建立机器人结直肠癌手术项目:理解机构与个人学习曲线
该研究回顾性分析单中心2009至2014年418例机器人辅助结直肠腺癌切除术,用CUSUM法构建学习曲线。最早开展者需74例完成初始学习阶段,后续术者仅需23-30例;项目建立后学习曲线缩短。
要点
- 建立机器人结直肠癌手术项目约需75例。
- 项目成熟后,后续术者仅需25-30例达到熟练。
- 机构学习曲线超越单个术者的学习经验。
核心结论
- 建立机器人结直肠癌手术项目约需75例。
- 项目建立后学习曲线更短,术者需25-30例达到熟练。
- 机构学习曲线超越单个术者的学习经验。
研究设计与样本
- 最早开展者(术者1)病例量最高,为203例;术者2-4为后续开展者;术者5加入时已有机器人经验。
- 采用累积和(CUSUM)技术构建学习曲线,定义初始学习阶段所需病例数,并分析各学习阶段的围术期变量。
主要发现
- CUSUM分析定义三个学习阶段,最早开展者术者1第一阶段需74例。
- 后续开展者初始学习阶段需23-30例。
- 术者1手术时间从第一阶段250分钟降至第三阶段213.6分钟(P=0.008),术中并发症或漏率无显著变化。
- 术者2-4手术时间从418分钟降至361.9分钟(P=0.004),术中并发症率从7.8%降至0%(P=0.03),漏率无显著差异(9.1% vs. 1.5%,P=0.07),但事件数少可能把握度不足。
关键数值与推荐
- 最早开展者初始学习阶段需74例。
- 后续开展者初始学习阶段需23-30例。
- 建立机器人结直肠癌手术项目约需75例。
- 项目建立后术者需25-30例达到熟练。
临床怎么用
- 规划机器人结直肠癌手术项目时,可参考约75例的机构学习曲线。
- 后续加入的术者若已有机器人经验,初始学习阶段可能缩短至23-30例。
局限性
- 回顾性单中心研究。
- 术者2-4漏率比较事件数少,可能把握度不足。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Robotic colorectal resection continues to gain in popularity. However, limited data are available regarding how surgeons gain competency and institutions develop programs. OBJECTIVE: To determine the number of cases required for establishing a robotic colorectal cancer surgery program. DESIGN: Retrospective review. SETTING: Cancer center. PATIENTS: We reviewed 418 robotic-assisted resections for colorectal adenocarcinoma from January 1, 2009, to December 31, 2014, by surgeons at a single institution. The individual surgeon's and institutional learning curve were examined. The earliest adopter, Surgeon 1, had the highest volume. Surgeons 2-4 were later adopters. Surgeon 5 joined the group with robotic experience. INTERVENTIONS: A cumulative summation technique (CUSUM) was used to construct learning curves and define the number of cases required for the initial learning phase. Perioperative variables were analyzed across learning phases. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Case numbers for each stage of the learning curve. RESULTS: The earliest adopter, Surgeon 1, performed 203 cases. CUSUM analysis of surgeons' experience defined three learning phases, the first requiring 74 cases. Later adopters required 23-30 cases for their initial learning phase. For Surgeon 1, operative time decreased from 250 to 213.6 min from phase 1-3 (P = 0.008), with no significant changes in intraoperative complication or leak rate. For Surgeons 2-4, operative time decreased from 418 to 361.9 min across the two phases (P = 0.004). Their intraoperative complication rate decreased from 7.8 to 0 % (P = 0.03); the leak rate was not significantly different (9.1 vs. 1.5 %, P = 0.07), though it may be underpowered given the small number of events. CONCLUSIONS: Our data suggest that establishing a robotic colorectal cancer surgery program requires approximately 75 cases. Once a program is well established, the learning curve is shorter and surgeons require fewer cases (25-30) to reach proficiency. These data suggest that the institutional learning curve extends beyond a single surgeon's learning experience.
引用
- Guend H, Widmar M, Patel S, et al. Developing a robotic colorectal cancer surgery program: understanding institutional and individual learning curves. Surg Endosc. 2016. PMID: 27815742. doi:10.1007/s00464-016-5292-0
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。