医疗提供者对衰弱手术患者心肺复苏的看法
该研究对波士顿2家学术医疗中心的麻醉科医生(8名)、外科医生(10名)和老年科医生(9名)进行半结构化访谈,定性主题分析识别出5个主题:对衰弱手术患者围术期心肺复苏的看法因专业而异;判断是否适合心肺复苏通常涉及多因素;复苏有时伴随道德困扰;能力歧视和年龄歧视等偏见可能影响判断;指导风险分层的证据不足。结论认为不同专科医生对衰弱与围术期心肺复苏相关性的看法存在分歧,可能妨碍目标一致性医疗。
要点
- 不同专科医生对衰弱手术患者围术期心肺复苏的看法存在差异。
- 判断心肺复苏是否合适常涉及患者目标、年龄、合并症和骤停病因等多因素。
- 复苏过程中有时会出现道德困扰,且偏见可能影响判断。
核心结论
- 麻醉科医生、外科医生和老年科医生对衰弱与手术患者心肺复苏判断的相关性给出了不同描述。
- 对衰弱和围术期心肺复苏的看法分歧可能妨碍目标一致性医疗的实施,并提示需要研究以指导风险分层、预测以患者为中心的结局,以及理解年龄歧视和能力歧视等潜在偏见的作用。
研究设计与样本
- 对波士顿2家学术医疗中心中照护高风险手术患者的麻醉科医生(8名)、外科医生(10名)和老年科医生(9名)进行半结构化访谈,并对访谈转录稿进行定性主题分析。
主要发现
- 识别出5个主题:对衰弱患者围术期心肺复苏的看法因提供者专业而异;对衰弱手术患者心肺复苏合适性的判断通常涉及多因素,包括患者目标、年龄、合并症和骤停病因;衰弱患者的复苏有时与道德困扰相关;能力歧视和年龄歧视等偏见可能扭曲临床医生对衰弱患者围术期心肺复苏合适性的看法;指导衰弱患者围术期心肺复苏风险分层的证据不足。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To characterize the perceptions of surgeons, anesthesiologists, and geriatricians regarding perioperative cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) in surgical patients with frailty. BACKGROUND: The population of patients undergoing surgery is growing older and more frail. Despite a growing focus on goal-concordant care, frailty assessment, and debate regarding the appropriateness of CPR in patients with frailty, providers' views regarding frailty and perioperative CPR are unknown. METHODS: We performed qualitative thematic analysis of transcripts from semistructured interviews of anesthesiologists (8), surgeons (10), and geriatricians (9) who care for high-risk surgical patients at 2 academic medical centers in Boston, MA. The interview guide elicited clinicians' understanding of frailty, approach to decision-making regarding perioperative CPR, and perceptions of perioperative CPR in frail surgical patients. RESULTS: We identified 5 themes: (1) perceptions of perioperative CPR in patients with frailty vary by provider specialty, (2) judgments regarding the appropriateness of CPR in surgical patients with frailty are typically multifactorial and include patient goals, age, comorbidities, and arrest etiology, (3) resuscitation in patients with frailty is sometimes associated with moral distress, (4) biases, such as ableism and ageism, may skew clinicians' perceptions of the appropriateness of perioperative CPR in patients with frailty, and (5) evidence to guide risk stratification for patients with frailty undergoing perioperative CPR is inadequate. CONCLUSIONS: Anesthesiologists, surgeons, and geriatricians offer different accounts of frailty's relevance to judgments regarding CPR in surgical patients. Divergent views regarding frailty and perioperative CPR may impede efforts to deliver goal-concordant care and suggest a need for research to inform risk stratification, predict patient-centered outcomes, and understand the role of potential biases, such as ageism and ableism.
引用
- Allen MB, Reich AJ, Collins P, et al. Provider Perceptions Regarding Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in Surgical Patients With Frailty. Ann Surg. 2024. PMID: 38258581. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000006214
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。