距终点五年:全球外科委员会以来的进展与意外后果
本文回顾了2015年柳叶刀全球外科委员会提出2030目标后的进展与争议。尽管学术项目、联盟和基础设施有所增长,但委员会六项指标中四项已纳入世界发展指标,然而各国对这些指标的报告却显著下降(部分全球降至0%),难以客观评估进展。文章讨论了专科外科人力密度、地理可及性、财务风险保护和手术量等基准的进展与争议,并提出了九方面框架建议。
要点
- 全球外科运动在学术项目、联盟和任务共享模型方面有积极增长。
- 委员会六项指标中四项已纳入世界发展指标,但国家报告率显著下降。
- 文章提出九方面框架以推动进展,并关注意外后果如负面框架和外科医生中心化。
核心结论
- 全球外科委员会2030目标提出后,学术和联盟有增长,但指标报告下降,进展难以客观评估。
- 文章讨论了四项基准的进展与争议,并识别了若干意外后果,提出九方面框架建议。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为综述/评论文章,旨在讨论全球外科委员会基准的进展与争议及意外后果。
主要发现
- 自2016年以来,委员会六项指标中有四项已整合入世界发展指标。
- 国家对这些指标的报告显著下降,部分情况下全球降至0%。
- 学术全球外科项目、中心、联盟、学生倡导、基础设施和任务共享模型有积极增长。
- 全球外科的框架从短期南北任务旅行转向具有新兴文献的学科。
关键数值与推荐
- 委员会六项指标中四项已纳入世界发展指标。
- 国家报告下降,部分指标全球报告率降至0%。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应关注全球外科指标报告下降对进展评估的影响。
- 在参与全球外科项目时,注意避免外科医生中心化和忽视实施能力。
局限性
- 使用10年前的数据,距终点仅5年。
- 国家报告下降导致难以客观评估进展。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The year 2015 was a landmark year for global surgical care due to the publication of the 2030 targets of the Lancet Commission on Global Surgery. The Lancet report catalysed the global surgery movement amidst warnings of the movement's fragmentation, exclusivity, and leaning towards the Global North. Since then, there has been positive growth in academic global surgery programmes and centres, surgery coalitions, student advocacy, infrastructure, and task-sharing models, and a shift in the framing of global surgery from brief north-south mission trips to an academic discipline with burgeoning literature. Since 2016, four of the commission's six indicators have been integrated into the World Development Indicators. However, there has been a significant decline in the national reporting of these indicators (in some instances to 0% globally), making it difficult to objectively assess progress. The aim of this article is to discuss the progress and controversies surrounding the commission's benchmarks for specialist surgical workforce density, geographical access to surgical care, financial risk protection for surgical care, and surgical volume and reporting of perioperative mortality, as well as to discuss some unintended consequences since the commission, including the challenge of negative framing, the creation of a surgeon-focused movement, the expansion of a largely academic field with little focus on implementers, emphasis on high-level advocacy without a similar focus on grassroots advocacy, hyper-emphasis on surgical plans without appropriate focus on implementation capacity, relegation of community-based care and prevention as a component of global surgery, and the challenge of the use of 10-year-old data, 5 years to the finish line. Finally, broad recommendations for progress are suggested using a nine-pronged framework.
引用
- Alayande BT, Bekele A. Five years to the finish line: progress and unintended consequences since the Lancet Commission on Global Surgery. Br J Surg. 2025. PMID: 41369657. doi:10.1093/bjs/znaf205
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。