文献速递甲状腺与颈部外科围术期管理与 ERAS

甲状腺手术后医疗过失诉讼:哪些因素有利于外科医生

Malpractice litigation after thyroid surgery: What factors favor surgeons?
PubMed 文献 · Surgery · 2023-11-18

该研究检索Westlaw法律数据库1949年至2022年甲状腺切除术医疗过失诉讼案件,共纳入68例。医疗过失是最常见诉因,其次为知情同意不足;最常见诱发手术事件为喉返神经损伤(n=34,50%)。外科医生总体胜诉53例(77.9%),学术机构12例中胜诉11例(91.7%),3名内分泌外科专科培训医生均胜诉。

要点

  • 医疗过失是甲状腺切除术诉讼最常见诉因,其次为知情同意不足。
  • 喉返神经损伤是最常见诱发手术事件,占34例(50%)。
  • 外科医生总体胜诉53例(77.9%),学术机构病例胜诉11/12(91.7%)。

核心结论

  • 非陪审团案件和学术机构手术似乎有利于被告判决。
  • 尽管无统计学显著性,所有内分泌外科专科培训的被告均胜诉。
  • 在有侵权改革的州,外科医生倾向于胜诉。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究检索Westlaw法律数据库,使用「甲状腺切除术」和「医疗过失」检索词,识别1949年至2022年针对外科医生的医疗过失案件。
  • 共纳入68例案件,收集并分析人口学、临床、手术和法学数据。

主要发现

  • 医疗过失是最常见诉因,其次为未能提供充分知情同意。
  • 最常见诱发手术事件为喉返神经损伤(n=34,50%)。
  • 外科医生总体胜诉53例(77.9%),学术机构治疗的12例中胜诉11例(91.7%)。
  • 3名内分泌外科专科培训的外科医生在其案件中均胜诉。
  • 患者胜诉的15例中,12例(80%)由陪审团裁定,裁定损害赔偿中位数为569,668美元(四分位距341,146-2,594,050美元)。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Litigation impacts physicians financially, reputationally, and professionally. Although thyroid surgery has favorable patient outcomes, litigation persists. We aimed to characterize malpractice claims after thyroidectomy and investigate which factors favor physicians. METHODS: We queried the Westlaw legal database using the terms "thyroidectomy" and "medical malpractice" to identify malpractice cases brought against surgeons from 1949 to 2022. We collected and analyzed demographic; clinical; surgical; and legal data, including year, cause for initiating litigation, verdict, state where the lawsuit was brought, and the state's tort reform status. RESULTS: Of the 68 cases included, medical negligence was the most common cause of action, followed by failure to provide adequate informed consent. The most common inciting surgical event was recurrent laryngeal nerve injury (n = 34, 50%). Surgeons prevailed more often overall (n = 53, 77.9%) and in 11 (91.7%) of the 12 cases treated at academic institutions. The 3 endocrine surgery fellowship-trained surgeons all prevailed in their cases. Of the 15 cases in which patients prevailed, 12 (80%) of which were decided by a jury, the median damages awarded were $569,668 (interquartile range $341,146-$2,594,050). In the 53 cases won by surgeons, 26 were jury decisions (49.1%). Surgeons prevailed in 87.5% of cases brought in the 24 states with tort reform and in 72.7% in the 44 states without tort reform. CONCLUSION: Non-jury cases and operations done at academic institutions appear to favor decisions for the defendant. Although not statistically significant, all endocrine surgery fellowship-trained defendants won. Where tort reforms are in place, surgeons tend to prevail.

来源:Surgery,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chao JC, Kheng M, Manzella A, et al. Malpractice litigation after thyroid surgery: What factors favor surgeons? Surgery. 2023. PMID: 37985316. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2023.04.071

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。