术后诊疗流程利用或并发症发生率能否解释癌症手术的量-费用关系?
该研究基于2005至2009年Medicare住院索赔数据,分析6种癌症切除术的医疗提供者手术量与费用的关系,并检验并发症和诊疗流程利用是否影响该关系。结果显示,高医院手术量仅与食管切除术患者费用降低相关;高外科医生手术量降低多数手术费用,但加入诊疗流程变量后关系减弱。结论认为并发症发生时实施的诊疗流程解释了大部分外科医生量-费用关系。
要点
- 高医院手术量仅与食管切除术费用降低相关。
- 高外科医生手术量降低多数癌症手术费用,但加入诊疗流程后减弱。
- 并发症相关诊疗流程费用高14%至34%,低量医生更常用。
核心结论
- 并发症发生时实施的诊疗流程解释了大部分外科医生手术量与费用的关系。
- 鉴于外科医生手术量易于观察,将患者转诊至高量外科医生可能实现更好结局和更低费用。
- 增加患者获得低并发症率外科医生的机会可能是避免昂贵诊疗流程、控制费用增长的最有效策略。
研究设计与样本
- 研究分析了2005年至2009年Medicare医院和住院索赔数据,涵盖6种癌症切除术:结肠切除术、直肠切除术、肺叶切除术、全肺切除术、食管切除术和胰腺切除术。
- 研究首先估计医疗提供者手术量与费用的关联回归,排除并发症和诊疗流程作为解释变量;随后将这些变量加入回归,检验是否削弱先前观察到的量-费用关系。
主要发现
- 较高医院手术量与食管切除术患者费用降低相关,但与其他手术无关。
- 较高外科医生手术量降低大多数手术的费用,但当诊疗流程加入回归时该结果减弱。
- 为应对不良事件而频繁实施的诊疗流程与费用增加14%至34%相关。
- 这些诊疗流程的利用在低量外科医生中比高量外科医生更普遍。
临床怎么用
- 鉴于外科医生手术量易于观察,可考虑将患者转诊至高量外科医生以可能实现更好结局和更低费用。
- 增加患者获得低并发症率外科医生的机会,可能有助于避免昂贵的诊疗流程并控制费用增长。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Past studies identify an association between provider volume and outcomes, but less is known about the volume-cost relationship for cancer surgery. We analyze the volume-cost relationship for 6 cancer operations and explore whether it is influenced by the occurrence of complications and/or utilization of processes of care. METHODS: Medicare hospital and inpatient claims for the years 2005 through 2009 were analyzed for 6 cancer resections: colectomy, rectal resection, pulmonary lobectomy, pneumonectomy, esophagectomy, and pancreatic resection. Regressions were first estimated to quantify the association of provider volume with costs, excluding measures of complications and processes of care as explanatory variables. Next, these variables were added to the regressions to test whether they weakened any previously observed volume-cost relationship. RESULTS: Higher hospital volume is associated with lower patient costs for esophagectomy but not for other operations. Higher surgeon volume reduces costs for most procedures, but this result weakens when processes of care are added to the regressions. Processes of care that are frequently implemented in response to adverse events are associated with 14% to 34% higher costs. Utilization of these processes is more prevalent among low-volume versus high-volume surgeons. CONCLUSION: Processes of care implemented when complications occur explain much of the surgeon volume-cost relationship. Given that surgeon volume is readily observed, better outcomes and lower costs may be achieved by referring patients to high-volume surgeons. Increasing patient access to surgeons with lower rates of complications may be the most effective strategy for avoiding costly processes of care, controlling expenditure growth.
引用
- Ho V, Short MN, Aloia TA, et al. Can postoperative process of care utilization or complication rates explain the volume-cost relationship for cancer surgery? Surgery. 2017. PMID: 28438333. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2017.03.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。