多中心研究:阑尾炎研究中账单编码准确性评估
该多中心研究纳入6家美国医学中心2012-2015年(ICD-9时代)和2018-2021年(ICD-10时代)的成人阑尾炎患者,以AAST标准为金标准,评估ICD账单编码区分复杂与不复杂阑尾炎的准确性。共1832例患者,21.1%为复杂阑尾炎,账单编码灵敏度仅0.59,阳性预测值0.72,40.8%的复杂阑尾炎被误分类为不复杂。结论认为账单编码准确性差,影响基于行政数据库的研究解读及医院报销。
要点
- ICD账单编码区分复杂与不复杂阑尾炎的灵敏度低(0.59),易漏判复杂病例。
- 40.8%的复杂阑尾炎被账单编码误分类为不复杂阑尾炎。
- 基于行政数据库的阑尾炎研究结果需谨慎解读,账单编码误差可导致医院报销不足。
核心结论
- 账单编码区分复杂与不复杂阑尾炎的灵敏度和阳性预测值均较差,对行政数据库研究的解读和未来分析构建有重要影响,且编码不准确可能导致医院报销不足。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心队列研究,纳入2012-2015年(ICD-9时代)和2018-2021年(ICD-10时代)就诊于6家美国医学中心的成人阑尾炎患者,基于ICD编码识别,通过病历回顾确认诊断,以AAST标准区分复杂与不复杂阑尾炎作为金标准,共1832例符合纳入标准。
主要发现
- 1832例患者中54.1%为男性,25%为非白人,44%为公共保险或无保险。
- 基于金标准,21.1%的患者为复杂阑尾炎:手术患者中18.8%(312/1661),非手术患者中43.9%(75/171)(P<0.001)。
- 所有患者中17.3%有复杂阑尾炎的账单编码(12.5%真阳性,4.8%假阳性)。
- 40.8%(158/387)的复杂阑尾炎患者被ICD编码误分类为不复杂阑尾炎。
- 复杂阑尾炎的账单编码灵敏度为0.59(95% CI: 0.54-0.64),阳性预测值为0.72(95% CI: 0.67-0.77)。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生和研究者应认识到行政数据库中的阑尾炎账单编码可能低估复杂病例,在解读相关研究时需谨慎。
- 医院编码和报销环节需关注阑尾炎复杂程度编码不准确导致的潜在报销不足问题。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the accuracy of International Classification of Disease (ICD)-9/10 billing codes in a multicenter cohort. BACKGROUND: Health services research on appendicitis often relies on administrative databases. However, billing codes may misclassify disease severity, as we demonstrated previously in a single institution study. METHODS: We performed a multicenter study of adult patients with appendicitis who presented to one of 6 US medical centers from 2012 to 2015 (ICD-9 era) and 2018 to 2021 (ICD-10 era). Patients were identified based on ICD codes. The diagnosis was confirmed via chart review. Each patient was characterized as complicated or uncomplicated based on AAST criteria; this was considered the gold standard. Billing codes were compared to the gold standard to calculate test parameters (ie, sensitivity). RESULTS: In total, 1832 patients met the inclusion criteria. A total of 54.1% were male, 25% non-White, and 44% publicly insured or uninsured. In total, 21.1% of patients had complicated appendicitis based on the gold standard: 18.8% (312/1661) of surgical patients and 43.9% (75/171) of nonoperative patients ( P <0.001). Among all patients, 17.3% had a billing code for complicated appendicitis (12.5% true positives and 4.8% false positives). A total of 40.8% (158 of 387) of patients with complicated appendicitis were misclassified as having uncomplicated appendicitis via ICD codes. Sensitivity and PPV for complicated appendicitis were 0.59 (95% CI: 0.54-0.64) and 0.72 (95% CI: 0.67-0.77), respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Billing codes have poor sensitivity and PPV for distinguishing complicated from uncomplicated appendicitis. These results have significant implications for how we should interpret data from administrative database studies and construct future analyses. Inaccuracies in billing codes negatively impact hospital reimbursement, with a tendency toward underpayment.
引用
- Beaulieu-Jones BR, Laudon AD, Duraiswamy S, et al. A Multicenter Assessment of the Accuracy of Claims Data in Appendicitis Research. Ann Surg. 2025. PMID: 40040610. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000006686
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。