外科医生在微创与开腹结肠切除术中并发症的差异:密歇根外科质量协作组结果
基于密歇根外科质量协作组2012至2015年数据,分析97名外科医生完成的5196例微创或开腹结肠切除术。
要点
- 医生间微创手术并发症率变异(8.8%–25.9%)近开腹手术(25.9%–43.8%)的两倍。
- 同一医生开腹与微创手术的并发症排名差异显著,平均变化25位。
核心结论
- 在全州质量协作组的外科医生中,微创结肠切除术的医生间并发症变异近开腹手术的两倍。
- 同一医生开腹手术的结局排名与微创手术结局排名差异显著。
- 提示部分外科医生在采用微创结肠切除术技术时需要改进培训。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析密歇根外科质量协作组2012年1月1日至2015年12月31日数据。
- 纳入97名外科医生,每人至少完成10例开腹和10例微创结肠切除术,共5196例患者。
- 采用分层回归评估医生间调整后并发症率的变异及两种术式结局的关联。
主要发现
- 5196例患者中,3118例(60.0%)接受微创结肠切除术,2078例(40.0%)接受开腹结肠切除术。
- 微创手术医生间并发症率从8.8%到25.9%不等。
- 开腹手术医生间并发症率更高但变异较小(1.7倍),从25.9%到43.8%不等。
- 97名医生中,开腹与微创手术排名平均变化25位;开腹排名前10的医生在微创中排名范围为6/97至89/97。
临床怎么用
- 临床应关注外科医生个体微创结肠切除术的并发症率,而非仅凭开腹手术表现推断微创手术质量。
- 质量改进项目需针对微创技术采用过程进行差异化培训和评估。
局限性
- 研究为观察性设计,仅纳入密歇根州质量协作组中每位医生至少10例开腹和10例微创手术的医生,可能存在选择偏倚。
- 未报告微创与开腹手术的具体匹配或混杂因素调整细节。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Minimally invasive colectomy (MIC) is an increasingly common surgical procedure. Although case series and controlled prospective trials have found the procedure to be safe, it is unclear whether safe adaptation of this approach from open colectomy (OC) is occurring among surgeons. OBJECTIVE: To assess rates of complications for MIC compared with OC among surgeons. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: We analyzed 5196 patients who underwent MIC or OC from January 1, 2012, through December 31, 2015, by 97 surgeons in the Michigan Surgical Quality Collaborative, with each surgeon performing at least 10 OCs and 10 MICs. Hierarchical regression was used to assess surgeon variation in adjusted rates of complications and the association of these outcomes across approaches. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Primary study outcome measurements included overall 30-day complication rates, variation in complication rates among surgeons, and surgeon rank by complication rate for MIC vs OC. RESULTS: Of the 5196 patients (mean [SD] age, 62.9 [14.4] years; 2842 [54.7%] female; 4429 [85.2%] white), 3118 (60.0%) underwent MIC and 2078 (40.0%) underwent OC. Overall, 1149 patients (22.1%) experienced complications (702 [33.8%] in the OC group vs 447 [14.3%] in the MIC group; P < .001). For MIC, the rates of complications varied from 8.8% to 25.9% among surgeons. For OC, rates of complications were higher but varied less (1.7-fold) among surgeons, ranging from 25.9% to 43.8%. Among the 97 surgeons ranked, the mean change in ranking between OC and MIC was 25 positions. The top 10 surgeons ranged in rank from 6 of 97 for OC to 89 of 97 for MIC. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Surgeon-level variation in complications was nearly twice as great for MIC than for OC among surgeons enrolled in a statewide quality collaborative. Moreover, surgeon rankings for OC outcomes differed substantially from outcomes for those same surgeons performing MIC. This finding implies a need for improved training in adoption of MIC techniques among some surgeons.
引用
- Healy MA, Regenbogen SE, Kanters AE, et al. Surgeon Variation in Complications With Minimally Invasive and Open Colectomy: Results From the Michigan Surgical Quality Collaborative. JAMA Surg. 2017. PMID: 28614551. doi:10.1001/jamasurg.2017.1527
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。