衰弱评分用于手术风险获益筛查:多学科方法
该研究回顾性分析某医疗中心2011年起12年间多学科手术暂停委员会(MDSPC)评估后的患者资料,计算衰弱风险分析指数(RAI)并更新生存状态。MDSPC计划分为四组:按计划手术(G1)、医疗优化后手术(G2)、降低手术或麻醉侵入性(G3)、非手术方式(G4)。结果显示医疗优化可改善总生存并使30天和1年死亡率与G1相当,而降低侵入性仅带来6个月生存优势。
要点
- 医疗优化后手术(G2)的总生存及30天、1年死亡率与直接手术(G1)相当。
- 降低手术侵入性(G3)仅改善6个月生存,之后与最差的非手术组(G4)相当。
- RAI评分是预测手术结局的有效工具,成功用于危重患者。
核心结论
- 医疗优化可改善总生存并使30天和1年死亡率与直接手术组相当。
- 降低手术侵入性仅带来6个月生存优势,此后与最差的非手术组相当。
- RAI评分是预测手术结局的优秀工具,并成功用于危重患者。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性收集自2011年起12年间在某医疗中心接受MDSPC评估后的患者信息。
- 计算患者衰弱风险分析指数(RAI)评分并更新生存状态。
- MDSPC计划分为四组:G1按计划手术、G2医疗优化后手术、G3降低手术或麻醉侵入性、G4非手术方式。
- 分类数据用χ²检验,数值数据用独立t检验;30天(主要终点)、1年和总死亡率用Kaplan-Meier分析,α设为0.05。
主要发现
- 共纳入12名女性和382名男性,平均年龄71±11岁。
- 87.3%的预定手术被分级为美国麻醉医师协会III和IV级。
- RAI评分:G1为36.4±9.6,与G2的37.4±10.8相似,但低于G3的41.4±9.3和G4的44.2±9.7(P<0.001)。
- 平均生存时间:G1为35个月,G2为35个月,均显著长于G3的20个月和G4的18个月(P<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 对衰弱患者术前采用MDSPC多学科评估,依据RAI评分和风险获益比制定个体化方案。
- 优先考虑医疗优化后手术,可达到与直接手术相当的生存结局。
- 降低手术侵入性仅带来短期生存优势,需权衡其与保守治疗的长期风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To examine the role of Multidisciplinary Surgical Pause Committees (MDSPCs) in perioperative planning to reduce adverse postoperative events and mortality rates. BACKGROUND: Frail patients could benefit from preoperative MDSPCs when utilizing risk-benefit ratios for the proposed surgical plan. We examined whether MDSPCs improved clinical outcomes by developing individualized care plans and stratifying patients based on their level of frailty and ability to overcome external stressors. METHODS: We retrospectively collected patient information after MDSPC evaluation, at our medical center for 12 years since 2011. Patient's frailty Risk Analysis Index (RAI) scores were calculated, and survival status was updated. MDSPCs plans were put into the following categories: proceed with the planned surgery (G1), proceed after medical optimization (G2), reduce the invasiveness of surgery or anesthesia plan (G3), or adopt a nonsurgical approach (G4). χ 2 and independent t tests were used for categorical and numerical data, respectively. Survival analysis for 30-day (primary endpoint), 1-year, and overall mortality rates used Kaplan-Meier. The alpha was set at 0.05. RESULTS: Clinical information was accessed from 12 women and 382 men. The average age was 71 ± 11 years. Of planned surgical operations, 87.3% were stratified as American Society of Anesthesiologists class III and IV. RAI scores were 36.4 ± 9.6 (G1), similar to 37.4 ± 10.8 (G2) but lower than 41.4 ± 9.3 (G3) and 44.2 ± 9.7 (G4; P < 0.001). Average survival duration was 35 months (G1), 35 months (G2), both significantly longer than 20 months (G3) and 18 months (G4; P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Medical optimization improved overall survival and reduced death within 30 days and 1 year to be comparable to G1. In addition, reducing the surgical invasiveness only improved survival advantage for 6 months, after which it was comparable to those in G4 with the worst outcome. RAI scoring is an excellent tool to predict the outcome of surgery, and it was used successfully in critically ill patients.
引用
- Ballacchino MM, McQuestion CC, Giuca MS, et al. The Use of Frailty Scores for Screening the Surgical Risk Benefits: A Multidisciplinary Approach. Ann Surg. 2024. PMID: 39041210. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000006452
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。