右半肝切除与左半肝切除治疗可切除Klatskin肿瘤的系统综述
该系统综述纳入21项研究,按Klatskin肿瘤类型比较右半肝切除与左半肝切除的肿瘤学结局与并发症。对于III/IV型肿瘤,两种术式在达到R0切除时长期肿瘤学结局似乎相当;对于I/II型肿瘤,左半肝切除可能具有边缘性肿瘤学优势和更低的并发症率。目前缺乏针对各类型Klatskin肿瘤理想手术方式的证据,手术策略高度依赖术者经验和技术。
要点
- III/IV型Klatskin肿瘤达到R0切除时,右半肝与左半肝切除的长期肿瘤学结局似乎相当。
- I/II型Klatskin肿瘤中,左半肝切除可能具有边缘性肿瘤学优势和更低的并发症率。
- 目前缺乏针对各类型Klatskin肿瘤理想手术方式的证据,手术策略依赖术者经验。
核心结论
- 对于Klatskin III/IV型肿瘤,达到R0切除时右半肝切除与左半肝切除的长期肿瘤学结局似乎相当。
- 对于Klatskin I/II型肿瘤,左半肝切除可能具有边缘性肿瘤学优势和更低的并发症率。
- 目前缺乏针对每种Klatskin肿瘤类型的理想手术方式的证据。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索PubMed、Medline和Scopus数据库,遵循PRISMA指南。
- 共纳入21项研究,按Klatskin肿瘤类型(I/II、II/IV、III、IV型)及未分型肝门部胆管癌分类。
主要发现
- 4项研究报告了右半肝或左半肝切除治疗Klatskin I/II型肿瘤的结局。
- 2项研究报告了Klatskin II/IV型肿瘤的结局,2项报告了III型,2项报告了IV型。
临床怎么用
- Klatskin肿瘤的管理需要在能够进行大范围肝切除、彻底淋巴结清扫、胆道和血管重建的专科肝胆外科中心进行。
- 手术策略的选择应基于Klatskin肿瘤在胆管树中的扩散类型,并高度依赖术者的经验和技术。
局限性
- 缺乏针对每种Klatskin肿瘤类型的理想手术方式的证据。
- 需要更大样本量的研究来就右半肝切除与左半肝切除的优越性达成广泛共识。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The prognosis of Klatskin tumors is poor, and radical surgery with disease-free surgical margins (R0) represents the treatment capable of ensuring the best long-term outcomes. In patients with Klatskin tumors, both right hepatectomy and left hepatectomy might achieve R0 surgical margins. This systematic review concentrated on a comparative investigation between left hepatectomy and right hepatectomy, aiming to furnish clinical evidence and to aid in surgical decision-making for Klatskin tumor depending on its spread within the bile duct tree. METHODS: The eligible articles in the study were obtained from PubMed, Medline, and Scopus databases, following the guidelines of the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis, and they were categorized according to the type of Klatskin tumor treated with right hepatectomy or left hepatectomy. The studies that analyzed the outcomes related to the 2 surgical techniques without focusing on the type of Klatskin tumor were included in a separate paragraph and table. RESULTS: In total, 21 studies were included. Four studies reported outcomes of right hepatectomy or left hepatectomy for Klatskin type I/II tumor, 2 for Klatskin type II/IV tumor, 2 for Klatskin type III tumor, and 2 for Klatskin type IV. Eleven studies included the outcomes of right hepatectomy and left hepatectomy for hilar cholangiocarcinoma without specifying the type of Klatskin tumor. Although long-term oncologic outcomes seem comparable between right hepatectomy and left hepatectomy when achieving R0 resection for Klatskin type III/IV tumors, there may exist a marginal oncologic edge and reduced complication rates favoring left hepatectomy in individuals with Klatskin type I/II tumors. DISCUSSION: Right hepatectomy traditionally has played a central role in treating Klatskin tumor, but recent studies have questioned its oncologic efficacy and surgical risks. Currently, there is a lack of evidence regarding the ideal surgical approach for each type of Klatskin tumor, and surgical strategy relies heavily on the individual surgeon's experience and technical skills. The management of Klatskin tumors necessitates specialized hepatobiliary surgical centers capable of conducting major hepatectomy with thorough lymphadenectomy, biliary, and vascular reconstructions. There is a need for studies with larger sample sizes to achieve a wide consensus about the superiority of one surgical technique over the other in cases in which both right hepatectomy and left hepatectomy can achieve an R0 margin.
引用
- Campisi A, Kawaguchi Y, Ito K, et al. Right hepatectomy compared with left hepatectomy for resectable Klatskin tumor: A systematic review across tumor types. Surgery. 2024. PMID: 39048329. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2024.07.001
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。