咬肌神经-面神经主干吻合术治疗侧颅底肿瘤术后完全性面瘫的解剖与临床研究
本研究分两阶段:先在4具尸头完成8次咬肌神经-面神经主干吻合的解剖学研究,建立标准手术步骤;随后回顾性纳入38例侧颅底肿瘤术后完全性面瘫患者行该手术。结果显示36例成功重建者术后12个月HB分级从术前6级改善至3级,闭眼、口角运动及eFACE评分均显著改善,口眼联动轻微,2例失败与三叉神经严重受损有关。
要点
- 咬肌神经-面神经主干吻合术解剖可行,面神经下干松解后可无张力对接。
- 36例成功重建者术后12个月HB分级由6级改善至3级,闭眼及口角运动明显恢复。
- 伴面部感觉障碍者术前需谨慎评估供体神经功能以降低失败风险。
核心结论
- 咬肌神经-面神经主干吻合术是侧颅底肿瘤术后完全性面瘫可行的重建方法。
- 该技术可显著改善面部静态和动态功能,恢复口角运动并改善抬眉和闭眼功能。
- 术后未引起严重口眼联动;伴面部感觉障碍者应谨慎评估供体神经功能。
研究设计与样本
- 第一阶段为解剖学研究,在4具尸头完成8次咬肌神经转位至面神经主干的解剖学研究。
- 第二阶段为回顾性病例系列研究,纳入2023年3月至2025年3月接受该手术的38例患者。
- 患者男12例、女26例,年龄47(22)岁(范围26~70岁),面瘫时间12(10)个月(范围3~72个月)。
主要发现
- 解剖学显示面神经主干翻转后至咬肌神经距离1.0(0.5)cm(范围0.4~1.4 cm),下干松解后无张力对接距离-0.4(-0.2)cm(范围-0.6~-0.2 cm)。
- 38例中2例(5.3%)手术失败,均与首次术后三叉神经功能严重受损有关;2例(5.3%)出现腮腺漏,经保守治疗好转。
- 36例成功重建者HB分级由术前6(0)级(范围4~6级)改善至术后12个月3(1)级(范围2~4级)(Z=-5.362,P<0.01)。
- 可用力闭眼患者由术前6例增至术后31例(χ²=23.040,P<0.01);口角微小和明显运动出现时间分别为108(43)d(范围51~218 d)和160(75)d(范围77~457 d)。
- eFACE静态及口角运动评分均较术前明显改善(P值均<0.01);口眼联动评分由100(0)分降至90(5)分(Z=-4.760,P<0.01)。
关键数值与推荐
- 面神经主干直接翻转后至咬肌神经距离中位数1.0 cm,下干充分松解后无张力对接距离中位数-0.4 cm。
- 手术失败2例(5.3%),腮腺漏2例(5.3%)。
- HB分级术前中位6级改善至术后12个月中位3级(P<0.01)。
- 口眼联动评分术后中位90分,提示仅轻度联动。
临床怎么用
- 该术式可作为侧颅底肿瘤术后完全性面瘫的重建选择,能改善静态与动态面功能。
- 术前应评估供体神经功能,尤其伴面部感觉障碍者,以降低手术失败风险。
- 术后腮腺漏可经保守治疗好转,需注意围手术期管理。
局限性
- 临床部分为单中心回顾性病例系列研究,样本量38例。
- 解剖学研究仅基于4具尸头、8次操作,解剖参数外推需谨慎。
- 随访时间截至术后12个月,缺乏更长期功能结局数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objectives: To evaluate the anatomical feasibility of masseteric-to-facial nerve trunk transfer and obtain the relevant anatomical parameters, and to assess the surgical feasibility and functional outcomes of this technique in complete facial paralysis following lateral skull base tumor surgery. Methods: The first phase is an anatomical cadaveric study. A total of eight masseteric-to-facial nerve trunk transfers were performed on four cadavers to obtain the anatomical measurements and establish a standardized surgical procedure. The second phase was a retrospective clinical case series study. Thirty-eight patients with complete facial paralysis after lateral skull base tumor surgery who underwent masseteric-to-facial nerve trunk transfer at the Department of Neurosurgery, the Second Affiliated Hospital, Zhejiang University School of Medicine, between March 2023 and March 2025 were included. There were 12 males and 26 females, with an age (M(IQR)) of 47(22)years (range:26 to 70 years). The underlying pathologies included vestibular schwannoma (n=24), paraganglioma (n=5), cholesteatoma (n=3), facial nerve schwannoma (n=3), cavernous hemangioma (n=2), and meningioma (n=1). The duration of facial paralysis was 12(10)months (range:3 to 72 months). Perioperative complications were recorded. Facial nerve function before surgery and 12 months after surgery was evaluated using the House-Brackmann (HB) grade, the electronic clinician-graded facial function scale (eFACE), and oral commissure movement measurements. Pre-and postoperative outcomes were compared using the Wilcoxon signed-rank test or McNemar test. Results: In the anatomical study, the median distance between the rotated facial nerve trunk and the masseteric nerve was 1.0(0.5)cm (range:0.4 to 1.4 cm). After complete mobilization of the inferior division of the facial nerve, tension-free coaptation between the facial nerve trunk and the masseteric