基于正式制定的质量指标评估急诊普通外科诊疗
研究采用改良德尔菲技术(RAND适宜性方法)制定急诊普通外科质量指标,经两轮排名确定25项有效指标(13项患者层面、12项医院层面),并在4家学术中心对4种非择期手术后的18项指标依从性进行历史性评估。结果显示不同指标依从性差异大,部分指标无医院达标,提示依从质量指标可能改善急诊普通外科诊疗质量。
要点
- 共制定25项有效急诊普通外科质量指标,其中13项针对患者层面、12项针对医院层面。
- 急性胆囊炎症状发作72小时内行胆囊切除术的依从性为45%至76%。
- 3项质量指标(非手术患者30天非计划再入院/再手术审计、腹腔感染感染源控制时间监测、转诊/转运流程)无医院达标。
核心结论
- 为急诊普通外科提供者制定质量指标并评估其表现,可为具体改进举措奠定基础。
- 依从质量指标可能改善当前结局可能可改变的急诊普通外科诊疗质量。
研究设计与样本
- 采用改良德尔菲技术(RAND适宜性方法)制定质量指标,经2轮排名由专家小组评定指标有效性。
- 在4家学术中心对4种非择期手术(胆囊切除术、阑尾切除术、结肠切除术、小肠切除术)后18项指标的依从性进行历史性评估。
主要发现
- 25项指标被评为有效,其中13项针对患者层面质量,12项针对医院层面质量。
- 急性胆囊炎症状发作72小时内行胆囊切除术的依从性范围为45%至76%。
- 空腔脏器穿孔未局限化决定手术后3小时内手术开始时间的依从性范围为20%至100%。
- 小肠梗阻伴缺血/即将穿孔决定手术后3小时内探查的依从性范围为0%至88%。
- 3项质量指标(非手术患者30天非计划再入院/再手术审计、腹腔感染感染源控制时间监测、转诊/转运流程)无医院达标。
关键数值与推荐
- 急性胆囊炎应在症状发作72小时内行胆囊切除术。
- 空腔脏器穿孔未局限化应在决定手术后3小时内开始手术。
- 小肠梗阻伴缺血/即将穿孔应在决定手术后3小时内行探查。
临床怎么用
- 急诊普通外科提供者可依据上述质量指标评估自身表现并开展针对性改进举措。
- 关注急性胆囊炎72小时内手术、穿孔及缺血性小肠梗阻3小时内手术等时限性指标以提升依从性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Emergency general surgery outcomes vary widely across the United States. The utilization of quality indicators can reduce variation and assist providers in administering care aligned with established recommendations. Previous quality indicators have not focused on emergency general surgery patients. We identified indicators of high-quality emergency general surgery care and assessed patient- and hospital-level compliance with these indicators. METHODS: We utilized a modified Delphi technique (RAND Appropriateness Methodology) to develop quality indicators. Through 2 rankings, an expert panel ranked potential quality indicators for validity. We then examined historic compliance with select quality indicators after 4 nonelective procedures (cholecystectomy, appendectomy, colectomy, small bowel resection) at 4 academic centers. RESULTS: Of 25 indicators rated as valid, 13 addressed patient-level quality and 12 addressed hospital-level quality. Adherence with 18 indicators was assessed. Compliance with performing a cholecystectomy for acute cholecystitis within 72 hours of symptom onset ranged from 45% to 76%. Compliance with surgery start times within 3 hours from the decision to operate for uncontained perforated viscus ranged from 20% to 100%. Compliance with exploration of patients with small bowel obstructions with ischemia/impending perforation within 3 hours of the decision to operate was 0% to 88%. For 3 quality indicators (auditing 30-day unplanned readmissions/operations for patients previously managed nonoperatively, monitoring time to source control for intra-abdominal infections, and having protocols for bypass/transfer), none of the hospitals were compliant. CONCLUSION: Developing indicators for providers to assess their performance provides a foundation for specific initiatives. Adherence to quality indicators may improve the quality of emergency general surgery care provided for which current outcomes are potentially modifiable.
引用
- Ingraham A, Nathens A, Peitzman A, et al. Assessment of emergency general surgery care based on formally developed quality indicators. Surgery. 2017. PMID: 28647046. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2017.03.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。