术后并发症『抢救失败』定义差异的系统综述及结局报告建议
该系统综述检索截至2022年12月31日的数据库,纳入359项报告术后抢救失败率的研究(共212,048,069例患者),分析抢救失败定义中分母并发症、分子死亡捕获比例及测量时点的差异。结果显示分母纳入并发症种类在295项研究(82%)中报告,共131种不同并发症,每项研究中位并发症数为10种(四分位距8-15),分母纳入并发症数越多的研究报告的抢救失败率越低;65项研究(18%)将死亡纳入分母并发症。当死亡未纳入分母时,抢救失败计算捕获死亡的中位百分比为79%。并发症(52%)和死亡率(40%)多在院内测量,其次为术后30天。结论指出抢救失败定义高度可变且报告不足,研究者应了解不同定义方法的优缺点。
要点
- 359项研究共212,048,069例患者,抢救失败定义中分母纳入的并发症共131种不同种类。
- 每项研究分母纳入并发症中位数为10种(四分位距8-15),纳入并发症数越多的研究报告抢救失败率越低。
- 65项研究(18%)将死亡纳入分母并发症;死亡未纳入分母时,抢救失败计算捕获死亡的中位百分比为79%。
核心结论
- 抢救失败是术后结局研究中的重要概念,但其定义高度可变且报告不足,研究者应了解不同定义方法的优缺点。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索数据库自建库至2022年12月31日,纳入所有将术后抢救失败率作为主要或次要结局报告的研究,共分析359项研究、212,048,069例患者。
主要发现
- 抢救失败分母纳入的并发症在295项研究(82%)中报告,共使用131种不同并发症,每项研究中位并发症数为10种(四分位距8-15)。
- 分母纳入并发症数越多的研究报告的抢救失败率越低。
- 65项研究(18%)将死亡纳入抢救失败分母并发症。
- 死亡未纳入分母时,抢救失败计算捕获死亡的中位百分比为79%。
- 并发症(52%)和死亡率(40%)多在院内测量,其次为术后30天。
关键数值与推荐
- 抢救失败分母纳入的并发症共131种不同种类,每项研究中位数为10种(四分位距8-15)。
- 死亡未纳入分母时,抢救失败计算捕获死亡的中位百分比为79%。
- 65项研究(18%)将死亡纳入分母并发症。
- 并发症(52%)和死亡率(40%)多在院内测量,其次为术后30天。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Failure to rescue is the rate of death amongst patients with postoperative complications and has been proposed as a perioperative quality indicator. However, variation in its definition has limited comparisons between studies. We systematically reviewed all surgical literature reporting failure to rescue rates and examined variations in the definition of the 'numerator,' 'denominator,' and timing of failure to rescue measurement. METHODS: Databases were searched from inception to 31 December 2022. All studies reporting postoperative failure to rescue rates as a primary or secondary outcome were included. We examined the complications included in the failure to rescue denominator, the percentage of deaths captured by the failure to rescue numerator, and the timing of measurement for complications and mortality. RESULTS: A total of 359 studies, including 212,048,069 patients, were analyzed. The complications included in the failure to rescue denominator were reported in 295 studies (82%), with 131 different complications used. The median number of included complications per study was 10 (interquartile range 8-15). Studies that included a higher number of complications in the failure-to-rescue denominator reported lower failure-to-rescue rates. Death was included as a complication in the failure to rescue the denominator in 65 studies (18%). The median percentage of deaths captured by the failure to rescue calculation when deaths were not included in the denominator was 79%. Complications (52%) and mortality (40%) were mostly measured in-hospital, followed by 30-days after surgery. CONCLUSION: Failure to rescue is an important concept in the study of postoperative outcomes, although its definition is highly variable and poorly reported. Researchers should be aware of the advantages and disadvantages of different approaches to defining failure to rescue.
引用
- Wells CI, Bhat S, Xu W, et al. Variation in the definition of 'failure to rescue' from postoperative complications: a systematic review and recommendations for outcome reporting. Surgery. 2024. PMID: 38245447. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2023.12.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。