nerve was achieved, with a median overlap distance of -0.4(-0.2)cm(range:-0.6 to -0.2 cm). In the 38 clinical cases, surgical failure occurred in 2 patients (5.3%), both of whom had severe trigeminal nerve dysfunction following the initial tumor surgery. Two patients (5.3%) developed postoperative salivary fistula, which resolved with conservative management. Among the remaining 36 successfully reconstructed patients, the median HB grade improved from 6(0) (range:4 to 6) preoperatively to 3(1) (range:2 to 4) at 12 months postoperatively (Z=-5.362, P<0.01). The number of patients able to achieve complete forceful eye closure increased from 6 preoperatively to 31 postoperatively (χ2=23.040,P<0.01). The time to initial and obvious oral commissure movement was 108(43)d (range:51 to 218 d) and 160(75)d (range: 77 to 457 d), respectively. Significant improvements were observed in both static and dynamic eFACE scores (all P<0.01). The synkinesis score decreased from 100(0) to 90(5) (Z=-4.760,P<0.01), indicating only mild postoperative synkinesis. FACE-gram analysis demonstrated significant increases in dynamic oral commissure excursion and excursion amplitude after surgery (all P<0.01). Conclusions: Masseteric-to-facial nerve trunk transfer is a feasible reconstructive option for complete facial paralysis following lateral skull base tumor surgery. This technique significantly improves both static and dynamic facial function, restores oral commissure movement, and provides additional recovery of eyebrow elevation and eye closure without causing severe synkinesis. In patients with concomitant facial sensory deficits, careful preoperative evaluation of donor nerve function is recommended to reduce the risk of surgical failure. 目的: 评估咬肌神经-面神经主干吻合术在解剖学层面的可行性,以及其治疗耳侧颅底肿瘤切除术后重度或完全性面瘫患者的可行性和效果。 方法: 第一阶段研究为解剖学研究。在4具尸头上共完成8次咬肌神经转位至面神经主干的解剖学研究,获取相关解剖学参数以建立标准手术步骤。第二阶段研究为回顾性病例系列研究。纳入2023年3月至2025年3月在浙江大学医学院附属第二医院神经外科接受咬肌神经-面神经主干吻合术的38例耳侧颅底肿瘤切除术后出现重度或完全性面瘫患者38例。男性12例,女性26例,年龄[M(IQR)]47(22)岁(范围:26~70岁)。其中前庭神经瘤24例,副神经节瘤5例,胆脂瘤3例,面神经鞘瘤3例,海绵状血管瘤2例以及脑膜瘤1例。患者面瘫时间为12(10)个月(范围:3~72个月)。记录围手术期并发症,采用House-Brackmann分级、电子化临床面神经麻痹评估量表(eFACE)及口角运动距离评价患者术前与术后12个月的面神经功能变化。手术前后资料的比较采用Wilcoxon符号秩检验或McNemar检验。 结果: 解剖学研究结果显示,面神经主干直接翻转后到咬肌神经的距离为1.0(0.5)cm(范围:0.4~1.4 cm),将面神经下干充分松解后,面神经主干可和咬肌神经无张力对接,距离为-0.4(-0.2)cm(范围:-0.6~-0.2 cm)。在临床病例系列研究的38例患者中,2例(5.3%)在随访期内未出现有效面肌收缩,判定为手术失败,与首次术后三叉神经功能严重受损有关;并发症方面,2例(5.3%)出现腮腺漏,经保守治疗后好转。在手术成功的36例患者中,House-Brackmann分级由术前的6(0)级(范围:4~6级)改善至术后3(1)级(范围:2~4级)(Z=-5.362,P<0.01);可用力闭眼患者由术前的6例增加至术后的31例(χ²=23.040,P<0.01);口角微小运动和明显运动出现时间分别为108(43)d(范围:51~218 d)和160(75)d(范围:77~457 d);eFACE静态及口角运动评分均较术前明显改善(P值均<0.01);口眼联动评分由术前的100(0)分降至术后的90(5)分(Z=-4.760,P<0.01);FACE-gram软件测量结果显示,患者术后口角动态距离及运动幅度均明显增加(P值均<0.01)。 结论: 咬肌神经-面神经主干吻合术治疗耳侧颅底肿瘤术后重度面瘫是可选的临床方法,可明显改善面部静态和动态功能,在恢复口角运动的同时还能改善抬眉和闭眼功能,且未引起严重的口眼联动。对伴有面部感觉障碍的患者,应谨慎评估供体神经功能,以降低失败风险。.
引用
- Wang YJ, Zhang AK, Jin ZY, et al. [Application of masseteric-to-facial nerve trunk transfer in complete facial paralysis after lateral skull base tumor surgery: an anatomical-based analysis and clinical outcome evaluation]. Zhonghua Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2026. PMID: 42951856. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112139-20260422-00165
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。