微创时代开放手术与中转开放手术的特征:对医师费用表的影响
该研究分析2023年ACS NSQIP数据库中105,085例腹部盆腔手术,将病例分为微创、直接开放和中转开放。结果显示开放手术已不常见且多为中转开放,中转开放手术时间更长、住院更久、并发症更多,现行CPT编码可能未反映其复杂性。
要点
- 开放腹部盆腔手术已不常见,中转开放占开放阑尾切除和胆囊切除约一半。
- 中转开放手术时间最长,阑尾切除超微创147%,胆囊切除超微创116%。
- 直接开放阑尾切除住院率比为2.92、并发症OR为4.02,中转开放进一步升高。
核心结论
- 当代开放腹部盆腔手术不常见且常为中转开放,此类病例手术更长、住院更久、并发症更高。
- 现行CPT编码和work RVU可能未反映开放手术的临床复杂性和工作量,支持重新评估开放手术的估值。
研究设计与样本
- 分析2023年美国外科医师学会NSQIP数据库,纳入阑尾切除、胆囊切除、右半结肠切除、低位前切除和Hartmann手术。
- 病例分为微创、直接开放和中转开放,比较患者特征、手术时间、住院时长和30天并发症,使用二项回归模型。
主要发现
- 共105,085例手术,微创在阑尾切除(98%)、胆囊切除(98%)、低位前切除(84%)和右半结肠切除(72%)中占主导,Hartmann手术主要为开放(77%)。
- 中转开放约占开放阑尾切除和胆囊切除的一半,手术时间最长,阑尾切除超微创147%,胆囊切除超微创116%。
- 与微创相比,直接开放阑尾切除住院率比2.92、并发症OR 4.02,中转开放阑尾切除住院率比4.85、并发症OR 7.07。
- 从微创到直接开放再到中转开放,各手术均观察到类似的阶梯式变化。
临床怎么用
- 外科医生和编码人员应认识到开放手术常代表中转开放,其复杂性和工作量高于微创。
- 评估开放手术时需考虑更高并发症风险和更长住院时间,可能影响费用表制定。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: CPT valuation historically treated open and minimally invasive (MIS) abdominopelvic operations as interchangeable services performed on similar patients. As MIS has become the dominant approach, open operation may now represent a distinct and more complex clinical scenario. This study characterized contemporary open operation for common abdominopelvic procedures. STUDY DESIGN: The 2023 American College of Surgeons NSQIP database was analyzed for appendectomy, cholecystectomy, right colectomy, low anterior resection, and Hartmann's procedure. Cases were categorized as MIS, straight to open, or conversion to open. Patient characteristics, operative time, length of stay, and 30-day complications were compared across approaches using binomial regression models. RESULTS: Among 105,085 operations, MIS predominated for appendectomy (98%), cholecystectomy (98%), low anterior resection (84%), and right colectomy (72%), whereas Hartmann's procedures were primarily open (77%). Conversions represented approximately half of open appendectomies and cholecystectomies and had the longest operative times, exceeding MIS operations by 147% for appendectomy and 116% for cholecystectomy. Compared with MIS, straight-to-open appendectomy was associated with increased length of stay (incident rate ratio 2.92) and higher complication odds (odds ratio 4.02), with conversion-to-open appendectomy showing further stepwise increases (incident rate ratio 4.85; odds ratio 7.07). Similar stepwise patterns from MIS to straight-to-open to conversion-to-open were observed across procedures. CONCLUSIONS: In contemporary practice, open abdominopelvic operations are uncommon and frequently represent conversion from MIS, identifying a subgroup with longer operations, longer hospitalization, and higher complication rate. Current CPT coding and work relative value units may not reflect the greater clinical complexity and effort associated with these cases, supporting reconsideration of open procedure valuation.
引用
- Childers CP, Sutherland MJ, Selzer DJ, et al. Characteristics of Open and Conversion-to-Open Operation in a Minimally Invasive Era: Implications for the Physician Fee Schedule. J Am Coll Surg. 2026. PMID: 41955253. doi:10.1097/XCS.0000000000001940
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。