标准伤口敷料与预防性闭合切口负压治疗对开放式腹壁切口疝修补术后手术部位感染的影响:多中心随机临床试验
PROPRESS多中心RCT在丹麦三家医院纳入110例择期开放式腹壁切口疝修补患者,随机分为标准伤口敷料(SWD)组和闭合切口负压治疗(ciNPT)组,主要结局为30天手术部位感染(SSI)发生率。结果显示SWD组SSI为8%(4/53),ciNPT组为13%(7/55),差异无统计学意义(P=0.673);手术部位 occurrences(SSOs)、瘢痕评分及生活质量组间均无差异。结论认为ciNPT未降低SSI,但研究受样本量较小限制。
要点
- ciNPT组30天SSI发生率为13%(7/55),SWD组为8%(4/53),差异无统计学意义(P=0.673)。
- 两组SSOs、瘢痕评分及生活质量变化均无显著差异。
- ciNPT未降低开放式腹壁切口疝修补术后SSI,但研究样本量较小。
核心结论
- 在开放式腹壁切口疝修补术后,预防性闭合切口负压治疗(ciNPT)与标准伤口敷料相比未降低30天手术部位感染(SSI)发生率。
研究设计与样本
- PROPRESS多中心随机对照试验于2023年3月1日至2024年6月25日在丹麦三家医院开展,纳入110例择期开放式腹壁切口疝修补患者,随机分为ciNPT组(56例)和标准伤口敷料(SWD)组(54例)。
- 患者中位年龄63.9岁(四分位距50.7–69.0),女性45例(40.1%),吸烟者7例(6.4%),平均BMI 29.3(标准差4.1)kg/m2,平均水平缺损尺寸8.7(标准差4.7)cm;108例(98.2%)完成30天随访。
主要发现
- 30天SSI发生率:SWD组4/53(8%),ciNPT组7/55(13%),P=0.673。
- 30天SSOs发生率:SWD组12/53(23%),ciNPT组14/55(26%),P=0.907。
- 瘢痕评分两组平均分均为24,P=0.892;总体生活质量显著改善(平均评分差-12.8,95%CI -15.4至-10.2,P<0.001),但组间无差异(SWD组平均变化-12.6 vs ciNPT组-13.0,P=0.874)。
- 每组各有一例死亡,与干预无关,但手术和麻醉可能是死亡诱因。
临床怎么用
- 对于择期开放式腹壁切口疝修补患者,预防性ciNPT不应常规用于降低SSI,因现有RCT证据未显示优于标准伤口敷料。
- 临床决策需结合患者个体风险与资源条件,并关注该研究样本量较小的局限性。
局限性
- 研究受相对较小的患者数量限制。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The benefit of closed incision negative-pressure therapy (ciNPT) after open incisional hernia repair in reducing surgical-site infection (SSI) is uncertain. METHODS: The PROPRESS multicentre RCT was conducted from 1 March 2023 to 25 June 2024 at three Danish hospitals. Patients undergoing elective open incisional hernia repair were randomized to ciNPT or a standard wound dressing (SWD). The primary outcome was the incidence of SSI at 30 days. Secondary outcomes at 30 days included the pooled incidence of surgical-site occurrences (SSOs), patient-reported quality of life (QoL), and patient-reported scar assessment. The last follow-up date was 25 July 2024. RESULTS: A total of 110 patients were randomized (54 SWD patients and 56 ciNPT patients; median age of 63.9 (interquartile range 50.7-69.0) years; 45 (40.1%) were female) and 108 (98.2%) completed follow-up at 30 days. In total, 7 of the 110 patients (6.4%) were smokers, the mean(s.d.) BMI was 29.3(4.1) kg/m2, and the mean(s.d.) horizontal defect size was 8.7(4.7) cm. One death in each group was unrelated to the intervention, but surgery and anaesthesia may have been predisposing factors for mortality. There was no difference in SSI rates; 4 of 53 patients (8%) in the SWD group versus 7 of 55 patients (13%) in the ciNPT group (P = 0.673). With regard to SSOs, these affected 12 of 53 patients (23%) in the SWD group versus 14 of 55 patients (26%) in the ciNPT group (P = 0.907). There was no difference in scar scores (equal mean scores of 24; P = 0.892) and overall QoL improved significantly (mean score difference: -12.8 (95% c.i. -15.4 to -10.2); P < 0.001) without a difference between the groups (mean score change: SWD -12.6 versus ciNPT -13.0; P = 0.874). CONCLUSION: ciNPT did not reduce SSI after open incisional hernia repair in this RCT, which was limited by the relatively small number of patients. REGISTRATION NUMBER: NCT05050786 (http://www.clinicaltrials.gov). Individuals undergoing abdominal surgery have a risk of developing a bulge through the scar called an incisional hernia. When undergoing repair of an incisional hernia, there is a high risk of wound complications, including infection. This negatively impacts quality of life and mortality. Currently, after the skin is closed, a standard wound dressing is applied. Some studies have indicated that a dressing connected to a pump providing negative-pressure therapy might reduce the risk of wound infection and therefore could be a better treatment. The aim of this study was to evaluate whether negative-pressure therapy reduces wound infections after incisional hernia repair compared with standard wound dressing. Further, the effect on quality of life and scar quality was assessed. A total of 110 participants planned for open incisional hernia repair were randomized after surgery to receive either standard wound dressing or negative-pressure therapy. After 30 days, events of wound complications were registered via chart review and phone interview. Quality-of-life and scar assessment scores were obtained through questionnaires. Four of the participants with standard wound dressing had a wound infection compared with seven of the participants with negative-pressure therapy. There was no statistical difference. Quality of life improved for all participants regardless of the type of wound dressing. There was no difference in scar assessment scores. In conclusion, negative-pressure therapy does not reduce the risk of wound infection, but the study was limited due to the small number of patients.
引用
- Marckmann M, Henriksen NA, Krarup PM, et al. Effect of standard wound dressing versus prophylactic closed incision negative-pressure therapy on surgical-site infection after open incisional hernia repair: multicentre randomized clinical trial. Br J Surg. 2025. PMID: 41316999. doi:10.1093/bjs/znaf230
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。