胃或十二指肠穿孔网膜补片修补术后常规与选择性上消化道造影对比
本研究回顾性分析115例胃或十二指肠穿孔行网膜补片修补术的患者,比较术后行上消化道造影(UGI)与未行UGI及选择性UGI与常规UGI的临床结局。结果显示UGI组与未UGI组在漏检测、死亡和再手术率上无差异,但UGI组住院时间中位数显著延长(15.5天 vs 8天)。选择性UGI与常规UGI之间无优势差异,建议根据临床指征选择UGI。
要点
- 胃或十二指肠穿孔网膜补片修补术后,常规或选择性UGI均未显示可改善漏检测、再手术或死亡结局。
- 术后行UGI与住院时间延长相关(中位15.5天 vs 8天),需权衡临床获益。
- 选择性UGI与常规UGI无优势差异,UGI应基于临床指征而非常规使用。
核心结论
- 胃或十二指肠穿孔行网膜补片修补术后,行UGI与否在漏检测、再手术和死亡方面无统计学差异。
- UGI组住院时间较未UGI组延长(中位15.5天 vs 8天)。
- 选择性UGI与常规UGI相比无优势,建议基于临床指征使用选择性UGI。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析纳入115例胃或十二指肠穿孔行网膜补片修补术的患者,数据来自佛罗里达七家医院院区。
- 患者年龄≥18岁,识别时间为2006年至2016年,依据ICD9计费信息筛选。
- 患者分为UGI组和未UGI组,UGI组再分为选择性UGI和常规UGI。
- 选择性UGI定义为术后第3天以后出现以下一项或多项:WBC>12,000、腹膜炎、体温>100.4 F、心率>110 bpm(三次及以上评估)或术后第7天后行任何UGI。
主要发现
- UGI组与未UGI组在术前症状、漏检测、死亡和再手术率方面无差异。
- UGI组与未UGI组住院时间中位数分别为15.5天和8天,差异有统计学意义。
- UGI亚组中29例患者有20例接受选择性检查,选择性UGI与常规UGI在漏检测、死亡和再手术方面无统计学差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 选择性UGI标准:术后第3天以后WBC>12,000、腹膜炎、体温>100.4 F、心率>110 bpm(三次及以上评估)或术后第7天后行任何UGI。
- UGI组住院时间中位数15.5天,未UGI组8天,差异有统计学意义。
临床怎么用
- 胃或十二指肠穿孔网膜补片修补术后,不建议常规行上消化道造影,应根据临床指征选择。
- 对于术后出现WBC升高、腹膜炎、发热、心动过速或术后第7天后仍需评估的患者,可考虑选择性UGI。
- 需注意UGI可能伴随住院时间延长,应权衡检查的必要性。
局限性
- 本研究为回顾性分析,存在选择偏倚和信息偏倚可能。
- 样本量较小(n=115),UGI亚组仅29例,统计效能有限。
- 数据来源于单一州的多家医院,结果外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There are no guidelines on the routine or selective use of contrast upper gastrointestinal series (UGI) after omental patch repair (OPR) of a gastric (GP) or duodenal perforation (DP). This study aims to elucidate whether the use of selective versus routine contrast study will lead to worse clinical outcomes. METHODS: A retrospective analysis of 115 (n = 115) patients with OPR of GP or DP was performed. Data were obtained from seven Florida Hospital campuses. Patients aged 18 and older from 2006 to 2016 were identified by ICD9 billing information. Patients were divided into two groups: UGI and no UGI. The UGI group was subdivided into selective versus routine. A selective UGI was defined as one or more of the following after post-operative day 3: WBC >12,000, peritonitis, fever >100.4 F, tachycardia >110 bpm on three or more assessments, and any UGI performed after POD 7. Perioperative symptoms, perforation location, size, abdominal contamination, laparoscopic or open, leak detection, length of stay, mortality, and reoperation within 2 weeks were also examined. RESULTS: No differences between the UGI group and non-UGI group relating to preoperative symptoms, leak detection, death, and reoperation rate were revealed. Differences in length of stay were found to be statistically significant with the UGI group and non-UGI at a median of 15.5 and 8 days, respectively. In the UGI subgroup, 20 of the 29 patients received selective studies. There were no statistical differences identified in leak detection, death, and reoperation. CONCLUSIONS: Rates of leak detection, reoperation, and death in patients with GP or DP repaired with omental patch utilizing an UGI study were not statistically significant. An increased length of stay was observed within the UGI group. There was no advantage demonstrated between a selective versus routine UGI; therefore, the use of selective UGI should be based upon clinical indications.
引用
- Poris S, Fontaine A, Glener J, et al. Routine versus selective upper gastrointestinal contrast series after omental patch repair for gastric or duodenal perforation. Surg Endosc. 2017. PMID: 28664428. doi:10.1007/s00464-017-5695-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。