结直肠手术两种醇类消毒剂预防手术部位感染的随机对照试验
该盲法随机非劣效试验比较碘伏醇与氯己定醇在择期清洁-污染结直肠手术中预防手术部位感染的效果,纳入788例意向治疗分析。碘伏醇组总体SSI率为18.7%,氯己定醇组为15.9%,差异2.8%(P=0.30),差异的2.5%置信区间上限为8.9%,超过预设非劣效界值6.6%,碘伏醇未达到非劣效标准。
要点
- 碘伏醇相比氯己定醇未达到预设的非劣效界值,不能认为等效。
- 两组总体SSI率分别为18.7%与15.9%,差异无统计学意义。
- 其他终点如SSI类型、诊断时间和住院时长两组无差异。
核心结论
- 在择期清洁-污染结直肠手术中,碘伏醇在预防总体SSI方面未达到相对于氯己定醇的非劣效性标准。
研究设计与样本
- 盲法、随机、非劣效试验,比较碘伏醇与氯己定醇在择期清洁-污染结直肠手术中的SSI预防效果。
- 2011年1月至2015年1月共随机802例,788例纳入意向治疗分析(碘伏醇组396例,氯己定醇组392例)。
- 主要结局为出院后30天内浅表或深部SSI的发生情况,预设非劣效界值为6.6%。
主要发现
- 碘伏醇组总体SSI率为18.7%,氯己定醇组为15.9%,差异为2.8%(P=0.30)。
- 差异的2.5%置信区间上限为8.9%,大于预设非劣效界值6.6%。
- 包括各类型SSI、SSI诊断时间和住院时长在内的其他终点两组间无差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 非劣效界值为6.6%,差异的2.5%置信区间上限8.9%超过该界值,未满足非劣效标准。
临床怎么用
- 在择期清洁-污染结直肠手术中,不宜将碘伏醇视为与氯己定醇等效的SSI预防消毒剂。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare 2 alcohol-based, dual-action skin preparations for surgical site infection (SSI) prevention in elective colorectal surgery. BACKGROUND: Colorectal surgery is associated with the highest SSI rate among elective surgical procedures. Although evidence indicates that alcohol-based skin preparations are superior in SSI prevention, it is not clear if different alcohol-based preparations are equivalent in clean-contaminated colorectal procedures. METHODS: We performed a blinded, randomized, noninferiority trial comparing iodine povacrylex-alcohol (IPA) and chlorhexidine-alcohol for elective, clean-contaminated colorectal surgery. The primary outcome was the presence or absence of SSI, defined as superficial or deep SSI, within 30 days postdischarge. A 6.6% noninferiority margin was chosen. RESULTS: Between January 2011 and January 2015, 802 patients were randomized with 788 patients included in the intent to treat analysis (396 IPA and 392 chlorhexidine-alcohol). The difference in overall SSI rate between IPA (18.7%) and chlorhexidine-alcohol (15.9%) was 2.8% (P = 0.30). The upper bound of the 2.5% confidence interval of this difference was 8.9%, which is greater than the prespecified noninferiority margin of 6.6%. Other endpoints, including individual SSI types, time to SSI diagnosis, and length of stay were not different between the 2 arms. CONCLUSIONS: In patients undergoing elective, clean contaminated colorectal surgery, the use of IPA failed to meet criterion for noninferiority for overall SSI prevention compared with chlorhexidine-alcohol. Photodocumentation of wounds and rigorous tracking of outcomes up to 30 days postdischarge contributed to high fidelity to current standard SSI descriptions and wound classifications.
引用
- Broach RB, Paulson EC, Scott C, et al. Randomized Controlled Trial of Two Alcohol-based Preparations for Surgical Site Antisepsis in Colorectal Surgery. Ann Surg. 2017. PMID: 28277409. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000002189
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。