急性阑尾炎:抗生素治疗联合主动观察与单纯主动观察的区组随机研究
在Sahlgrenska大学医院开展的区组随机研究,将126例急性阑尾炎患者按年龄和全身炎症状态分组,比较抗生素治疗联合主动观察与经典「观望等待」观察对阑尾切除需求的影响。结果显示抗生素组首次住院阑尾切除率为28%,对照组为53%(χ2,P < .004),随访期切除需求差异随时间变化(P < .03)。作者认为早期抗生素治疗在避免手术探查和阑尾切除方面优于传统观望等待。
要点
- 抗生素组首次住院阑尾切除率28%,对照组53%(χ2,P < .004)。
- 随访5至1200天期间,抗生素组手术探查和阑尾切除预防率为72%至50%,对照组为47%至37%。
- 作者认为早期抗生素治疗在避免手术探查和阑尾切除方面优于传统观望等待。
核心结论
- 早期抗生素治疗在避免手术探查和阑尾切除方面优于传统「观望等待」观察。
研究设计与样本
- 在Sahlgrenska大学医院开展区组随机研究,按年龄(18-60岁)和全身炎症(C反应蛋白<60 mg/L,白细胞<13,000/μL)联合急性阑尾炎临床和腹部特征进行区组随机。
- 研究组接受抗生素治疗和主动观察,对照组接受经典主动「观望等待」观察,由认证外科医生根据标准外科诊疗决定是否及何时行阑尾切除术。
- 共筛查1,019例患者,203例符合纳入标准,126例同意参与,29例拒绝,48例被漏纳入;抗生素组69例,对照组57例。
主要发现
- 抗生素组(n = 69)与对照组(n = 57)在纳入时基线可比。
- 首次住院期间阑尾切除率抗生素组为28%,对照组为53%(χ2,P < .004)。
- 生命表分析显示随访期间阑尾切除需求存在时间依赖性差异(P < .03)。
- 随访5至1200天期间,抗生素组手术探查和阑尾切除预防率为72%至50%,对照组为47%至37%。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Antibiotic treatment of unselected patients with acute appendicitis is safe and effective. However, it is unknown to what extent early provision of antibiotic treatment may represent overtreatment due to spontaneous healing of appendix inflammation. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the role of antibiotic treatment versus active in-hospital observation on spontaneous regression of acute appendicitis. METHOD: Patients who sought acute medical care at Sahlgrenska University Hospital were block-randomized according to age (18-60 years) and systemic inflammation (C-reactive protein <60 mg/L, white blood cell <13,000/μL), in combination with clinical and abdominal characteristics of acute appendicitis. Study patients received antibiotic treatment and active observation, while control patients were allocated to classic active "wait and see observation" for either disease regression or the need for surgical exploration. According to our standard surgical care, certified surgeons in charge decided whether and when appendectomy was necessary. In total, 1,019 patients were screened for eligibility; 203 patients met inclusion criteria, 126 were accepted to participate, 29 declined, and 48 were missed for inclusion. RESULTS: The antibiotic group (n = 69) and the control group (n = 57) were comparable at inclusion. Appendectomy at first hospital stay was 28% and 53% for study and control patients (χ2, P < .004). Life table analysis indicated a time-dependent difference in the need for appendectomy during follow-up (P < .03). Antibiotics prevented surgical exploration and appendectomy by 72% to 50% compared to 47% to 37% in the control group across the time course follow-ups between 5 and 1,200 days. CONCLUSION: Early antibiotic treatment is superior to traditional "wait and see observation" to avoid surgical exploration and appendectomy.
引用
- Iresjö BM, Blomström S, Engström C, et al. Acute appendicitis: A block-randomized study on active observation with or without antibiotic treatment. Surgery. 2024. PMID: 38218686. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2023.11.030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。