器官共享联合网络分配政策变更后肝移植费用与活动量
该横断面研究比较了美国器官共享联合网络(UNOS)2020年2月新肝分配政策实施前后两个12个月期间,22个移植中心的肝移植量与费用变化,发现移植量下降6%,本地脑死亡后捐献肝移植减少54%,输入性捐献增加133%,总体医院费用增加10.9%,飞行取肝费用增加77%,并显示弱势人群中心负担更重。
要点
- 新分配政策实施后肝移植总量下降6%(1948例降至1837例)。
- 本地脑死亡后捐献肝移植减少54%,输入性捐献增加133%。
- 参与中心总体医院费用增加10.9%,飞行取肝费用增加77%。
核心结论
- 基于此项大型多中心研究,与当前假设相反,新的肝分配系统似乎对已经存在医疗差异的肝移植群体造成不成比例的负担。
- UNOS正在推进的持续分配政策可能使情况进一步恶化。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,收集并回顾美国多个中心的肝移植量及费用数据,关注8个特定中心人口学特征。
- 比较两个独立的12个月时期:2019年3月4日至2020年3月4日(政策前)与2020年3月5日至2021年3月5日(政策后)。
- 68个中心中22个中心回复,比较政策前1948例肝移植与政策后1837例肝移植。
- 数据分析于2022年5月至12月进行。
主要发现
- 肝移植总量下降6%(政策前1948例 vs 政策后1837例)。
- 使用本地脑死亡后捐献的移植减少54%(P < .001),而输入性脑死亡后捐献增加133%(P = .003)。
- 输入性飞行取肝和空跑分别增加163%(中位数19,范围1-75 vs 50,范围2-91;P = .009)和33%(中位数3,范围0-16 vs 7,范围0-24;P = .02)。
- 参与中心总体医院费用增加10.9%至总额46 360 176美元(P = .94),政策后飞行取肝费用增加77%(10 600 234美元;P = .03)。
- 亚组分析:政策后肝移植量下降的中心总体医院费用更高(41 720 365美元;P = .048),肝输入费用增加122%(6 508 480美元;P = .002);低收入州移植中心医院费用增加12%、输入费用增加94%;服务少数族裔及黑人候选者比例较高的中心,尽管肝移植量较低,输入肝、飞行取肝和空跑费用增加超过90%;卫生系统表现较差的中心飞行取肝和空跑费用增加超过100%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: A new liver allocation policy was implemented by United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) in February 2020 with the stated intent of improving access to liver transplant (LT). There are growing concerns nationally regarding the implications this new system may have on LT costs, as well as access to a chance for LT, which have not been captured at a multicenter level. OBJECTIVE: To characterize LT volume and cost changes across the US and within specific center groups and demographics after the policy implementation. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This cross-sectional study collected and reviewed LT volume from multiple centers across the US and cost data with attention to 8 specific center demographics. Two separate 12-month eras were compared, before and after the new UNOS allocation policy: March 4, 2019, to March 4, 2020, and March 5, 2020, to March 5, 2021. Data analysis was performed from May to December 2022. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Center volume, changes in cost. RESULTS: A total of 22 of 68 centers responded comparing 1948 LTs before the policy change and 1837 LTs postpolicy, resulting in a 6% volume decrease. Transplants using local donations after brain death decreased 54% (P < .001) while imported donations after brain death increased 133% (P = .003). Imported fly-outs and dry runs increased 163% (median, 19; range, 1-75, vs 50, range, 2-91; P = .009) and 33% (median, 3; range, 0-16, vs 7, range, 0-24; P = .02). Overall hospital costs increased 10.9% to a total of $46 360 176 (P = .94) for participating centers. There was a 77% fly-out cost increase postpolicy ($10 600 234; P = .03). On subanalysis, centers with decreased LT volume postpolicy observed higher overall hospital costs ($41 720 365; P = .048), and specifically, a 122% cost increase for liver imports ($6 508 480; P = .002). Transplant centers from low-income states showed a significant increase in hospital (12%) and import (94%) costs. Centers serving populations with larger proportions of racial and ethnic minority candidates and specifically Black candidates significantly increased costs by more than 90% for imported livers, fly-outs, and dry runs despite lower LT volume. Similarly, costs increased significantly (>100%) for fly-outs and dry runs in centers from worse-performing health systems. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Based on this large multicenter effort and contrary to current assumptions, the new liver distribution system appears to place a disproportionate burden on populations of the current LT community who already experience disparities in health care. The continuous allocation policies being promoted by UNOS could make the situation even worse.
引用
- Ahmed O, Doyle MBM, Abouljoud MS, et al. Liver Transplant Costs and Activity After United Network for Organ Sharing Allocation Policy Changes. JAMA Surg. 2024. PMID: 38809546. doi:10.1001/jamasurg.2024.1208
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。