无充气经锁骨下与经腋窝入路及开放手术治疗单侧甲状腺癌的临床队列研究
回顾性分析151例cN0期甲状腺右叶癌患者,比较传统开放、无充气经腋窝及无充气经锁骨下三种入路。结果显示经锁骨下入路手术时间短于经腋窝入路,中央区完全显露率高于经腋窝入路,颈前区功能保护优于开放组,但美容效果欠佳。
要点
- 经锁骨下入路手术时间(97.0 min)短于经腋窝入路(115.0 min),均长于开放组(71.5 min)。
- 中央区完全显露率:开放组100%、经锁骨下组96.1%、经腋窝组86.4%,后两者差异有统计学意义。
- 术后1个月颈前区功能(疼痛、损伤指数、吞咽障碍)腔镜组均优于开放组,美容评分三组有差异。
核心结论
- 无充气经锁骨下入路操作较经腋窝入路简单,中央区淋巴结清扫视野更好,颈前区功能保护更优,但美容效果欠佳。
- 在严格术前评估和适应证把握下,两种无充气腔镜入路治疗cN0期甲状腺癌可获得与开放手术相似的效果。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入2024年6—10月郑州大学附属郑州中心医院151例cN0期甲状腺癌患者。
- 按手术入路分为传统开放组(56例)、无充气经腋窝入路组(44例)及无充气经锁骨下入路组(51例)。
- 比较手术时间、甲状旁腺自体移植率、中央区完全显露率、淋巴结清扫数目、阳性淋巴结数目、术后颈前区功能及切口外观满意度。
主要发现
- 手术时间:开放组71.5(16.0)min最短,经锁骨下组97.0(10.0)min短于经腋窝组115.0(11.0)min(P值均<0.01)。
- 甲状旁腺自体移植率:开放组53.6%(30/56)、经腋窝组70.5%(31/44)、经锁骨下组66.7%(34/51),组间差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。
- 中央区完全显露率:开放组100%(56/56)、经腋窝组86.4%(38/44)、经锁骨下组96.1%(49/51),开放组与经腋窝组差异有统计学意义(χ²=8.124,P<0.01)。
- 淋巴结清扫数目:开放组8(6)枚(范围2~17)、经腋窝组7(3)枚(范围2~16)、经锁骨下组7(4)枚(范围2~16),差异无统计学意义(P=0.078)。
- 阳性淋巴结数目:开放组0(1)枚(范围0~4)、经腋窝组0(1)枚(范围0~3)、经锁骨下组0(1)枚(范围0~2),差异无统计学意义(P=0.923)。
关键数值与推荐
- 术后3 d和1个月颈部疼痛评分:经腋窝组与经锁骨下组均无差异(P值均>0.017),但均低于开放组(P值均<0.01)。
- 术后3 d颈部损伤指数:经腋窝组与经锁骨下组无差异(P>0.017),均低于开放组(P值均<0.01);术后1个月三组依次降低,差异有统计学意义(P值均<0.01)。
- 吞咽障碍指数:术后3 d三组无差异(P>0.05);术后1个月经腋窝组和经锁骨下组均低于开放组(P值均<0.01)。
- 切口外观满意度:三组温哥华瘢痕评分、患者评分和观察者评分差异均有统计学意义(P值均<0.01)。
临床怎么用
- 对于cN0期甲状腺右叶癌,无充气经锁骨下入路可作为兼顾中央区显露与颈前区功能保护的腔镜术式选择。
- 经腋窝入路美容效果可能更优,但中央区完全显露率低于开放手术,需注意清扫彻底性。
- 腔镜入路手术时间均长于开放手术,经锁骨下入路较经腋窝入路缩短手术时间。
局限性
- 本研究为单中心回顾性队列研究,样本量有限,结论需前瞻性大样本研究验证。
- 原文未报告随访时间及肿瘤学长期结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To compare surgical-related indicators between non-inflated subclavian endoscopic surgery and axillary and traditional open surgery for the treatment of right lobe thyroid cancer,as well as their effects on postoperative anterior cervical function and cosmetic outcomes. Methods: This retrospective cohort study analyzed 151 cases of thyroid cancer patients who underwent surgical treatment at the Department of Thyroid Surgery,Zhengzhou Central Hospital Affiliated to Zhengzhou University from June 2024 to October 2024. Based on the surgical approach,patients were divided into three groups:56 cases of traditional open surgery group, 44 cases of non-inflated axillary approach group,and 51 cases of non-inflated subclavian approach group. Comparative indicators included surgical time, parathyroid autotransplantation rate,complete exposure rate of central area, number of lymph node dissections, number of positive lymph nodes, anterior cervical function, and satisfaction with incision beauty. One-way analysis of variance,non-parametric test,Kruskal-Wallis test,Pearson χ2 test and Fisher's exact