预防性阑尾切除术的成本效益:Markov模型
该研究构建Markov决策模型,模拟18至80岁接受择期腹腔镜腹部和盆腔手术的假设患者队列,比较预防性阑尾切除术与保留阑尾的成本与风险。结果显示,在预防性阑尾切除术增加成本660美元的基准假设下,该策略对18-27岁男性和18-28岁女性具有成本节约效应,且节约幅度随年龄增长呈指数变化。
要点
- 预防性阑尾切除术对18-27岁男性和18-28岁女性择期手术患者可节约成本。
- 20岁女性一生可节约130美元,40岁女性则多花费130美元。
- 当预防性阑尾切除术风险超过腹腔镜阑尾切除术或成本超过1080美元时,放弃该手术更节约成本。
核心结论
- 对于接受择期腹腔镜腹部和盆腔手术的30岁以下患者,预防性阑尾切除术可能节约成本。
研究设计与样本
- 构建Markov决策模型,模拟18至80岁接受择期腹腔镜腹部和盆腔手术的假设患者队列,以每生命年成本为主要结局指标。
主要发现
- 在基准假设(预防性阑尾切除术增加成本660美元)下,预防性阑尾切除术对18-27岁男性和18-28岁女性具有成本节约效应。
- 成本节约幅度取决于剩余生命年,并随年龄呈指数变化:20岁女性一生可节约130美元,40岁女性一生多花费130美元。
- 当预防性阑尾切除术风险超过腹腔镜阑尾切除术风险或成本超过1080美元时,放弃预防性手术更节约成本。
关键数值与推荐
- 预防性阑尾切除术的附加成本假设为660美元。
- 成本节约的年龄上限为男性27岁、女性28岁。
- 成本阈值:预防性阑尾切除术成本超过1080美元时,不再具有成本节约优势。
临床怎么用
- 对于30岁以下接受择期腹腔镜腹部或盆腔手术的患者,可考虑同时行预防性阑尾切除术以节约医疗成本。
- 决策时应评估预防性阑尾切除术的风险是否超过腹腔镜阑尾切除术,并考虑成本是否低于1080美元。
局限性
- 研究基于假设队列和文献提取的参数,结论需在真实临床环境中进一步验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Appendectomy is the most common emergency surgery performed in the USA. Removal of a non-inflamed appendix during unrelated abdominal surgery (prophylactic or incidental appendectomy) can prevent the downstream risks and costs of appendicitis. It is unknown whether such a strategy could be cost saving for the health system. METHODS: We considered hypothetical patient cohorts of varying ages from 18 to 80, undergoing elective laparoscopic abdominal and pelvic procedures. A Markov decision model using cost per life-year as the main outcome measure was constructed to simulate the trade-off between cost and risk of prophylactic appendectomy and the ongoing risk of developing appendicitis, with downstream costs and risks. Rates, probabilities, and costs of disease, treatment, and outcomes by patient age and gender were extracted from the literature. Sensitivity analyses were conducted using complications and costs of prophylactic appendectomy. RESULTS: With our base-case assumptions, including added cost of prophylactic appendectomy of $660, we find that prophylactic removal of the appendix is cost saving for males aged 18-27 and females aged 18-28 undergoing elective surgery. The margin of cost savings depends on remaining life-years and increases exponentially with age: a 20-year-old female undergoing elective surgery could save $130 over a lifetime by undergoing prophylactic appendectomy, while a 40-year-old female would lose $130 over a lifetime. When the risk of the prophylactic appendectomy exceeds the risk of laparoscopic appendectomy for appendicitis or the cost exceeds $1080, it becomes more cost saving to forego the prophylactic procedure. CONCLUSIONS: Prophylactic appendectomy can be cost saving for patients younger than age thirty undergoing elective laparoscopic abdominal and pelvic procedures.
引用
- Newhall K, Albright B, Tosteson A, et al. Cost-effectiveness of prophylactic appendectomy: a Markov model. Surg Endosc. 2017. PMID: 28078461. doi:10.1007/s00464-016-5391-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。