EAES快速指南:复杂性憩室炎的手术管理——ESCP参与
EAES基于个体参与者数据网络Meta分析(PRA vs HR vs LPL)制定复杂性憩室炎手术管理指南,采用GRADE和CINeMA评价证据确定性,通过共识会议和改良Delphi调查形成推荐。推荐无脓毒症患者优先行PRA而非HR或LPL,脓毒症、衰弱及免疫抑制患者优先行HR。
要点
- 无脓毒症的复杂性憩室炎患者,在有结直肠手术经验医师条件下,建议PRA优于HR或LPL。
- 脓毒症、衰弱或免疫抑制患者亚组,建议HR优于PRA或LPL。
- 推荐为条件性,需共享决策,优先考虑条件推荐支持的措施。
核心结论
- 复杂性憩室炎无脓毒症患者建议PRA优于HR或LPL,脓毒症、衰弱及免疫抑制患者建议HR优于PRA或LPL。
研究设计与样本
- 基于个体参与者数据网络Meta分析(PRA vs HR vs LPL),由多学科小组采用GRADE和CINeMA评价证据确定性,通过共识会议和改良Delphi调查形成推荐。
主要发现
- PRA的关键获益是1年无造口可能性更高,各比较间风险相似。
关键数值与推荐
- 推荐适用于有手术指征的复杂性憩室炎患者。
- 无脓毒症患者:建议PRA优于HR或LPL(需具备结直肠手术技能和经验的外科医师)。
- 脓毒症、衰弱、免疫抑制患者亚组:建议HR优于PRA或LPL。
- 推荐为条件性,需共享决策。
临床怎么用
- 对无脓毒症患者优先考虑PRA,对脓毒症、衰弱或免疫抑制患者优先考虑HR。
- 应用推荐时需结合患者价值观和意愿进行共享决策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The surgical management of complicated diverticulitis varies across Europe. EAES members prioritized this topic to be addressed by a clinical practice guideline through an online questionnaire. OBJECTIVE: To develop evidence-informed clinical practice recommendations for key stakeholders involved in the treatment of complicated diverticulitis; to improve operative and perioperative outcomes, patient experience and quality of life through a systematic evidence-to-decision approach by a diverse, multidisciplinary panel. METHODS: Informed by a linked individual participant data network meta-analysis of resection and primary anastomosis (PRA) versus Hartmann's resection (HR) versus laparoscopic lavage (LPL), a panel of general and colorectal surgeons, patient partners, trialists, and fellows appraised the certainty of the evidence using GRADE and CINeMA. The panel discussed the evidence using the evidence-to-decision framework during a synchronous consensus meeting. An asynchronous modified Delphi survey was used to establish consensus. RESULTS: The panel suggests that patients with complicated diverticulitis without sepsis receive PRA over HR or LPL when there is availability of a surgeon with skills and experience in colorectal surgery. HR is suggested over PRA or LPL in the subgroups of septic, frail, as well as immunocompromised patients. These recommendations apply to patients with an indication for surgery. Surgeons and patients should first consider conditionally recommended interventions, then conditionally recommended against. Based on the evidence, the key benefit of PRA was a higher likelihood of not having a stoma at 1 year, with similar risks across comparisons. Conditional recommendations call for shared decision-making when considering management options. The full guideline with user-friendly decision aids is available in https://app.magicapp.org/#/guideline/7490 . CONCLUSION: This clinical practice guideline provides evidence-informed recommendations on the management of patients with complicated diverticulitis in accordance with the highest methodological standards through a structured framework informed by an international, multidisciplinary panel of stakeholders.
引用
- Antoniou SA, Huo B, Ortenzi M, et al. EAES rapid guideline: surgical management of complicated diverticulitis - with ESCP participation. Surg Endosc. 2024. PMID: 39733172. doi:10.1007/s00464-024-11445-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。