英格兰NHS择期手术术前评估后延期率的变异
该回顾性审计分析纳入英格兰16家NHS信托机构两周内约8000份病历,择期手术在术前评估期间或之后延期率为7.3%(583例),各信托间从1.0%到31.9%不等。342例常规患者中85.7%因医疗原因而非路径或流程原因延期,一半常规患者从加入追踪列表到术前评估等待超过94天。
要点
- 择期手术术前评估后延期率整体为7.3%,但各信托间变异极大(1.0%–31.9%)。
- 常规患者延期多因医疗原因(85.7%),而非路径或流程因素。
- 常规患者从加入追踪列表到术前评估等待时间长,一半超过94天。
核心结论
- 择期手术术前评估后延期率在英格兰NHS信托间存在显著变异,减少延期并提高术前评估效率应纳入围术期路径优化举措。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析英格兰16家NHS信托机构的临床审计数据,收集2024年3月两周内所有延期病例,共审查约8000份病历。
主要发现
- 共583例(7.3%)延期,各信托延期率从31.9%到1.0%不等。
- 342例常规患者中293例(85.7%)因医疗原因而非路径或流程原因延期。
- 一半常规患者从加入患者追踪列表到术前评估等待超过94天,四分之一等待198天。
- 日间手术患者、紧急患者、无早期筛查患者及无「入院日期」患者从转诊到术前评估的时间显著更短。
临床怎么用
- 应尽早识别可能影响手术的健康问题,避免术前评估过于接近计划手术日期。
- 减少延期和改进术前评估效率可作为围术期路径 streamlining 的组成部分。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Postponement of surgery at preoperative assessment in the days or weeks before the patient is admitted for surgery, as distinct from cancellation on the planned day of surgery, can be devastating for patients and an inefficient use of finite resources. However, postponements are often poorly recorded. The primary aim of this pilot study was to investigate elective surgical postponement rates during or after preoperative assessment across England, and the reasons for postponement for patients on an elective surgical pathway. METHODS: A retrospective analysis of clinical audit data from 16 National Health Service (NHS) trusts in England was undertaken. Data were collected during a two-week period in March 2024 on all postponements within a service. The primary outcome of interest was the postponement rate. RESULTS: Some 8000 case notes were reviewed. There were 583 (7.3%) postponements. Postponement rates across trusts varied from 31.9% to 1.0%. Significantly shorter time from referral to preoperative assessment was observed for day-case patients, urgent patients, patients without early screening and patients without a 'to come in' date in place. Of the 342 routine patients, 293 (85.7%) had postponements for medical rather than pathways or process reasons. Half of all routine patients waited over 94 days and a quarter of patients waited 198 days from being added to a patient tracking list to preoperative assessment. CONCLUSIONS: Minimizing postponements and improving preoperative assessment efficiency should be part of wider initiatives to streamline perioperative pathways. BACKGROUND: Many hospital patients in England are currently waiting a long time for planned operations. When the operation does not go ahead, it can be very disappointing for patients and their families. Knowing why this happens is important so we can improve. Before an operation, patients will attend pre-assessment. It is here where patients are asked questions about their health. This appointment often happens very close to the date of an operation, meaning that if any problems are found surgery is likely to be delayed. AIM: This paper looks at those patients who could not have an operation as planned after the pre-assessment appointment and reasons behind this. METHODS: We collected information on patients whose surgery was delayed from 16 hospitals in England during two weeks in spring 2023. We collected information on how urgent surgery was, if the patient was planned to stay in hospital following surgery, why surgery was delayed, who made the decision to delay, and how long patients had waited for surgery until it was delayed. FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS: Of 8000 patients who had surgery, 583 could not go ahead with surgery as planned. This is about 7 out of every 100 patients. Delay rates varied a lot across the 16 hospitals. The main reason for delays was a current health condition. Knowing about these earlier could have helped avoid a delay. Avoiding having pre-assessment close to the planned date of surgery could also have meant surgery did not need to be delayed. The health service in England needs to do more to avoid delays to planned surgery and our study helps us understand how to do this.
引用
- McCone E, Snowden C, Swart M, et al. Variation in surgery postponement rates in the NHS in England. Br J Surg. 2024. PMID: 39530342. doi:10.1093/bjs/znae280
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。