2010至2021年微创外科专科培训中机器人手术经验的表征分析
基于2010至2021年Fellowship Council的去标识病例日志,评估微创外科专科培训中机器人手术占比及变化趋势。结果显示有机器人平台的培训项目从45.1%(51/113)增至90.4%(123/136),机器人病例占比从2.0%(1127/56,033)升至23.2%(16,139/69,496),每名学员机器人病例中位数从0(0-6)例增至72.5(17.8-171.5)例(p<0.01)。
要点
- 有机器人平台的微创外科专科培训项目从45.1%(51/113)增至90.4%(123/136)。
- 机器人病例占比从2.0%(1127/56,033)升至23.2%(16,139/69,496),腹腔镜病例从80.2%降至65.3%。
- 每名微创外科专科培训学员机器人病例中位数从0(0-6)例增至72.5(17.8-171.5)例(p<0.01)。
核心结论
- 过去十年微创外科专科培训中机器人使用大幅增长,但腹腔镜和开放手术经验仍保持充足。
- 机器人培训病例存在不均衡,最繁忙的50%机器人项目完成了超过90%的机器人培训病例。
研究设计与样本
- 研究评估了2010至2021年Fellowship Council的去标识病例日志数据。
- 按手术类别(如减重、疝、前肠)分层分析机器人经验随时间的变化,并按机器人使用百分比将项目分层分析各四分位内的经验变化。
主要发现
- 有机器人平台的微创外科专科培训项目从45.1%(51/113)增至90.4%(123/136)。
- 机器人病例占比从2.0%(1127/56,033)增至23.2%(16,139/69,496),腹腔镜病例从80.2%(44,954/56,033)降至65.3%(45,356/69,496)。
- 疝和结直肠类别机器人使用增幅最大:疝从0.7%(62/8614)增至38.4%(4661/12,135),结直肠从4.2%(116/2747)增至31.8%(666/2094)。
- 按机器人使用百分比分层,当前(2020-2021)项目位于>95百分位的项目完成了21.8%(3523/16,139)的机器人手术,位于>50百分位的项目完成了90.0%(14,533/16,139)的机器人病例。
- 每名微创外科专科培训学员机器人病例中位数从2010年的0(0-6)例显著增至2021年的72.5(17.8-171.5)例(p<0.01)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
- 原文结论指出微创外科项目经验差异很大,学员应仔细查看项目病例日志以确认兴趣匹配。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Robotic surgery has experienced exponential growth in the past decade. Few studies have evaluated the impact of robotics within minimally invasive surgery (MIS) fellowship training programs. The purpose of our study was to examine and characterize recent trends in robotic surgery within MIS fellowship training programs. METHODS: De-identified case log data from the Fellowship Council from 2010 to 2021 were evaluated. Percentage of operations performed with robot assistance over time was assessed and compared to the laparoscopic and open experience. Case logs were further stratified by operative category (e.g., bariatric, hernia, foregut), and robotic experience over time was evaluated for each category. Programs were stratified by percent robot use and the experience over time within each quartile was evaluated. RESULTS: MIS fellowship training programs with a robotic platform increased from 45.1% (51/113) to 90.4% (123/136) over the study period. The percentage of robotic cases increased from 2.0% (1127/56,033) to 23.2% (16,139/69,496) while laparoscopic cases decreased from 80.2% (44,954/56,033) to 65.3% (45,356/69,496). Hernia and colorectal case categories had the largest increase in robot usage [hernia: 0.7% (62/8614) to 38.4% (4661/12,135); colorectal 4.2% (116/2747) to 31.8% (666/2094)]. When stratified by percentage of robot utilization, current (2020-2021) programs in the > 95th percentile performed 21.8% (3523/16,139) of robotic operations and programs in the > 50th percentile performed 90.0% (14,533/16,139) of all robotic cases. The median number of robotic cases performed per MIS fellow significantly increased from 2010 to 2021 [0 (0-6) to 72.5 (17.8-171.5), p < 0.01]. CONCLUSIONS: Robotic use in MIS fellowship training programs has grown substantially in the past decade, but the laparoscopic and open experience remains robust. There remains an imbalance with the top 50% of busiest robotic programs performing over 90% of robot trainee cases. The experience in MIS programs varies widely and trainees should examine program case logs closely to confirm parallel interests.
引用
- Haywood N, Scott J, Zhang A, et al. Characterization of the robotic surgery experience in minimally invasive surgery fellowships from 2010 to 2021. Surg Endosc. 2023. PMID: 37658200. doi:10.1007/s00464-023-10402-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。