EAES多学科快速指南:食管旁疝外科管理的系统评价、Meta分析、GRADE评估与循证推荐
欧洲内镜外科协会多学科专家组基于三项系统评价和GRADE方法,针对成人中大型(II–IV型、至少50%胃疝入胸腔)食管旁疝制定循证推荐。推荐对体弱无症状/轻微症状患者保守优于手术(强推荐),对非体弱同类患者建议手术优于保守(条件推荐);并分别就补片与缝线、胃底折叠与胃固定、急诊胃固定与胃底折叠给出条件推荐。
要点
- 对体弱无症状/轻微症状食管旁疝,推荐保守管理优于手术(强推荐)。
- 对非体弱无症状/轻微症状食管旁疝,建议手术优于保守管理(条件推荐)。
- 择期修补建议补片优于缝线关闭裂孔、胃底折叠优于胃固定(条件推荐)。
核心结论
- 多学科专家组采用最高方法学标准和透明流程,就食管旁疝管理的关键议题提供推荐。
研究设计与样本
- 欧洲内镜外科协会成员优先将食管旁疝管理纳入推荐议题,由指南国际网络认证的指南制定专家主持。
- 开展三项系统评价,采用GRADE方法总结与评价证据确定性。
- 由普通外科与上消化道外科医生、消化内科医生及一名患者代表组成的专家组在共识会议形成推荐,随后进行改良德尔菲调查。
主要发现
- 对无症状/轻微症状食管旁疝,专家组建议手术优于保守管理(条件推荐)。
- 对体弱无症状/轻微症状食管旁疝,推荐保守管理优于手术(强推荐)。
- 食管旁疝修补中裂孔关闭,专家组建议补片优于缝线(条件推荐)。
- 择期食管旁疝修补,专家组建议胃底折叠优于胃固定(条件推荐)。
- 对需急诊食管旁疝修补且存在心肺不稳定的患者,专家组建议胃固定优于胃底折叠(条件推荐)。
关键数值与推荐
- 强推荐意指所提议的措施适用于绝大多数患者。
- 条件推荐意指多数患者会选择所提议的措施,需外科医生与患者共同决策。
- 本指南适用于II至IV型中大型食管旁疝且至少50%胃疝入胸腔的成人患者。
- 使用推荐时应同时阅读配套证据摘要与证据至决策框架。
临床怎么用
- 对体弱无症状/轻微症状食管旁疝患者,按强推荐选择保守管理优于手术。
- 对非体弱无症状/轻微症状患者,按条件推荐经共同决策后建议手术优于保守管理。
- 裂孔关闭时按条件推荐建议补片优于缝线;择期修补建议胃底折叠优于胃固定。
- 急诊修补且心肺不稳定者,按条件推荐建议胃固定优于胃底折叠。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: New evidence has emerged since latest guidelines on the management of paraesophageal hernia, and guideline development methodology has evolved. Members of the European Association for Endoscopic Surgery have prioritized the management of paraesophageal hernia to be addressed by pertinent recommendations. OBJECTIVE: To develop evidence-informed clinical practice recommendations on paraesophageal hernias, through evidence synthesis and a structured evidence-to-decision framework by an interdisciplinary panel of stakeholders. METHODS: We performed three systematic reviews, and we summarized and appraised the certainty of the evidence using the GRADE methodology. A panel of general and upper gastrointestinal surgeons, gastroenterologists and a patient advocate discussed the evidence in the context of benefits and harms, the certainty of the evidence, acceptability, feasibility, equity, cost and use of resources, moderated by a Guidelines International Network-certified master guideline developer and chair. We developed the recommendations in a consensus meeting, followed by a modified Delphi survey. RESULTS: The panel suggests surgery over conservative management for asymptomatic/minimally symptomatic paraesophageal hernias (conditional recommendation), and recommends conservative management over surgery for asymptomatic/minimally symptomatic paraesophageal hernias in frail patients (strong recommendation). Further, the panel suggests mesh over sutures for hiatal closure in paraesophageal hernia repair, fundoplication over gastropexy in elective paraesophageal hernia repair, and gastropexy over fundoplication in patients who have cardiopulmonary instability and require emergency paraesophageal hernia repair (conditional recommendation). A strong recommendation means that the proposed course of action is appropriate for the vast majority of patients. A conditional recommendation means that most patients would opt for the proposed course of action, and joint decision-making of the surgeon and the patient is required. Accompanying evidence summaries and evidence-to-decision frameworks should be read when using the recommendations. This guideline applies to adult patients with moderate to large paraesophageal hernias type II to IV with at least 50% of the stomach herniated to the thoracic cavity. The full guideline with user-friendly decision aids is available in https://app.magicapp.org/#/guideline/j7q7Gn . CONCLUSION: An interdisciplinary panel provides recommendations on key topics on the management of paraesophageal hernias using highest methodological standards and following a transparent process. GUIDELINE REGISTRATION NUMBER: PREPARE-2023CN018.
引用
- Markar SR, Menon N, Guidozzi N, et al. EAES Multidisciplinary Rapid Guideline: systematic review, meta-analysis, GRADE assessment and evidence-informed recommendations on the surgical management of paraesophageal hernias. Surg Endosc. 2023. PMID: 37910246. doi:10.1007/s00464-023-10511-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。