指南与共识围术期管理与 ERAS

外科文献中种族与民族差异统计方法综述及改进建议

Statistical Methods to Examine Racial and Ethnic Disparities in the Surgical Literature: A Review and Recommendations for Improvement.
指南 / 共识 · Ann Surg · 2024-07-09

该综述系统评价了2021-2022年外科领域种族与民族差异研究的统计方法质量,发现多数研究未满足关键设计标准,如调整社会健康决定因素、处理患者聚类及区分提供者内/间效应,建议通过期刊出版指南和政策改进。

要点

  • 多数外科差异研究未充分调整社会健康决定因素(SDOH)。
  • 仅23.1%的多中心研究采用适当方法处理患者聚类。
  • 仅5.4%的多中心研究区分提供者内与提供者间效应。

核心结论

  • 近期发表的外科种族与民族差异研究多数未满足重要统计设计标准,可能影响差异估计的准确性。
  • 改进的最有效杠杆点是改变期刊出版指南和政策。

研究设计与样本

  • 综述纳入2021-2022年描述外科或围术期可及性、过程质量或结局中种族/民族差异的研究。
  • 共识别224篇论文,其中38篇单机构研究,186篇多中心研究。

主要发现

  • 38篇单机构研究中,24篇(63.2%)调整了至少一个SDOH变量。
  • 186篇多中心研究中,113篇(60.8%)调整了至少一个SDOH变量。
  • 186篇多中心研究中,43篇(23.1%)使用适当统计方法处理患者聚类。
  • 仅10篇(5.4%)多中心研究尝试分析总体差异由提供者内与提供者间效应驱动的比例。

关键数值与推荐

  • 统计方法学评价标准包括:调整与种族/民族及结局均相关的变量(含SDOH)、处理患者在医院或其他子单元(提供者)内的聚类、区分提供者内与提供者间效应。

临床怎么用

  • 外科差异研究应调整社会健康决定因素(SDOH)。
  • 多中心研究需采用适当统计方法处理患者聚类。
  • 应努力区分提供者内与提供者间效应对差异的贡献。
  • 期刊出版指南和政策是推动统计方法改进的关键杠杆点。

局限性

  • 仅纳入2021-2022年文献,未涵盖更早年份。
  • 仅评价了三个统计设计标准,未全面评估其他方法学质量维度。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To characterize the quality of statistical methods for studies of racial and ethnic disparities in the surgical-relevant literature during 2021-2022. BACKGROUND: Hundreds of scientific papers are published each year describing racial and ethnic disparities in surgical access, quality, and outcomes. The content and design quality of this literature have never been systematically reviewed. METHODS: We searched for 2021 to 2022 studies focused on describing racial and/or ethnic disparities in surgical or perioperative access, process quality, or outcomes. Identified studies were characterized in terms of 3 methodological criteria: (1) adjustment for variables related to both race/ethnicity and outcomes, including social determinants of health (SDOH), (2) accounting for clustering of patients within hospitals or other subunits ("providers"), and (3) distinguishing within-provider and between-provider effects. RESULTS: We identified 224 papers describing racial and/or ethnic differences. Of the 38 single-institution studies, 24 (63.2%) adjusted for at least one SDOH variable. Of the 186 multisite studies, 113 (60.8%) adjusted for at least one SDOH variable, and 43 (23.1%) accounted for the clustering of patients within providers using appropriate statistical methods. Only 10 (5.4%) of multi-institution studies made efforts to examine how much of the overall disparities were driven by within versus between-provider effects. CONCLUSIONS: Most recently published papers on racial and ethnic disparities in the surgical literature do not meet these important statistical design criteria and, therefore, may risk inaccuracy in the estimation of group differences in surgical access, quality, and outcomes. The most potent leverage points for these improvements are changes to journal publication guidelines and policies.

来源:Ann Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Harris AHS, Eddington H, Shah VB, et al. Statistical Methods to Examine Racial and Ethnic Disparities in the Surgical Literature: A Review and Recommendations for Improvement. Ann Surg. 2024. PMID: 38979600. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000006440

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。