经肛内镜微创手术与内镜黏膜下剥离术治疗直肠腺瘤的随机对照试验
一项单中心随机对照试验纳入236例直肠腺瘤≥3 cm患者,1:1随机接受TEM或ESD。TEM组R0切除率和整块切除率均显著高于ESD组,但两组围术期并发症和2年复发率无差异。
要点
- TEM组R0切除率79.7%高于ESD组67.5%,整块切除率97.5%高于85.6%。
- 两组Clavien-Dindo>II级并发症发生率无显著差异(16.9% vs 15.2%)。
- 随访至少2年,TEM与ESD复发率无差异(5.4% vs 4.8%)。
核心结论
- TEM较ESD获得更高的R0切除率和整块切除率,但两组2年复发率无差异。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心随机对照试验(NCT03718351),纳入直肠腺瘤≥3 cm患者236例,1:1随机分为TEM组和ESD组各118例。
主要发现
- TEM组R0切除率79.7%,ESD组67.5%(p=0.04)。
- TEM组整块切除率97.5%,ESD组85.6%(p=0.002)。
- Clavien-Dindo>II级并发症:TEM组16.9%(20/118),ESD组15.2%(18/118),p=0.9。
- 至少2年随访复发率:TEM组5.4%(4/73),ESD组4.8%(3/63),p=1.0。
- TEM组9例(7.6%)、ESD组6例(5.1%)行补充手术。
临床怎么用
- 对于≥3 cm直肠腺瘤,TEM在R0切除和整块切除方面优于ESD,可作为优先选择之一。
局限性
- 单中心研究,长期随访中TEM组36例、ESD组48例失访。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Comparison of Transanal Endoscopic Microsurgery (TEM) and Endoscopic Submucosal Dissection (ESD) is based only on retrospective studies. With the aim of comparing the effectiveness of TEM and ESD, a single-center randomized clinical trial (RCT) registered at ClinicalTrials.gov NCT03718351 was undertaken. PATIENTS AND METHODS: patients with rectal adenomas ≥ 3 cm were randomized (1:1) to TEM or ESD. The primary outcome was R0 resection rate, the secondary end-points were en bloc resection rate, perioperative morbidity and 2-year recurrence rate. RESULTS: between 2018 and 2023, 236 patients were included into the ESD or TEM group (n = 118 each). One patient (0.8%) from the ESD group had conversion to the TEM one. The mean size of lesions was 4.2 cm in the TEM vs. 4.1 cm in the ESD group (p = 0.39). Perioperative complications (> II by Clavien-Dindo) developed in 20/118 (16.9%) patients after TEM vs. 18/118 (15.2%) patients after ESD (p = 0.9). R0 resection and en bloc removal were 79.7% and 97.5% after TEM versus 67.5% and 85.6% after ESD (p = 0.04 and p = 0.002, respectively). Completion surgery performed in 9 (7.6%) and 6 (5.1%) cases, respectively. Those patients were excluded from an analysis of long-term results. Thirty-six patients from the TEM and 48 from the ESD group were lost for the follow up. After at least two-year surveillance, the recurrence rate was identical between the groups: 4/73 (5.4%) in TEM vs. 3/63 (4.8%) in ESD (p = 1.0). CONCLUSION: TEM resulted in a higher R0 and en bloc resection rate comparing to ESD; no difference in the recurrence rate was demonstrated.
引用
- Rybakov E, Chernyshov S, Likutov A, et al. The results of randomized controlled trial comparing effectiveness of transanal endoscopic microsurgery versus endoscopic submucosal dissection. Surg Endosc. 2025. PMID: 41136652. doi:10.1007/s00464-025-12319-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。