欧洲外科医生对复杂性憩室炎手术处理存在显著差异:一项横断面调查
该研究通过在线问卷调查欧洲内镜外科协会(EAES)的233名外科医生及研究员,评估对稳定与不稳定Hinchey III及IV期憩室炎的手术选择。结果显示,对于稳定Hinchey III期,Hartmann切除术(41.6%)最常见,而腹腔镜灌洗后切除占31.4%;不稳定Hinchey III期及稳定/不稳定Hinchey IV期均以Hartmann切除术为主(73.9%、71.7%、83.1%)。结论认为欧洲实践存在显著差异,需加强指南推荐在临床中的知晓与应用。
要点
- 稳定Hinchey III期憩室炎手术方式多样,Hartmann切除术占41.6%。
- 不稳定Hinchey III期及Hinchey IV期均以Hartmann切除术为主要选择。
- 欧洲不同国家间对复杂性憩室炎的手术处理存在显著差异。
核心结论
- 欧洲外科医生对复杂性憩室炎的手术处理存在显著差异,需提高指南推荐的知晓与应用。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面调查,通过Opinio平台向EAES fellow及外科医生会员发放在线问卷,共收到233份回复。
主要发现
- 稳定Hinchey III期:Hartmann切除术41.6%,一期切除吻合18.5%,Hartmann术前腹腔镜灌洗16.9%,一期吻合前腹腔镜灌洗15.5%,仅腹腔镜灌洗8.6%。
- 不稳定性Hinchey III期:Hartmann切除术73.9%,一期切除吻合3.85%,仅腹腔镜灌洗6.84%,腹腔镜灌洗后切除15.4%。
- 稳定Hinchey IV期:Hartmann切除术71.7%,一期切除吻合4.7%,仅腹腔镜灌洗1.3%,腹腔镜灌洗后切除22.3%。
- 不稳定Hinchey IV期:Hartmann切除术83.1%,一期切除吻合1.3%,仅腹腔镜灌洗3.5%,腹腔镜灌洗后切除12.1%。
临床怎么用
- 临床决策需结合患者Hinchey分期及稳定性,并参考国际指南推荐。
- 对于稳定Hinchey III期,可考虑腹腔镜灌洗后切除等保留肠道的策略。
- 不稳定性Hinchey III/IV期仍以Hartmann切除术为主要选择。
局限性
- 调查基于问卷自我报告,可能存在选择偏倚。
- 样本以意大利、希腊和英国为主,可能不能完全代表全欧洲实践。
- 未报告应答率及非应答者的特征。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: There are many options for the surgical management of complicated diverticulitis, and standards vary widely despite international practice recommendations. We conducted a survey to capture the variation in practice across Europe. METHODS: An online questionnaire was distributed to fellow and surgeon members of the European Association of Endoscopic Surgery (EAES) via email using the Opinio survey platform. Participants shared their demographic details. We asked members to rank the most likely intervention for patients with both stable and unstable Hinchey Class III, as well as Hinchey Class IV diverticulitis based on practice standards in their country. We used descriptive statistics, including counts and percentages, to characterize survey results. We created a heatmap to visualize the percentage of votes received for each intervention. RESULTS: We received 233 responses from surgeons and fellows across Europe from various countries, including Italy (35.6%), Greece (11.2%), and the United Kingdom (9.9%). Most members (79.4%) self-reported having expertise in colorectal surgery. For patients with stable Hinchey III diverticulitis, surgeons offered Hartmann's resection (HR) (41.6%), primary resection and anastomosis (PRA) (18.5%), laparoscopic peritonea lavage (LPL) prior to HR (16.9%), or LPL prior to PRA (15.5%), or LPL only (8.6%). In total, 31.4% of respondents offered LPL prior to sigmoid resection (HR + PRA). For patients with unstable Hinchey III diverticulitis, respondents offered HR (73.9%), PRA (3.85%), LPL only (6.84%), or LPL followed by sigmoid resection (15.4%). For patients with stable Hinchey IV diverticulitis, surgeons offered HR (71.7%), PRA (4.7%), LPL only (1.3%), or LPL then sigmoid resection (22.3%). Finally, for patients with unstable Hinchey IV diverticulitis, surgeons offered HR (83.1%), PRA (1.3%), LPL only (3.5%), or LPL followed by sigmoid resection (12.1%). CONCLUSION: Significant variation exists in the surgical management of complicated diverticulitis across Europe. Efforts must be made to increase the awareness and uptake of surgical guideline recommendations in clinical practice.
引用
- Huo B, Massey LH, Seitidis G, et al. Variation in the surgical management of complicated diverticulitis: a cross-sectional study of European surgeons. Surg Endosc. 2024. PMID: 39719489. doi:10.1007/s00464-024-11456-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。