probability method were used to compare the results of the three groups and subsequent pairwise comparisons,respectively. Results: All laparoscopic surgeries were successfully completed without conversion to open surgery. (1) Surgical time:the traditional open surgery group had the shortest operative time (M(IQR))(71.5(16.0)minutes), significantly shorter than both endoscopic groups (both P<0.01); among the endoscopic approaches, the non-inflated subclavian approach group (97.0(10.0)minutes) had a significantly shorter operative time than the non-inflated axillary approach group (115.0(11.0)minutes)(P<0.01). (2) Parathyroid autotransplantation rate:the rates were 53.6%(30/56) in the traditional group, 70.5%(31/44) in the non-inflated axillary approach group, and 66.7%(34/51) in the non-inflated subclavian approach group, with no statistically significant differences (P>0.05). (3) Complete exposure rate of the central area:the exposure rate was 100%(56/56) in the traditional open surgery group, 86.4%(38/44) in the non-inflated axillary approach group, and 96.1%(49/51) in the non-inflated subclavian approach group. A significant difference was observed between the traditional open surgery group and the non-inflated axillary approach group (χ²=8.124,P<0.01), but not observed between other groups. (4) Number of lymph node dissection:no significant difference was found among the three groups (8(6)(range:2 to 17) in the traditional open surgery group,7(3)(range:2 to 16) in the non-inflated axillary approach group,7(4)(range:2 to 16) in the non-inflated subclavian approach group)(P=0.078).(5) Number of positive lymph nodes:no significant differences were observed among the three groups(P=0.923). (6) Postoperative anterior cervical function:① Visual analogue scale: there was no significant difference between the non-insufflation transaxillary approach group and the non-insufflation subclavian approach group at 3 days and 1 month postoperatively (P>0.017). However, the two groups had significantly lower scores than the traditional open group (both P<0.01). ② Neck disability index:at 3 days post-surgery, there were significantly lower in the axillary and subclavian groups compared to the traditional open group (P<0.01), with no significant difference between the two endoscopic groups(P>0.017); at 1 month postoperatively, the traditional open surgery group, gasless axillary approach group, and gasless subclavian approach group, with statistically significant differences between each group (both P<0.01). ③ Swallowing disorder index: no significant differences were observed at 3 days post-surgery(P>0.05); however, at 1 month post-surgery, the endoscopic groups showed significantly lower scores compared to the traditional open group(both P<0.01).