文献速递围术期管理与 ERAS胃肠外科疝与腹壁外科

美国普外科住院医师独立执业准备度评估

Readiness of US General Surgery Residents for Independent Practice.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Surg · 2017-01-01

本研究通过14个普外科培训项目的444名主治医师对536名住院医师的10130例手术进行评分,评估住院医师手术表现与自主性。结果显示,核心手术「实践准备」比例从第一年的12.3%升至最后一年的77.1%,但复杂患者或高难度核心手术的预测胜任概率低于80%,且自主性有限。结论认为美国普外科住院医师并非普遍能在毕业时独立完成核心手术。

要点

  • 核心手术「实践准备」比例从第一年12.3%升至最后一年77.1%。
  • 最后一周住院医师对平均核心手术的预测胜任概率为90.5%。
  • 复杂患者胜任概率降至84.6%,高难度核心手术低于80%。

核心结论

  • 美国普外科住院医师毕业时并非普遍具备独立完成核心手术的能力。
  • 住院医师逐步获得的自主性有限,且尚不清楚其是否足以确保覆盖全部独立执业范围。

研究设计与样本

  • 在14个普外科培训项目中,主治医师经培训后使用SIMPL表现量表(5级)和Zwisch自主性量表(4级)在手术后即时评分。
  • 共444名主治医师对536名分类住院医师的10130例手术进行了评分。
  • 数据分析采用描述性统计并辅以贝叶斯有序模型估计。

主要发现

  • 核心手术(n=6931)的「实践准备」及以上评分比例从培训第一年的12.3%增至最后一年77.1%。
  • 在住院培训最后一周,典型受训者完成平均核心手术(平均复杂度患者)的预测胜任概率为90.5%(95%CI:85.7%-94%)。
  • 该概率在更复杂患者中降至84.6%,在更困难的核心手术中降至低于80%。
  • 所有手术中,体现有意义自主性(「被动帮助」或「仅监督」)的Zwisch评分比例从第一年的15.1%增至最后一年65.7%。
  • 在培训最后6个月住院医师完成的核心手术(胆囊切除术、腹股沟/股疝修补术、阑尾切除术、腹壁疝修补术、部分结肠切除术)中,近独立(「仅监督」)的Zwisch评分比例(n=357)为33.3%。

临床怎么用

  • 应关注住院医师在复杂患者和高难度核心手术中的独立执业准备度不足。
  • 需针对性提升住院医师在核心手术中的自主性,尤其是毕业前阶段。

局限性

  • 研究未明确所达到的自主性程度是否足以确保覆盖全部独立执业范围。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: This study evaluates the current state of the General Surgery (GS) residency training model by investigating resident operative performance and autonomy. BACKGROUND: The American Board of Surgery has designated 132 procedures as being "Core" to the practice of GS. GS residents are expected to be able to safely and independently perform those procedures by the time they graduate. There is growing concern that not all residents achieve that standard. Lack of operative autonomy may play a role. METHODS: Attendings in 14 General Surgery programs were trained to use a) the 5-level System for Improving and Measuring Procedural Learning (SIMPL) Performance scale to assess resident readiness for independent practice and b) the 4-level Zwisch scale to assess the level of guidance (ie, autonomy) they provided to residents during specific procedures. Ratings were collected immediately after cases that involved a categorical GS resident. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and supplemented with Bayesian ordinal model-based estimation. RESULTS: A total of 444 attending surgeons rated 536 categorical residents after 10,130 procedures. Performance: from the first to the last year of training, the proportion of Performance ratings for Core procedures (n = 6931) at "Practice Ready" or above increased from 12.3% to 77.1%. The predicted probability that a typical trainee would be rated as Competent after performing an average Core procedure on an average complexity patient during the last week of residency training is 90.5% (95% CI: 85.7%-94%). This falls to 84.6% for more complex patients and to less than 80% for more difficult Core procedures. Autonomy: for all procedures, the proportion of Zwisch ratings indicating meaningful autonomy ("Passive Help" or "Supervision Only") increased from 15.1% to 65.7% from the first to the last year of training. For the Core procedures performed by residents in their final 6 months of training (cholecystectomy, inguinal/femoral hernia repair, appendectomy, ventral hernia repair, and partial colectomy), the proportion of Zwisch ratings (n = 357) indicating near-independence ("Supervision Only") was 33.3%. CONCLUSIONS: US General Surgery residents are not universally ready to independently perform Core procedures by the time they complete residency training. Progressive resident autonomy is also limited. It is unknown if the amount of autonomy residents do achieve is sufficient to ensure readiness for the entire spectrum of independent practice.

来源:Ann Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. George BC, Bohnen JD, Williams RG, et al. Readiness of US General Surgery Residents for Independent Practice. Ann Surg. 2017. PMID: 28742711. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000002414

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。