患者对乳房切除术后乳房重建的偏好
该网络横断面研究采用自适应选择联合分析,纳入406名考虑乳房切除后重建的女性,评估重建属性重要性。腹部并发症风险最重要(相对重要性28%),其次为主要并发症风险(25%)和额外手术次数(23%);多数参与者(85%)偏好植入物重建。未来研究应评估决策辅助工具如何帮助个体化术前咨询。
要点
- 腹部并发症风险是考虑乳房重建女性最看重的属性(相对重要性28%)。
- 85%的参与者偏好植入物重建,其最看重腹部并发症风险(30%)。
- 偏好皮瓣重建者最看重额外手术次数(31%)和乳房外观(27%)。
核心结论
- 本研究提供了女性在乳房重建决策中如何权衡不同方面的信息。
- 未来研究应评估引出个体层面偏好的决策辅助工具如何帮助调整医患讨论,将术前咨询聚焦于对每位患者最重要的因素,并最终改善以患者为中心的照护。
研究设计与样本
- 网络横断面研究,采用自适应选择联合分析(ACBC)。
- 研究于2022年3月1日至2023年1月31日在杜克大学开展,并于2022年6月1日至12月31日通过Love Research Army注册库开展。
- 参与者包括105名杜克大学新诊断或遗传易感乳腺癌并考虑乳房切除后重建的女性,以及301名通过Love Research Army注册库识别的有乳腺癌病史或遗传易感的女性。
- 共406名女性参与:杜克大学105名(平均年龄46.3岁,标准差10.5),Love Research Army注册库301名(平均年龄59.2岁,标准差11.9)。
主要发现
- 整体认为最重要的属性是腹部并发症风险(平均相对重要性28%,标准差11%),其次为主要并发症风险(25%,标准差10%)、额外手术次数(23%,标准差12%)、乳房外观(13%,标准差12%)和恢复时间(11%,标准差7%)。
- 多数参与者(344名,85%)偏好植入物重建,这些参与者最关心腹部并发症风险(平均相对重要性30%,标准差11%),其次为并发症风险(26%,标准差11%)和额外手术次数(21%,标准差12%)。
- 偏好皮瓣重建的参与者最关心额外手术次数(平均相对重要性31%,标准差15%)、乳房外观(27%,标准差16%)和并发症风险(18%,标准差6%)。
- 选择皮瓣重建的独立相关因素包括已婚(比值比2.30,95%置信区间1.04-5.08;P=0.04)和较高教育水平(大学教育;比值比2.43,95%置信区间1.01-5.86;P=0.048),而收入水平大于75,000美元与选择皮瓣方案的可能性降低相关(比值比0.45,95%置信区间0.21-0.97;P=0.01)。
- 偏好皮瓣外观的应答者愿意接受腹部并发症风险平均增加14.9%(标准差2.2%;n=113)或并发症风险平均增加6.4%(标准差4.8%;n=115)。
关键数值与推荐
- 整体相对重要性:腹部并发症风险28%(标准差11%),主要并发症风险25%(标准差10%),额外手术次数23%(标准差12%),乳房外观13%(标准差12%),恢复时间11%(标准差7%)。
- 偏好植入物重建者(n=344,85%)相对重要性:腹部并发症风险30%(标准差11%),并发症风险26%(标准差11%),额外手术次数21%(标准差12%)。
- 偏好皮瓣重建者相对重要性:额外手术次数31%(标准差15%),乳房外观27%(标准差16%),并发症风险18%(标准差6%)。
- 选择皮瓣重建的比值比:已婚2.30(95%置信区间1.04-5.08;P=0.04),大学教育2.43(95%置信区间1.01-5.86;P=0.048),收入大于75,000美元0.45(95%置信区间0.21-0.97;P=0.01)。
- 偏好皮瓣外观者愿意接受腹部并发症风险平均增加14.9%(标准差2.2%;n=113)或并发症风险平均增加6.4%(标准差4.8%;n=115)。
临床怎么用
- 本研究结果可用于帮助临床医生在术前咨询中聚焦对每位患者最重要的因素,以改善共享决策和以患者为中心的照护。
- 原文未据此给出具体推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Up to 40% of women experience dissatisfaction after breast reconstruction due to unexpected outcomes that are poorly aligned with personal preferences. Identifying what attributes patients value when considering surgery could improve shared decision-making. Adaptive choice-based conjoint (ACBC) analysis can elicit individual-level treatment preferences. OBJECTIVES: To identify which attributes of breast reconstruction are most important to women considering surgery and to describe how these attributes differ by those who prefer flap vs implant reconstruction. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This web-based, cross-sectional study was conducted from March 1, 2022, to January 31, 2023, at Duke University and between June 1 and December 31, 2022, through the Love Research Army with ACBC analysis. Participants were 105 women at Duke University with a new diagnosis of or genetic predisposition to breast cancer who were considering mastectomy with reconstruction and 301 women with a history of breast cancer or a genetic predisposition as identified through the Love Research Army registry. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Relative importance scores, part-worth utility values, and maximum acceptable risks were estimated. RESULTS: Overall, 406 women (105 from Duke University [mean (SD) age, 46.3 (10.5) years] and 301 from the Love Research Army registry [mean (SD) age, 59.2 (11.9) years]) participated. The attribute considered most important was the risk of abdominal morbidity (mean [SD] relative importance [RI], 28% [11%]), followed by chance of major complications (RI, 25% [10%]), number of additional operations (RI, 23% [12%]), appearance of the breasts (RI, 13% [12%]), and recovery time (RI, 11% [7%]). Most participants (344 [85%]) preferred implant-based reconstruction; these participants cared most about abdominal morbidity (mean [SD] RI, 30% [11%]), followed by the risk of complications (mean [SD], RI, 26% [11%]) and additional operations (mean [SD] RI, 21% [12%]). In contrast, participants who preferred flap reconstruction cared most about additional operations (mean [SD] RI, 31% [15%]), appearance of the breasts (mean [SD] RI, 27% [16%]), and risk of complications (mean [SD] RI, 18% [6%]). Factors independently associated with choosing flap reconstruction included being married (odds ratio [OR], 2.30 [95% CI, 1.04-5.08]; P = .04) and higher educational level (college education; OR, 2.43 [95% CI, 1.01-5.86]; P = .048), while having an income level of greater than $75 000 was associated with a decreased likelihood of choosing the flap profile (OR, 0.45 [95% CI, 0.21-0.97]; P = .01). Respondents who preferred flap appearance were willing to accept a mean (SD) increase of 14.9% (2.2%) chance of abdominal morbidity (n = 113) or 6.4% (4.8%) chance of complications (n = 115). CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: This study provides information on how women value different aspects of their care when making decisions for breast reconstruction. Future studies should assess how decision aids that elicit individual-level preferences can help tailor patient-physician discussions to focus preoperative counseling on factors that matter most to each patient and ultimately improve patient-centered care.
引用
- Shammas RL, Hung A, Mullikin A, et al. Patient Preferences for Postmastectomy Breast Reconstruction. JAMA Surg. 2023. PMID: 37755818. doi:10.1001/jamasurg.2023.4432
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。