观察等待对比TEP修补术治疗隐匿性腹股沟疝伴疼痛:EFFECT非劣效随机试验
多中心非劣效RCT纳入85例单侧腹股沟痛(NRS≥1)且无临床显疝的成人,比较观察等待(WW)与TEP修补。3个月时疼痛缓解WW未达非劣效(静息差0.644,运动差0.806),但次要结局至3个月相似,且TEP存在过度治疗风险,至少3个月WW可作为筛选手术获益者的诊断工具。
要点
- 隐匿性腹股沟疝伴疼痛者3个月时WW疼痛缓解未达非劣效于TEP。
- 两组次要结局至3个月相似,WW交叉至手术率10%。
- 至少3个月WW策略可作为判断哪些患者真正需要手术的诊断工具。
核心结论
- 该试验未能证明WW在干预后3个月疼痛缓解方面非劣效于TEP修补。
- 结果并未确认WW劣于TEP,因至3个月次要结局可比且 upfront TEP存在过度治疗风险。
- 至少3个月WW策略可能作为诊断工具,判断哪些患者可从手术获益。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心、非劣效RCT,2017年12月29日至2022年3月4日筛查单侧腹股沟痛(NRS≥1)且无临床显疝的成人。
- WW组接受休息、镇痛药或物理治疗,手术组接受TEP修补。
- 每臂计划样本量80例(非劣效界值0.75 NRS;单侧α=0.025;β=0.10;失访10%),总随访12个月。
- 共99例中85例纳入分析(WW组49例;TEP组36例)。
- 主要结局为基线至随访3个月静息和运动时NRS平均差值,采用混合效应模型分析。
主要发现
- 静息疼痛平均差值为0.644(97.5%CI:-0.321至1.610)。
- 运动时疼痛平均差值为0.806(97.5%CI:-0.402至2.014)。
- WW组交叉至TEP者5例(10%)。
- 两组次要结局至3个月相似。
关键数值与推荐
- 非劣效界值为0.75 NRS,单侧α=0.025,β=0.10,计划失访10%。
- 主要结局为基线至3个月NRS平均差值,静息和运动分别分析。
- 总随访12个月,次要结局包括生活质量、患者满意度和交叉率。
临床怎么用
- 对隐匿性腹股沟疝伴疼痛患者,可考虑至少3个月WW策略以筛选可能从手术获益者。
- upfront TEP修补需权衡过度治疗风险。
- WW期间可采用休息、镇痛药或物理治疗。
局限性
- 实际样本量(85例)低于计划每臂80例的目标。
- WW组样本量(49例)与TEP组(36例)不均衡。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Current international guidelines offer no specific recommendations for managing occult inguinal hernias with groin pain, often resulting in unnecessary repairs. This randomized controlled trial (RCT) evaluated whether watchful waiting (WW) is non-inferior to totally extraperitoneal (TEP) repair in this distinct patient population. METHODS: From December 29, 2017, to March 4, 2022, this multicenter, non-inferiority RCT screened all adult patients with unilateral groin pain (numeric rating scale [NRS] ≥ 1) without a clinically evident inguinal hernia. Patients allocated to the WW arm were treated with rest, analgesics, or physiotherapy, while those assigned to surgery underwent TEP repair. The sample size was 80 patients per arm (non-inferiority margin: 0.75 NRS; 1-sided alpha: 0.025; beta: 0.10; loss to follow-up: 10%). The primary outcome was the mean NRS difference between baseline and 3 months of follow-up, measured at rest and during exercise, and analyzed using a mixed-effects model. Total follow-up was 12 months. Secondary outcomes included quality of life, patient satisfaction, and crossover rate. RESULTS: From a total of 99 patients, 85 patients were included in the study (WW: 49; TEP: 36). The analysis showed a mean difference of 0.644 (97.5% CI: - 0.321 to 1.610) for pain at rest and 0.806 (97.5% CI: - 0.402 to 2.014) for pain during exercise. Crossover from WW to TEP occurred in five patients (10%). Secondary outcomes were similar between the groups up to 3 months. CONCLUSION: This trial failed to demonstrate non-inferiority of WW compared to TEP repair for pain relief at 3 months post-intervention in patients with groin pain and an occult inguinal hernia. However, this result does not confirm that WW is inferior, as secondary outcomes were comparable up to 3 months and upfront TEP repair carried a risk of overtreatment. Therefore, a WW strategy for at least 3 months may be justified as a diagnostic tool to determine which patients may benefit from surgery.
引用
- Meuzelaar RR, Verleisdonk EJMM, Schiphorst AHW, et al. Watchful waiting versus totally extraperitoneal (TEP) hernia repair for occult inguinal hernia and pain (EFFECT trial)-a multicenter, non-inferiority, randomized controlled trial. Surg Endosc. 2025. PMID: 40404884. doi:10.1007/s00464-025-11681-w
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。