机器人肝手术全球概览:国际调查研究结果
该国际在线调查收集了对机器人肝手术有经验或兴趣的肝胆外科医生的数据,分析机器人平台使用、采用率、学习曲线、手术选择及限制因素。结果显示da Vinci平台最常用,使用模式存在差异,结构化学习对安全开展至关重要,学习曲线是多步骤过程且取决于手术类型等因素。
要点
- da Vinci平台是最常用的机器人平台,新系统仍处于早期采用阶段。
- 结构化学习(模拟、督导、第二控制台学习)被认为是安全开展机器人肝手术的关键。
- 低复杂度切除中腹腔镜、机器人和开腹方法被认为相对相似;后上段、大范围肝切除及重建病例分别首选机器人、开腹或机器人联合开腹。
核心结论
- 机器人肝手术在肝胆外科中逐渐被采用,但分布不均。
- 统一的培训模式、组织结构和系统平等可及性是决定机器人系统扩展的关键因素。
研究设计与样本
- 国际在线调查研究,对象为有机器人肝手术经验或兴趣的肝胆外科医生,使用描述性统计分析收集的回复。
主要发现
- da Vinci平台最常用,新系统仍处于早期采用阶段。
- 使用模式存在变异性。
- 结构化学习包括模拟、督导和第二控制台学习,被认为是确保安全采用的关键。
- 学习曲线是多步骤过程,取决于手术类型、固有手术技能和既往培训。
- 低复杂度切除中腹腔镜、机器人和开腹方法被认为相对相似;后上段、大范围肝切除及重建病例分别首选机器人、开腹或机器人联合开腹。
临床怎么用
- 开展机器人肝手术应建立包括模拟、督导和第二控制台学习的结构化培训。
- 根据手术复杂度和部位选择机器人、开腹或联合入路:低复杂度切除可考虑腹腔镜、机器人或开腹;后上段和大范围肝切除首选机器人或开腹;重建病例考虑机器人联合开腹。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Robotic liver surgery has gradually increased within the realm of minimally invasive hepatobiliary surgery; nevertheless, worldwide adoption rates, educational systems, and thought processes are various. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An online worldwide survey was devised to collect data from hepatobiliary surgeons with experience or interests in robotic liver surgery. The design explores the use of robotic platforms, adoption rate, learning opportunities, learning curves, procedural options based on complexity, safety in perioperative phases, and limiting factors. Descriptive statistics are used to analyze the collected responses. RESULTS: The da Vinci platform is the most commonly used, while the new systems are still in the early adoption stages. Variability of use patterns has been identified. Structured learning, including simulation, proctoring, and learning at a second console, has been identified as essential to ensure safe adoption. The learning curve is a multi-step process that is dependent on procedure type, inherent surgical skills, and prior training. The laparoscopic, robotic, and open methods are considered to be relatively similar in low-complexity resections, while robotic, open, or a combination of robotic or open would be preferred for directing posterosuperior, major hepatectomy, as well as reconstruction cases, respectively. CONCLUSION: Robotic liver surgery is gradually being adopted within the realm of hepatobiliary surgery, but has been unevenly distributed. Uniform models of training, organizational structure, and equal availability of systems are essential factors that define how such systems are expanded.
引用
- Caringi S, Delvecchio A, Casella A, et al. Robotic liver surgery: a global snapshot. Results from an international survey. Surg Endosc. 2026. PMID: 41776097. doi:10.1007/s00464-026-12582-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。