文献速递胃肠外科急腹症与外科感染围术期管理与 ERAS

内镜与手术治疗医源性结肠穿孔:GRADE系统评价与荟萃分析

Endoscopic versus surgical management for iatrogenic colonic perforations: a GRADE-assessed systematic review and meta-analysis of cohort studies.
PubMed 文献 · Surg Endosc · 2026-03-11

该系统评价纳入4项回顾性队列共123例成人医源性结肠穿孔患者(内镜组52例、手术组71例),比较内镜闭合与手术的结局。内镜组住院时间更短(MD -9.23天,95%CI -13.74至-4.73),治疗成功率与死亡率无明确差异,但证据确定性低至极低,且存在明显适应证混杂。

要点

  • 内镜闭合多用于即刻识别、较小穿孔且临床情况稳定者,手术多用于延迟诊断或污染重者。
  • 内镜组住院时间较手术组缩短约9.23天,但证据确定性低。
  • 治疗成功率与死亡率差异不明确,不能据此认为两种方式等效。

核心结论

  • 在观察性队列中,内镜闭合与手术的治疗成功率无明确差异(RR 1.00,95%CI 0.94-1.06;I2=0%;低确定性)。
  • 死亡率事件少且估计不精确(8例事件;RR 0.26,95%CI 0.06-1.16;I2=0%;极低确定性)。
  • 内镜管理组住院时间更短(MD -9.23天,95%CI -13.74至-4.73;I2=43%;低确定性)。
  • 因适应证混杂明显,合并估计不应被解读为两种方式等效的证据。

研究设计与样本

  • PROSPERO注册(CRD420251233077)的GRADE评估系统评价与荟萃分析。
  • 纳入4项回顾性队列,共123例(内镜52例、手术71例),来自葡萄牙、韩国和马来西亚。
  • 两位评价者独立筛选、提取数据,并用ROBINS-I评估偏倚。
  • 采用随机效应模型合并风险比(RR)与均数差(MD),GRADE评级确定证据确定性。

主要发现

  • 治疗成功率:RR 1.00,95%CI 0.94-1.06;I2=0%;低确定性。
  • 住院时间:内镜组更短,MD -9.23天,95%CI -13.74至-4.73;I2=43%;低确定性。
  • 死亡率:8例事件,RR 0.26,95%CI 0.06-1.16;I2=0%;极低确定性。
  • 空腹时间无显著差异且存在异质性。
  • 未检测到地理亚组效应(P=0.95);敏感性分析总体稳健,但住院时间异质性受一项研究的转诊病例影响。

关键数值与推荐

  • 内镜闭合适用于即刻识别、穿孔<2 cm、无弥漫性腹膜炎或血流动力学不稳定的经选择患者。
  • 手术优先用于延迟诊断、较大缺损或怀疑污染者。
  • 诊断性结肠镜穿孔率0.016-0.2%,治疗性结肠镜0.15-5%,报告死亡率15-25%。

临床怎么用

  • 对即刻识别、缺损<2 cm且无弥漫性腹膜炎或不稳定的患者,内镜闭合可作为可行的一线策略。
  • 内镜闭合可能缩短住院时间,但需结合患者选择与穿孔特征谨慎决策。
  • 延迟诊断、较大缺损或怀疑污染者应优先考虑手术。
  • 解读现有合并结果时须考虑适应证混杂,不能据此认为内镜与手术等效。

局限性

  • 仅纳入4项回顾性队列,总样本量123例,死亡率事件少导致估计不精确。
  • 内镜与手术患者基线特征不同,存在明显适应证混杂。
  • 空腹时间等结局存在异质性,住院时间异质性部分源于一项研究的转诊病例。
  • 缺乏前瞻性多中心研究及标准化定义与严格混杂调整。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Iatrogenic colonic perforation is a rare but potentially catastrophic complication of colonoscopy (0.016-0.2% diagnostic; 0.15-5% therapeutic) with reported mortality of 15-25%. Rates may increase with expanding colonoscopy volume and advanced therapeutic interventions. Endoscopic closure is increasingly used, yet comparative outcomes remain uncertain. METHODS: Registered in PROSPERO (CRD420251233077). We searched six databases from inception to November 2025 for adult observational cohorts comparing endoscopic closure versus surgery. Outcomes included treatment success, mortality, major morbidity, reoperation, length of stay, and fasting duration. Two reviewers independently screened studies, extracted data, and assessed bias using ROBINS-I. Random-effects models pooled risk ratios (RR) and mean differences (MD); GRADE rated certainty. Sensitivity and geographic subgroup analyses assessed robustness and effect modification. RESULTS: Four retrospective cohorts (n = 123; 52 endoscopic, 71 surgical) from Portugal, Korea, and Malaysia were included across care settings. Treatment success showed no clear difference (RR 1.00, 95% CI 0.94-1.06; I2 = 0%; low certainty). Mortality was rare and imprecise (8 events; RR 0.26, 95% CI 0.06-1.16; I2 = 0%; very low certainty). Hospital stay was shorter with endoscopic management (MD - 9.23 days, 95% CI - 13.74 to - 4.73; I2 = 43%; low certainty). Fasting duration did not differ significantly and was heterogeneous. No geographic subgroup effect was detected (P = 0.95). Sensitivity analysis supported robustness, except for hospital-stay heterogeneity driven by referred cases in one study. CONCLUSIONS: In observational cohorts, endoscopic closure was typically used for immediately recognized, smaller perforations in favorable clinical conditions, whereas surgery was preferentially used for delayed diagnosis, larger defects, or suspected contamination, introducing substantial confounding by indication. Accordingly, the pooled estimates should not be interpreted as evidence of equivalence. In carefully selected patients (immediate recognition, < 2 cm, no generalized peritonitis/instability), endoscopic closure appears to be a viable first-line strategy and may reduce length of stay. Prospective multicenter studies with standardized definitions and rigorous confounder adjustment are needed.

来源:Surg Endosc,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Mirza W, Khan ME, Iqbal H, et al. Endoscopic versus surgical management for iatrogenic colonic perforations: a GRADE-assessed systematic review and meta-analysis of cohort studies. Surg Endosc. 2026. PMID: 41814000. doi:10.1007/s00464-026-12735-3

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。