseases since its advent in the early 1990s. Now, with robotic surgery rapidly gaining traction in this high-tech surgical landscape, it remains to be seen how the long-term surgical landscape will be affected. METHODS: Review of the surgical evolution, published data and cost factors to reflect on advantages and disadvantages in order to develop a broader perspective on the role of various technology platforms. RESULTS: Advocates for robotic technology tout its advantages of 3D views, articulating wrists, lack of hand tremor, and surgeon comfort, which may extend the scope of minimally invasive surgery by allowing for operations in places that are more difficult to access for laparoscopic surgery (e.g., the deep pelvis), for complex tasks (e.g., intracorporeal suturing), and by decreasing the learning curve. But conventional laparoscopy has also evolved and offers high-definition 3D vision to all team members. It remains to be seen whether all together the robot features outweigh the downsides of higher cost, operative times, lack of tactile feedback, possibly unusual complications, inability to move the operative table with ease, and the difficulty to work in different quadrants. CONCLUSIONS: While technical and design developments will likely address some shortcomings, the value-based impact of the various approaches will have to be examined in general and on a case-by-case basis. Value as the ratio of quality over cost depends on numerous parameters (disease, complications, patient, efficiency, finances).

来源:Surg Endosc,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Zelhart M, Kaiser AM. Robotic versus laparoscopic versus open colorectal surgery: towards defining criteria to the right choice. Surg Endosc. 2017. PMID: 28812154. doi:10.1007/s00464-017-5796-2

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。