(7) Satisfaction with incision beauty:significant differences were found among the three groups in terms of vancouver scar scores, patient scar assessment scores, and observer scar assessment scores(all P<0.01). Conclusions: Compared to the non-inflated axillary endoscopic thyroidectomy, the non-inflated subclavian approach offers a technically simpler procedure, better exposure of the central lymph node dissection area, and superior protection of anterior cervical function, although it results in less favorable cosmetic outcomes. Under strict preoperative evaluation and appropriate indications,both non-inflated subclavian and axillary approaches can achieve outcomes comparable to traditional open surgery for cN0 thyroid cancer,demonstrating good clinical application value. 目的: 比较无充气经锁骨下入路腔镜手术与经腋窝入路和传统开放手术治疗甲状腺右叶癌的手术相关指标及对术后颈前区功能和外观的影响。 方法: 本研究为回顾性队列研究。回顾性分析2024年6—10月于郑州大学附属郑州中心医院行手术治疗的151例cN0期甲状腺癌患者资料。男性33例,女性118例,年龄(47.1±9.3)岁(范围:25~62岁)。按照手术入路不同分为传统开放组(56例)、无充气经腋窝入路组(44例)及无充气经锁骨下入路组(51例)。比较三组患者手术时间、甲状旁腺自体移植率、中央区完全显露率、淋巴结清扫数目、阳性淋巴结数目、术后颈前区功能及切口外观满意度等指标。采用单因素方差分析、Kruskal-Wallis检验、Pearson χ2检验或Fisher确切概率法比较三组间数据,并对P<0.05的指标进一步行两两比较。 结果: 所有腔镜手术均顺利完成,无中转开放。(1)手术时间:与腔镜组相比,传统开放组的手术时间[M(IQR),71.5(16.0)min]最短,且无充气经锁骨下入路组手术时间[97.0(10.0)min]短于无充气经腋窝入路组[115.0(11.0)min](P值均<0.01)。(2)甲状旁腺自体移植率:传统开放组为53.6%(30/56),无充气经腋窝入路组为70.5%(31/44),无充气经锁骨下入路组为66.7%(34/51),三组间差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。(3)中央区完全显露率:传统开放组、无充气经腋窝入路组、无充气经锁骨下入路组分别为100%(56/56)、86.4%(38/44)、96.1%(49/51),其中传统开放组与无充气经腋窝入路组的差异有统计学意义(χ²=8.124,P<0.01)。(4)淋巴结清扫数目:传统开放组[8(6)枚(范围:2~17枚)]、无充气经腋窝入路组[7(3)枚(范围:2~16枚)]和无充气经锁骨下入路组[7(4)枚(范围:2~16枚)]的淋巴结清扫数目的差异无统计学意义(P=0.078)。(5)阳性淋巴结数目:传统开放组[0(1)枚(范围:0~4 枚)]、无充气经腋窝入路组[0(1)枚(范围:0~3枚)]、无充气经锁骨下入路组[0(1)枚(范围:0~2枚)]的差异无统计学意义(P=0.923)。(6)术后颈前区功能:①颈部疼痛评分:术后3 d和1个月时无充气经腋窝入路组和无充气经锁骨下入路组均无差异(P值均>0.017),但均低于传统开放组(P值均<0.01)。②颈部损伤指数:术后3 d无充气经腋窝入路组和无充气经锁骨下入路组无差异(P>0.017),但均低于传统开放组(P值均<0.01);术后1个月时传统开放组、无充气经腋窝入路组、无充气经锁骨下入路组依次降低,差异有统计学意义(P值均<0.01)。③吞咽障碍指数:三组术后3 d无差异(P>0.05);术后1个月时无充气经腋窝入路组和无充气经锁骨下入路组均低于传统开放组(P值均<0.01)。(7)切口外观满意度:三组患者温哥华瘢痕评分、患者评分和观察者评分相比,差异均有统计学意义(P值均<0.01)。 结论: 相较于无充气经腋窝入路腔镜甲状腺手术,无充气经锁骨下入路操作简单,可较好地显露中央区淋巴结清扫视野,更好地保护颈前区功能,但外观效果欠佳。在严格术前评估及把握适应证的情况下,无充气经锁骨下入路和经腋窝入路可达到与开放手术治疗cN0期甲状腺癌相似的效果。.
引用
- Li MC, Fan X, Chen Z, et al. [Clinical cohort study of non inflated subclavian approach,axillary approach,and traditional open surgery for unilateral thyroid cancer]. Zhonghua Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2025. PMID: 40443337. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112139-20241030-00478
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。