SAGES腹膜透析通路指南2023年更新
美国胃肠道与内镜外科医师学会指南委员会系统回顾2014年指南发布以来的文献,在成人提出7个、儿童提出4个关键问题,采用GRADE方法制定12条推荐,涉及腹腔镜腹膜透析置管围术期实施及导管功能障碍处理。
要点
- 成人:条件推荐分期疝修补后置管优于同期;医学可行时传统起始优于紧急起始。
- 成人:建议(弱推荐)先进腹腔镜置管而非基础腹腔镜或开放置管。
- 儿童:条件推荐传统或紧急起始均可,同期清洁或清洁-污染手术并置管优于分期。
核心结论
- 成人条件推荐支持分期疝修补后腹膜透析置管优于同期置管,以及医学可行时传统起始优于紧急起始。
- 成人条件推荐支持先进腹腔镜置管而非基础腹腔镜或开放置管,并条件推荐先进腹腔镜或影像引导经皮置管均可、非手术或手术挽救均可。
- 成人未就同期清洁-污染手术作出推荐;儿童条件推荐传统或紧急起始均可、同期清洁或清洁-污染手术并置管优于分期、先进腹腔镜置管优于基础或开放置管。
研究设计与样本
- 美国胃肠道与内镜外科医师学会(SAGES)指南委员会小组回顾2014年 prior 指南发布以来的文献。
- 在成人提出7个关键问题、儿童提出4个关键问题,系统综述后采用GRADE方法制定循证推荐。
主要发现
- 经系统综述、数据提取和证据到决策会议,小组就腹腔镜腹膜透析置管围术期实施及导管功能障碍管理达成12条推荐。
- 成人条件推荐:分期疝修补后置管优于同期置管;医学可行时传统起始优于紧急起始。
- 成人建议(弱推荐)先进腹腔镜置管技术而非基础腹腔镜或开放置管。
- 成人条件推荐先进腹腔镜或影像引导经皮置管均可,非手术或手术挽救均可。
- 儿童条件推荐传统或紧急起始均可、同期清洁或清洁-污染手术并置管优于分期、先进腹腔镜置管优于基础或开放置管。
关键数值与推荐
- 成人条件推荐:分期疝修补后腹膜透析置管优于同期置管。
- 成人条件推荐:医学可行时传统起始优于紧急起始。
- 成人建议(弱推荐):先进腹腔镜置管而非基础腹腔镜或开放置管。
- 成人条件推荐:先进腹腔镜或影像引导经皮置管均可;非手术或手术挽救均可。
- 儿童条件推荐:传统或紧急起始均可;同期清洁或清洁-污染手术并置管优于分期;先进腹腔镜置管优于基础或开放置管。
临床怎么用
- 成人腹膜透析置管可考虑分期疝修补后置管而非同期置管(条件推荐)。
- 成人医学可行时传统起始优于紧急起始(条件推荐)。
- 成人置管建议(弱推荐)采用先进腹腔镜技术而非基础腹腔镜或开放置管。
- 成人可考虑先进腹腔镜或影像引导经皮置管,非手术或手术挽救均可(条件推荐)。
- 儿童可考虑传统或紧急起始、同期清洁或清洁-污染手术并置管、先进腹腔镜置管(条件推荐)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Minimally invasive surgery has been used for both de novo insertion and salvage of peritoneal dialysis (PD) catheters. Advanced laparoscopic, basic laparoscopic, open, and image-guided techniques have evolved as the most popular techniques. The aim of this guideline was to develop evidence-based guidelines that support surgeons, patients, and other physicians in decisions on minimally invasive peritoneal dialysis access and the salvage of malfunctioning catheters in both adults and children. METHODS: A guidelines committee panel of the Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic Surgeons reviewed the literature since the prior guideline was published in 2014 and developed seven key questions in adults and four in children. After a systematic review of the literature, by the panel, evidence-based recommendations were formulated using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation approach. Recommendations for future research were also proposed. RESULTS: After systematic review, data extraction, and evidence to decision meetings, the panel agreed on twelve recommendations for the peri-operative performance of laparoscopic peritoneal dialysis access surgery and management of catheter dysfunction. CONCLUSIONS: In the adult population, conditional recommendations were made in favor of: staged hernia repair followed by PD catheter insertion over simultaneous and traditional start over urgent start of PD when medically possible. Furthermore, the panel suggested advanced laparoscopic insertion techniques rather than basic laparoscopic techniques or open insertion. Conditional recommendations were made for either advanced laparoscopic or image-guided percutaneous insertion and for either nonoperative or operative salvage. A recommendation could not be made regarding concomitant clean-contaminated surgery in adults. In the pediatric population, conditional recommendations were made for either traditional or urgent start of PD, concomitant clean or clean-contaminated surgery and PD catheter placement rather than staged, and advanced laparoscopic placement rather than basic or open insertion.
引用
- Haggerty SP, Kumar SS, Collings AT, et al. SAGES peritoneal dialysis access guideline update 2023. Surg Endosc. 2023. PMID: 37989887. doi:10.1007/s00464-023-10550-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。