文献速递疝与腹壁外科

Muysoms A-H-M-T-F 疝修补命名法的国际可重复性:ARMONIA 多中心调查

International reproducibility of the Muysoms A-H-M-T-F nomenclature for standardized reporting of hernia repair: The ARMONIA (Achieving Reliability and Methodologic standardizatiOn in Nomenclature for abdomInal wAll surgery) multicenter survey.
PubMed 文献 · Surgery · 2026-08-07

该国际横断面调查邀请72名有疝修补经验的外科医生独立使用A-H-M-T-F系统编码15个临床场景,其中83%此前未使用过该命名法。结果显示各组成部分的Fleiss kappa为中等至相当程度,完整5组件编码的kappa为0.484,格式标准化后较经典自由文本术语减少72%的命名变异性。

要点

  • 补片位置、疝类型和固定方式的评分者间一致性较高,完整编码一致性为中等。
  • 格式标准化后,Muysoms系统较经典术语减少72%的手术命名变异性。
  • 该命名法在多数首次使用者中仍表现出中等至相当程度的可重复性。

核心结论

  • Muysoms命名法在主要为首次使用者中表现出中等至相当程度的评分者间可重复性,并减少了手术命名变异性。

研究设计与样本

  • 国际横断面调查,邀请有疝修补经验的外科医生独立使用A-H-M-T-F系统编码15个临床场景。
  • 共72名来自4大洲的外科医生完成调查,83%此前未使用过该命名法。

主要发现

  • 模态反应的平均百分比一致性最高为补片位置(99.0%)和疝类型(95.3%),其次为补片类型(93.5%)、固定(89.4%)和入路(87.2%)。
  • Fleiss kappa在补片位置(0.735)、疝类型(0.726)和固定(0.672)为相当程度,入路(0.591)、补片类型(0.559)和完整编码(0.484)为中等。
  • 格式标准化后,Muysoms系统较经典自由文本术语减少72%的手术命名变异性。

临床怎么用

  • 可考虑将Muysoms A-H-M-T-F命名法用于标准化手术报告、登记研究和腹壁外科比较研究。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The proliferation of acronyms in abdominal wall surgery has fragmented procedural language, limiting comparability across studies, registries, and operative reports. The Muysoms A-H-M-T-F nomenclature was proposed to standardize hernia repair description across 5 key dimensions; however, its inter-rater reproducibility among independent surgeons has not previously been evaluated. METHODS: An international cross-sectional survey was conducted among surgeons with hernia repair experience, who were invited to independently code 15 clinical scenarios using the A-H-M-T-F system. For each case, respondents rated their confidence, assigned a classic nomenclature label, and provided qualitative feedback. Percentage agreement and Fleiss' kappa were calculated for each nomenclature component and for the full 5-component code. Variability in classic terminology was compared with Muysoms coding variability before and after format normalization. RESULTS: Seventy-two surgeons from 4 continents completed the survey; 83% had not previously used the nomenclature. Mean percentage agreement on the modal response was highest for mesh position (99.0%) and hernia type (95.3%), followed by mesh type (93.5%), fixation (89.4%), and approach (87.2%). Fleiss' kappa was substantial for mesh position (0.735), hernia type (0.726), and fixation (0.672), and moderate for approach (0.591), mesh type (0.559), and the full code (0.484). After format normalization, the Muysoms system reduced procedural naming variability by 72% compared with classic free-text terminology. CONCLUSION: The Muysoms nomenclature demonstrated moderate-to-substantial inter-rater reproducibility, even among predominantly first-time users, and reduced procedural naming variability. These findings support its potential role in standardized operative reporting, registry-based research, and comparative studies in abdominal wall surgery.

来源:Surgery,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Brucchi F, Formisano G, Bianchi PP, et al. International reproducibility of the Muysoms A-H-M-T-F nomenclature for standardized reporting of hernia repair: The ARMONIA (Achieving Reliability and Methodologic standardizatiOn in Nomenclature for abdomInal wAll surgery) multicenter survey. Surgery. 2026. PMID: 42659984. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2026.110518

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。