伤口愈合问卷在中低收入国家腹部手术后手术部位感染诊断中的准确性
该研究嵌套于FALCON试验,在七个中低收入国家前瞻性评估电话版伤口愈合问卷(WHQ)诊断腹部手术后手术部位感染的准确性。以术后30天面对面临床评估为参考标准,电话WHQ的AUROC为0.869,阈值≥4分时灵敏度0.701、特异度0.911。结论认为在资源有限环境中可通过电话问卷诊断手术部位感染。
要点
- 电话版WHQ对腹部手术后手术部位感染具有较好的判别能力,AUROC为0.869。
- 阈值≥4分时灵敏度0.701、特异度0.911、阳性预测值0.723、阴性预测值0.901。
- 非中线切口及面对面评估确诊手术部位感染的患者更难通过电话联系到。
核心结论
- 在资源有限环境中,可通过电话问卷诊断手术部位感染,从而避免面对面评估。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心、国际、前瞻性研究,嵌套于FALCON试验(一项在七个中低收入国家测试降低手术部位感染措施的析因随机对照试验,NCT03700749)。
- 研究按预注册方案(SWAT126)实施,并按STARD指南报告。
- 参考测试为术后30天由经过培训的临床医生按美国疾病控制与预防中心标准进行面对面评估。
- 指数测试为术后27至30天由对面对面评估结果不知情的研究人员通过电话实施改编版WHQ。
- 条目应答评分总和生成0至29分的总体评分。
主要发现
- 90.3%(1196例中1088例)患者被成功联系到。
- 非中线切口患者较难联系到(调整比值比:0.36,95%置信区间0.17至0.73,P=0.005)。
- 面对面评估确诊手术部位感染的患者较难联系到(比值比:0.42,95%置信区间0.20至0.92,P=0.006)。
- 问卷能正确区分大多数有和无手术部位感染的患者(AUROC 0.869,95%置信区间0.824至0.914),且在各亚组中一致。
- 代表性阈值≥4分时,灵敏度为0.701(0.610-0.792),特异度为0.911(0.878-0.943),阳性预测值为0.723(0.633-0.814),阴性预测值为0.901(0.867-0.935)。
关键数值与推荐
- 电话WHQ总体评分范围为0至29分。
- 阈值≥4分时灵敏度0.701(95%置信区间0.610-0.792)。
- 阈值≥4分时特异度0.911(95%置信区间0.878-0.943)。
- 阈值≥4分时阳性预测值0.723(95%置信区间0.633-0.814)。
- 阈值≥4分时阴性预测值0.901(95%置信区间0.867-0.935)。
临床怎么用
- 在资源有限环境中,电话问卷可用于诊断手术部位感染,避免面对面评估。
- 患者若在电话沟通后对伤口有任何担忧,仍应寻求医生或护士的帮助。
局限性
- 电话联系并非总能成功,90.3%(1196例中1088例)患者被成功联系到。
- 非中线切口患者较难通过电话联系到(调整比值比:0.36,95%置信区间0.17至0.73,P=0.005)。
- 面对面评估确诊手术部位感染的患者较难通过电话联系到(比值比:0.42,95%置信区间0.20至0.92,P=0.006)。
- 电话问卷并非始终完美,尤其对感染非常轻微的患者。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Telemedicine is being adopted for postoperative surveillance but requires evaluation for efficacy. This study tested a telephone Wound Healing Questionnaire (WHQ) to diagnose surgical site infection (SSI) after abdominal surgery in low- and middle-income countries. METHOD: A multi-centre, international, prospective study was embedded in the FALCON trial; a factorial RCT testing measures to reduce SSI in seven low- and middle-income countries (NCT03700749). It was conducted according to a pre-registered protocol (SWAT126) and reported according to STARD guidelines. The reference test was in-person review by a trained clinician at 30 postoperative days according to US Centres for Disease Control criteria. The index test was telephone administration of an adapted WHQ at 27 to 30 postoperative days by a researcher blinded to the outcome of in-person review. The sum of item response scores generated an overall score between 0 and 29. The primary outcome was the diagnostic accuracy of the WHQ, defined as the proportion of SSI correctly identified by the telephone WHQ, and summarized using the area under the receiving operator characteristic curve (AUROC) and diagnostic test accuracy statistics. RESULTS: Patients were included from three upper-middle income (396 patients, 13 hospitals), three lower-middle income (746 patients, 19 hospitals), and one low-income country (54 patients, 4 hospitals). 90.3% (1088 of 1196) patients were successfully contacted. Those with non-midline incisions (adjusted odds ratio: 0.36, 95% c.i. 0.17 to 0.73, P=0.005) or a confirmed diagnosis of SSI on in-person assessment (odds ratio: 0.42, 95% c.i. 0.20 to 0.92, P=0.006) were harder to reach. The questionnaire correctly discriminated between most patients with and without SSI (AUROC 0.869, 95% c.i. 0.824 to 0.914), which was consistent across subgroups. A representative cut-off score of ≥4 displayed a sensitivity of 0.701 (0.610-0.792), specificity of 0.911 (0.878-0.943), positive predictive value of 0.723 (0.633-0.814) and negative predictive value of 0.901 (0.867-0.935). CONCLUSION: SSI can be diagnosed using a telephone questionnaire (obviating in-person assessment) in low resource settings. A wound infection happens when germs enter the cut made in your body by a doctor when you are operated on. Germs are small organisms that cannot be seen by your eyes, but they can cause problems in the healing of the cut. Infection is the most common problem after surgery and can delay you getting out of hospital and back to normal life. The current way to check whether you have an infection is for a doctor or nurse to look at the cut made on your tummy and see how it is healing. For example, a doctor may check if the cut has a green liquid oozing from it or if the area of the wound is red or swollen. A month after you leave hospital, a doctor may ask you to come back for a follow-up visit. However, this will require you to travel to hospital and take a day off work or away from your family, and can be expensive and time-consuming if you travel far. We wanted to find out if talking to a doctor over the phone would work as well as you travelling to hospital to show the wound to a doctor or nurse in person. To do this, we asked over 1000 patients who had recently undergone surgery to be checked using both methods—to take a phone call from one doctor and be checked in person by a different doctor. We were able to compare the phone follow-up and in-person check to see if the doctors came to a different conclusion. We also looked at whether patients were able to receive a phone call at home and their experience of the process. For most patients, the phone call from a doctor was just as good at seeing if a patient had an infection as a face-to-face check-up by a doctor. However, the phone call was not perfect all the time, particularly for patients with very mild infections. Most patients were able to receive the phone call after a few tries and all patients were very happy with the process. As an international research team, we are now trying new ways to improve the phone call, including looking at the wound over video if possible. A phone call to check how your wound is healing can now be used as a substitute for a face-to-face check-up by a doctor. If you have any worries about your wound after the phone call you should still seek help from a doctor or nurse. We hope that the phone call will be more convenient for patients like you to avoid travelling back to hospital and taking time away from your work and family.
引用
- Accuracy of the Wound Healing Questionnaire in the diagnosis of surgical-site infection after abdominal surgery in low- and middle-income countries. Br J Surg. 2024. PMID: 38747515. doi:10.1093/bjs/znad446
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。