肝脏体积测量软件的技术性能与临床应用:叙述性综述
本叙述性综述总结了11种常用肝脏体积测量(LV)软件的技术特点、性能与临床适用性。手动描边仍是参考标准但操作者依赖性强、耗时长、可重复性低;半自动工具减少变异性并缩短时间,自动平台与手动或移植物重量参考高度一致,但多数仍需手动勾画。软件比较因缺乏标准化验证方案而受限,需多中心标准化研究明确相对优势。
要点
- 手动描边是参考标准,但操作者依赖性强、耗时长、可重复性低。
- 半自动与自动平台缩短处理时间并与参考标准高度一致,但多数仍需手动勾画。
- 软件间比较受限于缺乏标准化验证方案,需多中心标准化研究。
核心结论
- 新兴证据支持肝脏体积测量软件的临床效用,但需多中心标准化研究明确相对优势并促进一致应用。
研究设计与样本
- 叙述性综述,总结11种广泛使用的肝脏体积测量工具的特征、性能与临床适用性。
主要发现
- 手动描边仍是参考标准,但操作者依赖性强、执行时间长、可重复性低。
- 半自动工具减少用户变异性并缩短处理时间;Synapse无明显学习曲线,Syngo.via需用户培训。
- Hermes整合SPECT功能数据,对PHLF预测更优,但与活体肝移植实际移植物重量相关性欠精确。
- LiverVision、Myrian XP-Liver和Vitrea等自动平台与手动或移植物重量参考高度一致且执行时间更短。
- 多数工具仍需手动勾画,尤其用于解剖 delineation 和排除血管或胆道结构;LISA等全自动工具仍处实验阶段缺乏临床验证。
临床怎么用
- 术前规划肝切除或活体肝移植时可选用半自动或自动体积测量软件以缩短时间并减少变异性。
- 需注意多数软件仍需手动勾画解剖边界及排除血管胆道结构,不能完全依赖自动化结果。
- 选择软件时应考虑学习曲线与培训需求,如Syngo.via需用户培训而Synapse无明显学习曲线。
局限性
- 缺乏标准化验证方案,研究间指标变异大,且以专有产品为主,软件比较困难且受限。
- 全自动工具如LISA仍处实验阶段,缺乏临床验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Liver volumetry (LV) is essential in preoperative planning for liver resection and living donor liver transplantation, particularly in extended resections, where minimizing the risk of post-hepatectomy liver failure (PHLF) and ensuring donor safety are pivotal. Several software platforms have been developed to support LV, employing different segmentation techniques, from manual to semi-automated and fully automated, based on contrast-enhanced computed tomography (CT) or, less frequently, magnetic resonance imaging. MAIN FINDINGS: Manual tracing remains the reference standard but it is limited by high operator dependency, long execution times, and low reproducibility. Semi-automated tools reduce user variability and shorten processing time. Synapse has shown no evident learning curve, while Syngo.via requires user training. Hermes, integrating functional data from SPECT, offers superior prediction of PHLF but less precise correlation with actual graft weight in living donor liver transplantation. Automated platforms such as LiverVision, Myrian XP-Liver, and Vitrea have demonstrated strong agreement with manual or graft weight references and shorter execution times. However, most tools still require manual contouring, particularly for anatomical delineation and exclusion of vessels or biliary structures. Fully automated tools such as LISA remain experimental and lack clinical validation. Software comparison remains challenging and limited due to the absence of standardized validation protocols, metrics variations across studies, and the predominance of proprietary conditions. CONCLUSION: The aim of this narrative review is to summarize the available features, performances and clinical applicability of 11 widely used LV tools. While emerging evidence supports their clinical utility, further multicenter studies using standardized methodologies are needed to clarify their relative advantages and promote consistent use in surgical practice.
引用
- Al Harakeh H, Esposito G, Odorizzi R, et al. Liver volumetry software: a narrative review of technical performance and clinical utility. Surg Endosc. 2026. PMID: 42151462. doi:10.1007/s00464-026-12877-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。