术后并发症分级量表现状:一项系统综述
该系统综述纳入79篇文献,评估术后并发症分级量表的开发、改编、比较与验证。Clavien-Dindo分级(CDC)与综合并发症指数(CCI)最常用;36项比较研究中33项(92%)认为CCI在住院时间或费用等指标上优于CDC。作者主张研究中使用CCI,临床中认可CDC的实用性。
要点
- CDC是使用最广泛的术后并发症分级量表。
- CCI在住院时间等结局指标上相关性优于CDC。
- 建议研究采用CCI,临床可依专科调整使用CDC。
核心结论
- CDC为最常用的术后并发症分级量表,CCI与结局指标相关性更好。
- 作者主张研究中使用CCI,临床中认可CDC的实用性并可按外科专科适当调整。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述纳入79篇开发、改编、比较和/或验证成人术后并发症分级量表的文献。
- 两名研究者独立评估文献,排除预后或预测评分、疾病/症状/操作特异性分类及评论、信件和回复。
主要发现
- 79篇文章中6篇(8%)引入新分级量表,7篇(9%)提出改编。
- 验证和/或比较研究使用的结局指标包括住院时间(n=46,58%)、生活质量(n=4,5%)和/或医疗费用(n=11,14%)。
- 36项比较CDC与CCI的研究中33项(92%)基于住院时间或费用等特定结局指标认为CCI优于CDC。
- 以住院时间为比较结局指标的27项研究中26项(96%)显示CCI与住院时间的相关性优于CDC。
临床怎么用
- 临床可继续使用CDC进行术后并发症分级,但宜结合外科专科特点适当调整。
- 研究场景中可优先选用CCI以更好地反映住院时间等结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To describe the existing classifications for grading postoperative complications and provide insight into their strengths and limitations. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Classifications for grading postoperative complications aim to standardize outcome reporting and improve postoperative patient care. Several grading scales exist; however, comprehensive comparisons of these systems are limited in the literature.Methods:A systematic review of the available literature that developed, adapted, compared, and/or validated scores for postoperative complications in adult patients undergoing any surgical intervention was conducted. Two researchers independently assessed the literature, excluding prognostic or predictive scores, disease-, symptom-, or procedure-specific classifications, as well as comments, letters, and replies. RESULTS: A total of 79 articles were included, with 6 articles (8%) introducing a new grading scale and 7 articles (9%) proposing adaptations. The Clavien-Dindo Classification (CDC) and the Comprehensive Complication Index (CCI) were the most commonly used grading scales. Studies that validated and/or compared classifications used length of stay (LoS) (n=46, 58%), quality of life (QoL) (n=4, 5%), and/or medical costs (n=11, 14%) as outcome indicators. From the 36 studies comparing the CDC to the CCI, 33 (92%) concluded superiority of the CCI over the CDC based on specific outcome indicators such as LoS or cost. Correlation of the CCI with LoS was superior to the CDC in 26 of the 27 studies (96%) using LoS as a comparative outcome indicator. CONCLUSIONS: This systematic review examined grading scales for postoperative complications, highlighting the CDC as the most used and the CCI as better correlated with outcome indicators. The authors advocate for the CCI in research while recognizing the CDC's practicality in clinical care if appropriately tailored to surgical specialties.
引用
- Fischer RMJ, Vos TJ, Hoeks SE, et al. The Current State of Postoperative Complication Grading Scales: A Systematic Review. Ann Surg. 2025. PMID: 41489378. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000006947
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。