迈向独立:可信赖专业活动评分反映的信任进展
美国外科委员会自2016年引入可信赖专业活动(EPA)作为 competency-based 教育评估框架。本研究基于2023年7月至2025年7月PGY-1至PGY-5住院医师的国家ABS EPA数据,比较不同EPA、阶段和培训年份的微型评估。结果显示不同手术操作达到间接监督/实践就绪的中位形成性评估时间不同,可识别快速信任进展期和需要额外支持的目标。
要点
- 多种腹腔内手术操作在PGY-3即有超过半数住院医师达到间接监督/实践就绪的中位形成性评估。
- 结肠疾病、胆囊疾病、腹股沟疝和甲状腺/甲状旁腺疾病进展较慢,至PGY-4才达到半数以上。
- 软组织感染进展更早,PGY-2即有54.8%达到间接监督或更高。
核心结论
- EPA的引入和向 competency-based 评估的转变能够识别信任快速进展的时期,并支持识别可能促进 competency-based 培训框架发展的目标。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析国家ABS EPA数据,纳入2023年7月至2025年7月PGY-1至PGY-5住院医师,共9,932名住院医师来自345个项目,包含185,901次EPA微型评估。
主要发现
- 在PGY-3水平,超过半数住院医师在多种腹腔内手术操作上达到间接监督/实践就绪的中位形成性评估,包括阑尾炎(58.2%,n=819)、腹壁疝(50.4%,n=618)、乳腺疾病(52.7%,n=309)和皮肤/皮下肿瘤(66%,n=325)。
- 结肠疾病(73.4%,n=756)、胆囊疾病(86.6%,n=1410)、腹股沟疝(76.5%,n=734)和甲状腺/甲状旁腺疾病(61.3%,n=184)进展较慢,至PGY-4水平才达到50%的住院医师。
- 软组织感染进展更早,PGY-2水平即有54.8%(n=355)达到间接监督或更高。
临床怎么用
- 可利用EPA评分变化识别住院医师在特定操作上的信任进展,为需要额外支持者提供早期干预依据。
- 针对进展较慢的EPA(如结肠、胆囊、腹股沟疝、甲状腺/甲状旁腺疾病)可在PGY-3至PGY-4阶段加强针对性培训。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In 2016 the American Board of Surgery introduced Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) as an assessment framework to support competency-based education within general surgery. EPAs operationalize milestones and competencies into a practical assessment framework, enabling timely, targeted feedback and progressive entrustment. OBJECTIVE: We hypothesize that variability in trainee entrustment may identify specific EPAs that function as performance targets, allowing earlier identification of trainees who may need additional support. METHODS: National ABS EPA data for PGY-1 through PGY-5 residents from July 2023 to July 2025 were reviewed. Microassessments (MAs) using the ABS entrustment scale (1=Limited Participation; 4=Practice Ready) were compared by EPA, phase, and postgraduate year. Descriptive statistics summarized formative entrustment ratings and progression within postgraduate year. RESULTS: Subjects included 9,932 residents from 345 programs, with 185,901 EPA MAs. For several intraoperative EPAs, over half of trainees achieved a median formative assessment of Indirect Supervision/Practice Ready at the PGY-3 level, including appendicitis (58.2%, n=819), abdominal wall hernia (50.4%, n=618), breast disease (52.7%, n=309), and cutaneous/subcutaneous neoplasm (66%, n=325). Colon disease (73.4%, n=756), gallbladder disease (86.6%, n=1410), inguinal hernia (76.5%, n=734), and thyroid/parathyroid disease (61.3%, n=184) showed a slower progression, not achieving 50% of residents until the PGY-4 level. Earlier progression was noted for soft tissue infection with 54.8% (n=355) attaining indirect supervision or higher at the PGY-2 level. CONCLUSIONS: The introduction of EPAs and shift towards competency-based assessment enables the identification of periods of rapid entrustment progression and supports the identification of targets that may facilitate the development of a competency-based training framework.
引用
- Diaconescu A, Kasmirski J, White E, et al. The Path to Independence: Progression in Entrustment Reflected in Entrustable Professional Activity Ratings. Ann Surg. 2026. PMID: 42277576. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000007114
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。