文献速递围术期管理与 ERAS急腹症与外科感染

风险调整累积和用于早期识别围术期死亡率过高的医院

Risk-Adjusted Cumulative Sum for Early Detection of Hospitals With Excess Perioperative Mortality.
PubMed 文献 · JAMA Surg · 2023-01-01

该全国性观察性医院层面比较效果研究纳入697 566例在退伍军人事务部医院接受非心脏手术的患者,比较风险调整累积和(CUSUM)与季度观察值与预期值比值(O/E)对围术期死亡率过高医院的早期识别能力。CUSUM可在O/E报告前中位49天识别异常医院,且CUSUM信号数量与O/E比值呈剂量反应关系,提示持续性能评估工具应被国家质量改进项目采用。

要点

  • CUSUM较季度O/E报告中位提前49天识别围术期死亡率过高的医院。
  • 季度内至少1个CUSUM信号识别异常医院的频率为33.3%,高于O/E比值的11.0%。
  • CUSUM信号数量与中位O/E比值呈剂量反应关系(0信号0.63至≥4信号2.49,趋势检验P<.001)。

核心结论

  • CUSUM可在标准季度末报告之前很早就识别围术期死亡率过高的医院,提示间歇性评估策略未能发现失控过程并使患者处于风险之中。
  • 作者建议国家质量改进项目应采用持续性能评估工具以预防可避免的患者伤害。

研究设计与样本

  • 全国性、观察性、医院层面比较效果研究,纳入697 566例患者。
  • 患者为2011年1月1日至2016年12月31日在退伍军人事务部医院接受非心脏手术、年龄18岁及以上且有退伍军人事务部外科质量改进项目记录者。
  • 比较风险调整CUSUM与现行标准(季度30天风险调整死亡率O/E比值)识别死亡率过高医院的效果。

主要发现

  • 队列纳入104家医院24个季度的697 566例患者,平均(SD)年龄60.9(13.2)岁,男性91.4%,女性8.6%。
  • 每家医院被O/E比值、至少1个CUSUM信号、超过1个CUSUM信号检出的季度数中位数分别为2个季度(IQR 1-4)、8个季度(IQR 4-11)、3个季度(IQR 1-4)。
  • 在2496个总季度中,至少1个CUSUM信号识别异常医院的频率为33.3%(830个季度),超过1个CUSUM信号为12.5%(311个季度),季度末O/E比值为11.0%(274个季度)。
  • CUSUM检测较O/E报告中位提前49天(IQR 25-63天);1个信号提前35天(IQR 17-54天),2个信号提前49天(IQR 26-61天),3个信号提前58天(IQR 44-69天),≥4个信号提前49天(IQR 42-69天),趋势检验P<.001。
  • 274个被O/E比值检测到的医院季度中,72.6%(199)被至少1个CUSUM信号同时检测到,42.7%(117)被超过1个CUSUM信号同时检测到。

临床怎么用

  • 原文结论认为CUSUM可在标准季度末报告前很早就识别围术期死亡率过高的医院,并建议国家质量改进项目采用持续性能评估工具以预防可避免的患者伤害。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

IMPORTANCE: National surgical quality improvement programs lack tools for early detection of quality or safety concerns, which risks patient safety because of delayed recognition of poor performance. OBJECTIVE: To compare the risk-adjusted cumulative sum (CUSUM) with episodic evaluation for early detection of hospitals with excess perioperative mortality. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: National, observational, hospital-level, comparative effectiveness study of 697 566 patients. Identification of hospitals with excess, risk-adjusted, quarterly 30-day mortality using observed to expected ratios (ie, current criterion standard in the Veterans Affairs Surgical Quality Improvement Program) was compared with the risk-adjusted CUSUM. Patients included in the study underwent a noncardiac operation at a Veterans Affairs hospital, had a record in the Veterans Affairs Surgical Quality Improvement Program (January 1, 2011, through December 31, 2016), and were aged 18 years or older. MAIN OUTCOME AND MEASURE: Number of hospitals identified as having excess risk-adjusted 30-day mortality. RESULTS: The cohort included 697 566 patients treated at 104 hospitals across 24 quarters. The mean (SD) age was 60.9 (13.2) years, 91.4% were male, and 8.6% were female. For each hospital, the median number of quarters detected with observed to expected ratios, at least 1 CUSUM signal, and more than 1 CUSUM signal was 2 quarters (IQR, 1-4 quarters), 8 quarters (IQR, 4-11 quarters), and 3 quarters (IQR, 1-4 quarters), respectively. During 2496 total quarters of data, outlier hospitals were identified 33.3% of the time (830 quarters) with at least 1 CUSUM signal within a quarter, 12.5% (311 quarters) with more than 1 CUSUM signal, and 11.0% (274 quarters) with observed to expected ratios at the end of the quarter. The CUSUM detection occurred a median of 49 days (IQR, 25-63 days) before observed to expected ratio reporting (1 signal, 35 days [IQR, 17-54 days]; 2 signals, 49 days [IQR, 26-61 days]; 3 signals, 58 days [IQR, 44-69 days]; ≥4 signals, 49 days [IQR, 42-69 days]; trend test, P < .001). Of 274 hospital quarters detected with observed to expected ratios, 72.6% (199) were concurrently detected by at least 1 CUSUM signal vs 42.7% (117) by more than 1 CUSUM signal. There was a dose-response relationship between the number of CUSUM signals in a quarter and the median observed to expected ratio (0 signals, 0.63; 1 signal, 1.28; 2 signals, 1.58; 3 signals, 2.08; ≥4 signals, 2.49; trend test, P < .001). CONCLUSIONS: This study found that with CUSUM, hospitals with excess perioperative mortality can be identified well in advance of standard end-of-quarter reporting, which suggests episodic evaluation strategies fail to detect out-of-control processes and place patients at risk. Continuous performance evaluation tools should be adopted in national quality improvement programs to prevent avoidable patient harm.

来源:JAMA Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chen VW, Chidi AP, Dong Y, et al. Risk-Adjusted Cumulative Sum for Early Detection of Hospitals With Excess Perioperative Mortality. JAMA Surg. 2023. PMID: 37610743. doi:10.1001/jamasurg.2023.3673

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。