肝切除术中红细胞输注适当性的渥太华标准:基于RAND/UCLA适当性方法
该指南采用RAND/UCLA适当性方法,由国际多学科专家组对468个肝切除术围术期场景进行评分,其中47.4%评为适当、28.2%不适当、24.4%不确定。关键推荐包括:显著出血或ST段改变时输血从无不适当,术中血红蛋白≤75 g/L输血从无不适当;术后稳定无症状患者输血阈值为70 g/L(无冠心病)或80 g/L(有冠心病)。
要点
- 术中显著出血或ST段改变时,输血从无不适当。
- 术中血红蛋白≤75 g/L输血从无不适当。
- 术后稳定无症状患者输血阈值:无冠心病70 g/L,有冠心病80 g/L。
核心结论
- 基于最佳证据和专家意见,确定了肝切除术围术期红细胞输注的适当性标准。
研究设计与样本
- 采用RAND/UCLA适当性方法,由肝胆外科、麻醉、输血医学和重症监护的国际多学科专家组对468个围术期场景进行评分。
主要发现
- 约47.4%的场景评为输血适当,28.2%评为不适当,24.4%评为不确定。
- 术中显著出血或ST段改变时输血从无不适当。
- 术中血红蛋白≤75 g/L输血从无不适当。
- 无显著出血或ST改变时,血红蛋白≥95 g/L输血不适当,血红蛋白≥85 g/L输血需强 justification。
- 术后稳定无症状患者输血阈值:无冠心病70 g/L,有冠心病80 g/L;术后即刻或较前一日下降>15 g/L且血红蛋白≤75 g/L时输血适当。
关键数值与推荐
- 术中显著出血或ST段改变时输血从无不适当。
- 术中血红蛋白≤75 g/L输血从无不适当。
- 无显著出血或ST改变时,血红蛋白≥95 g/L输血不适当。
- 无显著出血或ST改变时,血红蛋白≥85 g/L输血需强 justification。
- 术后稳定无症状患者输血阈值:无冠心病70 g/L,有冠心病80 g/L。
临床怎么用
- 肝切除术围术期输血决策可参照本标准,结合出血情况、ST段改变、血红蛋白水平及冠心病史综合判断。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Create practice guidelines for the appropriate use of red blood cell transfusions in hepatectomy. BACKGROUND: Hepatectomy is associated with a high prevalence of transfusions. A transfusion can be life-saving, but can be associated with important adverse effects. Given the prevalence, the potential for benefit and harm, and the difficulty in conducting clinical trials, transfusion in hepatectomy is well-suited for a study of appropriateness. METHODS: Using the RAND/UCLA appropriateness method, an international, multidisciplinary expert panel in hepatobiliary surgery, anesthesia, transfusion medicine, and critical care rated a series of 468 perioperative scenarios for transfusion appropriateness. Scenarios were rated individually, and again during an inperson group moderated session. Median scores and level of agreement were calculated to classify each scenario as appropriate, inappropriate, or uncertain. RESULTS: Approximately, 47.4% of scenarios were rated as appropriate for transfusion, 28.2% were inappropriate, and 24.4% were uncertain. The key recommendations for intraoperative transfusion were (i) it is never inappropriate to transfuse for significant bleeding or ST segment changes; (ii) it is never inappropriate to transfuse for an intraoperative hemoglobin ≤75 g/L; and (iii) in the absence of significant bleeding or ST changes, transfusion for hemoglobin of ≥95 g/L is inappropriate, and transfusion for hemoglobin of ≥85 g/L requires strong justification. The key recommendations for postoperative transfusions were: (i) in a stable, asymptomatic patient, an appropriate transfusion trigger is 70 g/L (without coronary artery disease) or 80 g/L (with coronary artery disease) and (ii) it is appropriate to transfuse any patient for a hemoglobin of ≤75 g/L either immediately post-operative, or with a significant decrease from the previous day (>15 g/L). CONCLUSIONS: Based on best available evidence and expert opinion, criteria for appropriate perioperative red blood cell transfusions in hepatectomy were determined.
引用
- Bennett S, Tinmouth A, McIsaac DI, et al. Ottawa Criteria for Appropriate Transfusions in Hepatectomy: Using the RAND/UCLA Appropriateness Method. Ann Surg. 2018. PMID: 28288056. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000002205
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。