腹腔内疝修补术中液体防粘连剂:Artiss®与CoSeal®、Adept®在大鼠IPOM模型中的比较
该研究在56只Sprague-Dawley大鼠开放IPOM模型中植入2×2 cm中量聚丙烯补片,比较纤维蛋白胶(Artiss®)、艾考糊精(Adept®)与聚乙二醇(CoSeal®)单用或联用的防粘连效果及补片组织整合情况,观察30天。结果显示Artiss®单用或联合Adept®防粘连效果最佳,Adept®单用30天未见显著防粘连作用,PEG虽防粘连效果与FS相当但损害组织整合。
要点
- Artiss®单用或联合Adept®在IPOM大鼠模型中防粘连效果最佳
- Adept®单用30天未显示显著防粘连作用
- PEG防粘连效果与FS相当,但导致补片组织整合受损
核心结论
- 纤维蛋白胶(Artiss®)单用及联合艾考糊精(Adept®)具有优异的防粘连效果,是IPOM修补中最有效的防粘连剂之一。
- 艾考糊精单用30天后未显示显著防粘连作用。
- 聚乙二醇(CoSeal®)防粘连效果与纤维蛋白胶相当,但引起补片组织整合受损。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为动物实验,采用开放IPOM技术,共纳入56只Sprague-Dawley大鼠。
- 植入2×2 cm中量聚丙烯补片,分7组:FS、ID、PEG、FS+ID、FS+PEG、PEG+ID及未覆盖补片的对照组,每组8只。
- 观察期30天,进行宏观与组织学评估。
主要发现
- 严重粘连见于ID组、PEG+ID组及对照组。
- FS单用或FS+ID组效果最佳。
- 各处理组补片组织整合均较对照组降低。
- PEG+ID组有7个样本补片表面组织整合不足50%。
临床怎么用
- 在IPOM修补中可优先考虑纤维蛋白胶(Artiss®)单用或联合艾考糊精以降低粘连。
- 不宜单独使用艾考糊精作为防粘连措施。
- 使用聚乙二醇类防粘连剂时需权衡其防粘连获益与组织整合受损的风险。
局限性
- 研究为大鼠动物模型,结果外推至人体需谨慎。
- 样本量有限,每组8只。
- 观察期仅30天,缺乏长期结局数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Adhesion formation remains an important issue in hernia surgery. Liquid agents were developed for easy and versatile application, especially in laparoscopy. The aim of this study was to compare the antiadhesive effect of fibrin sealant (FS, Artiss®), Icodextrin (ID, Adept®) and Polyethylene glycol (PEG, CoSeal®) alone and in combination and to evaluate the resulting effect on tissue integration of the mesh. METHODS: A total of 56 Sprague-Dawley rats were operated in open IPOM technique. A middleweight polypropylene mesh of 2 × 2 cm size was implanted and covered with 1: FS, 2: ID, 3: PEG, 4: FS + ID, 5: FS + PEG, 6: PEG + ID, 7: control group, uncovered mesh (n = 8 per treatment/control). Observation period was 30 days. Macroscopic and histological evaluation was performed. RESULTS: Severe adhesions were found in group 2 (ID), group 6 (PEG + ID) and the controls. Best results were achieved with FS alone or FS + ID. Mesh integration in the treatment groups was reduced in comparison with the control group. This is a new finding possibly relevant for the outcome of intraperitoneal mesh repair. Group 6 (PEG + ID) showed an impairment of tissue integration with <50 % of the mesh surface in seven samples. CONCLUSION: FS alone and in combination with ID yielded excellent adhesion prevention. ID alone did not show significant adhesion prevention after 30 days. Tissue integration of FS-covered meshes was superior to ID or PEG alone or combined. PEG did show adhesion prevention comparable to FS but evoked impaired tissue integration. So Artiss® is among the most potent antiadhesive agents in IPOM repair.
引用
- Gruber-Blum S, Fortelny RH, Keibl C, et al. Liquid antiadhesive agents for intraperitoneal hernia repair procedures: Artiss® compared to CoSeal® and Adept® in an IPOM rat model. Surg Endosc. 2016. PMID: 27800586. doi:10.1007/s00464-016-5277-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。