远程机器人手术用于战伤救治的可行性验证
该研究由相距1096公里的两所大学医院的外科医生,在尸体标本上双向远程完成胆囊切除与右半结肠切除的分离操作,并电子添加0至300毫秒的延迟。结果显示,网络延迟28毫秒、抖动0.03毫秒、零丢包;总延迟78至378毫秒下,右半结肠切除手术时间反而随总延迟下降(P=0.005),总体操作表现各维度维持在4/5至5/5且与总延迟无关,作者认为战伤远程机器人手术高度可行。
要点
- 经验丰富的机器人外科医生能快速适应远程延迟,操作表现与总延迟无关
- 右半结肠切除手术时间随总延迟增加反而减少(P=0.005),胆囊切除无此变化(P=0.47)
- 手术任务负荷与外科医生经验强相关(P<0.001),与总延迟无关(P=0.47)
核心结论
- 经验丰富的机器人外科医生能快速形成对远程机器人延迟的认知与运动适应,战伤远程机器人手术高度可行。
- 研究数据提示对延迟的耐受度显著高于既往报道,但卫星远程可能带来比光纤民用场景更大的延迟。
研究设计与样本
- 两所相距1096公里的大学医院的外科医生在尸体标本上双向远程完成胆囊切除与右半结肠切除的分离操作。
- 电子添加0至300毫秒的延迟,并测定网络性能、手术室时间、总体操作表现(GP)与手术任务负荷指数(TLX),统计方法为简单线性回归。
主要发现
- 网络延迟28毫秒、抖动0.03毫秒、零丢包,计入机器人固有延迟50毫秒后总延迟为78至378毫秒。
- 4名外科医生共完成12例胆囊切除与14例右半结肠切除,右半结肠切除手术时间随总延迟下降(P=0.005),胆囊切除无变化(P=0.47)。
- 手术室时间与普外科医生经验强相关(P=0.024);TLX与经验强相关(P<0.001)而与总延迟无关(P=0.47)。
- GP在所有维度持续处于4/5至5/5之间,且与总延迟无关(P=0.41)。
临床怎么用
- 提示在光纤网络条件下,经验丰富的机器人外科医生可耐受最高约378毫秒的总延迟完成远程分离操作,为战伤远程手术部署提供参考。
- 术前应关注术者机器人手术经验,因其与手术时间和任务负荷密切相关。
局限性
- 研究在尸体标本上完成,非活体战伤伤员,出血与组织条件与实战不同。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: These experiments test the feasibility of tele-robotic surgery for the shipboard care of combat casualties. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: Limited research on the effects of telecommunications latency on tele-robotics has been a consistent concern in the growth of tele-robotic surgery. These experiments are designed to provide well-controlled real-world data on robotic surgical performance with electronically added latency that simulates combat-relevant, satellite-based tele-robotic communication. METHODS: Surgeons at 2 university hospitals separated by 1096 km bi-directionally performed remote cholecystectomy (Ch) and right colectomy (Co) dissections on cadaver subjects. Varying latency between 0 and 300 ms was electronically added. Network performance, OR time, Global Performance (GP), and Surgery Task Load Index (TLX) were determined. Statistical analysis: simple linear regression. RESULTS: Network latency was 28 ms, jitter 0.03 ms, with zero packet loss. Including robotic intrinsic latency of 50 ms, total latency (TOT) varied from 78 to 378 ms. 12 Ch and 14 Co were performed by 4 surgeons. Co OR time unexpectedly decreased with TOT ( P =0.005), but Ch did not ( P =0.47). OR time was strongly associated with general surgeon experience ( P =0.024). TLX was strongly associated with surgeon experience ( P <0.001) but not TOT ( P =0.47). GP was consistently between 4/5 and 5/5 across all domains and did not correlate with TOT ( P =0.41). Each surgeon showed rapid cognitive and motor adaptation to increasing latency. CONCLUSIONS: Experienced robotic surgeons rapidly develop cognitive and motor adaptation to tele-robotic latency. Satellite-based tele-robotic surgery in combat environments may add greater latency than fiber-optic-connected civilian applications. Our data indicate a significantly greater tolerance for latency than previously reported. Development of telerobotic surgery for combat casualties is highly feasible.
引用
- Merchant T, Bianco F, Dyke MC, et al. Tele-Robotic Surgery for Combat Casualty Care: Proof of Feasibility. Ann Surg. 2026. PMID: 42613656. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000007178
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。